Skip to contentSkip to conversation

freebox possible GPL violation

DISCUSSION Pierre Michon 4 participants 4 messages Oct 6, 2005

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

Quoted 3 lines

I might have misunderstood but I think that if you buy the hardware you cannot connect it to the DSLAM network anymore. So that only the boxes they own are connected to the DSLAM.

Again have you any proof that there aren't any Linux firmware in the flash of the freebox ?
How do you explain that the boot sequence isn't stateless ? Why in case of a firmware update, you have a special state of 10 seconds were the freebox seem to download and write some data somewhere ?

So yes may be you can't connect anymore to the free DSLAM, but there is may be still GPL data in the flash.

Quoted 2 lines

Are you sure this point has been clarified in court in the past ? If not, I would bet on it (for the specific case of settop boxes).

For french law I don't know, but someone on gpl-violation this is true for de and au.

Quoted 5 lines

I mentioned in another mail the case of a mobile phone network infrastructure where the network nodes to which mobile phones are connecting are running Linux. It seems to be an "internal use" (as it never leak out of the company network) and yet providing a service to customers.

No the freebox is more like a dvb box that is lended by a satellite provider and could do firmware update via satellite.

I don't know if there are similar case for dvb box.

Pierre

#1 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Pierre Michon
Quoted 4 lines

I might have misunderstood but I think that if you buy the hardware you cannot connect it to the DSLAM network anymore. So that only the boxes they own are connected to the DSLAM.

Again have you any proof that there aren't any Linux firmware in the flash of the freebox ?

Helloooo !!! Have you proofs that they have ???

You're always assuming the worst from Free, this is really starting to be annoying. Just stick to the FACTS and if you want to argue on something, bring PROOFS !

And even if it was the case, you missed the point here, if they own the Freebox their point is that they are using Linux for "internal use" only.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Are you sure this point has been clarified in court in the past ? If not, I would bet on it (for the specific case of settop boxes).

For french law I don't know, but someone on gpl-violation this is true for de and au.

Nonsense, you are talking about cases of softwares which were sold to customers with GPL code inside. This is no such case here.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines

I mentioned in another mail the case of a mobile phone network infrastructure where the network nodes to which mobile phones are connecting are running Linux. It seems to be an "internal use" (as it never leak out of the company network) and yet providing a service to customers.

No the freebox is more like a dvb box that is lended by a satellite provider and could do firmware update via satellite.

I don't know if there are similar case for dvb box.

You obviously need a brain, try to get one and come back after you learned to use it.

Regards

Signature · 4 lines
Emmanuel Fleury

Shut up and hack !
  -- Theo de Raadt (OpenBSD Hackaton)
#2 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Emmanuel Fleury
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Are you sure this point has been clarified in court in the past ? If not, I would bet on it (for the specific case of settop boxes).

For french law I don't know, but someone on gpl-violation this is true for de and au.

Nonsense, you are talking about cases of softwares which were sold to customers with GPL code inside. This is no such case here.

In the US, the law (17 USC 106) is very clear that renting, lending, and leasing are "distribution" that is a protected right. The Berne Convention says the same in article 11bis (remember that a later revision explicitly included computer programs in "literary works"). Do you think this interpretation of "distribution" does not apply to Free? If not, why not?

Michael Poole

#3 lore raw

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Quoted 6 lines · Michael Poole

In the US, the law (17 USC 106) is very clear that renting, lending, and leasing are "distribution" that is a protected right. The Berne Convention says the same in article 11bis (remember that a later revision explicitly included computer programs in "literary works"). Do you think this interpretation of "distribution" does not apply to Free? If not, why not?

The argument seems to be that you're paying for the service, and not the box, and that the box is owned by Free and therefore no distribution occurs here, as the kernel moves from Free to Free.

The obvious example is web servers, where you aren't distributing anything (at least not the server software) and still providing service.

The difference here is that the box is physically at the customer's house, which could be considered "lending", but IANAL.

Anyway, I guess you'll have to ask a (preferably French) lawyer to find out.

BTW, the whole thing about the kernel being in ROM or RAM or whatever and how it got there are moot - its still running Linux. And if lending is distribution, then they need to offer the source code.

FYI: Needing to reboot to change firmware makes sense, and those 10 extra seconds might involve upgrading the proprietary firmware... But thats irrelevant.

- --

[Name      ]   ::  [Matan I. Peled    ]
[Location  ]   ::  [Israel            ]
[Public Key]   ::  [0xD6F42CA5        ]
[Keyserver ]   ::  [keyserver.kjsl.com]

encrypted/signed plain text preferred

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFDRTlGA7Qvptb0LKURAs9iAJ9NKgLPDkUl/BBeAMJBot0PGzIDBwCfY/SS pxRwgjqVPlasdIPTG/kvp6U=
=uAEf
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----