OSDL and the Linux kernel community
I've just read about Greg Kroah-Hartman (one of the 17 kernel developers) proposal about what OSDL could do to improve the kernel work. As a none-kernel developer I think it's important to look closer at some of the issues.
First I have to mention that the kernel is an important but only _one_ part of a Linux system a user may buy in a shop. There are many more parts which have to fit in until a system is bought. IMO the OSDL's task is to care for all of these parts, not only at the kernel. Nobody will buy a computer if it only has a superb kernel but the rest doesn't fit equally well.
Second the breakthrough of the Linux desktop system has been predicted so many years, it's hard to find the correct number. It's not worth to discuss this much, just think the OSDL thought it necessary to start a survey about it last year. The results of this survey can be read here (http://www.osdl.org/dtl/DTL_Survey_Report_Nov2005.pdf). Besides the usual points as e.g. hardware difficulties, there is one single point which stands out. Doesn't it strike you odd when you read that these users still ask for applications not available on a Linux system? Even if the majority had Linux deployed? Can you imagine what the first top inhibitor of the Linux desktop adoption means?
Well the answers is quite simple, it means a low market share! A market share so low that manufactures don't care about providing drivers, even so low they don't even provide documentation. Too low that vendors don't care for using parts which have Linux drivers, let alone selling Linux systems even if it's cheaper for them. Don't you think it is much more important to raise the market share above a minimal necessary level?
So the number one priority to solve many of the problems of the Linux kernel is to increase the market share above this minimal level. To fix the first top inhibitor of the Linux desktop adoption. I guess very few of you have an idea how this can be achieved. Neither had the desktop architects at ODSL before I mentioned it to them. Even then they are reluctant to listen to me (see http://lists.osdl.org/pipermail/desktop_architects/2005-December/000349.html) albeit they finally seem to agree (see http://lists.osdl.org/pipermail/desktop_architects/2005-December/000369.html). At least they and most probably you don’t know any alternative.
So if Linux should finally become widespread used by everybody my “cross-platform development” initiative (see http://wyoguide.sourceforge.net/index.php?page=Cross-platform.html) has to succeed. Only then becomes a Linux system attractive for the ordinary users and therefore for the vendors and the manufactures.
You may ask now why do I tell this here and wonder what you have to do with. Well first it was Greg Kroah-Hartman proposal to the OSDL and second because I think my proposal will solve many of the limitations you currently face in your work. I think you are well advised to advocate this to the OSDL so they finally look for a desktop architect in their fellowship program <http://www.osdl.org/about_osdl/Maintainers/document_view>. You may further advocate the use of the wyoGuide guidelines so the Linux desktop only has just one set of guidelines instead of several. And you are free to participate in wyoGuide so it’s not only a good but the best for the Linux desktop.
O. Wyss
Signature · 1 line
Application guidelines: http://wyoguide.sf.net/
Quoted 4 lines · Otto Wyss
I've just read about Greg Kroah-Hartman (one of the 17 kernel developers) proposal about what OSDL could do to improve the kernel work. As a none-kernel developer I think it's important to look closer at some of the issues.
Of course, you can do what I do at work - promote GNU/Linux in _every_ conversation with the users (no matter waht the topic).
Only this week I recovered 1.2GB of pictures from a users home computer that die running eXtra Problems.
Using Knoppix and a USB stick with the bad drive mounted on hdb (ok, took 6 'runs' to recover all data) , he was WELL impressed (his wife even more so...) and started asking questions...
Nick
Quoted 6 lines · Otto Wyss
First I have to mention that the kernel is an important but only _one_ part of a Linux system a user may buy in a shop. There are many more parts which have to fit in until a system is bought. IMO the OSDL's task is to care for all of these parts, not only at the kernel. Nobody will buy a computer if it only has a superb kernel but the rest doesn't fit equally well.
Yes, but if the kernel doesn't support the user's wireless chipset and all they can get is binary blob drivers for their graphics cards, the rest of the system will seem naturally worse.
Quoted 6 lines
Well the answers is quite simple, it means a low market share! A market share so low that manufactures don't care about providing drivers, even so low they don't even provide documentation. Too low that vendors don't care for using parts which have Linux drivers, let alone selling Linux systems even if it's cheaper for them. Don't you think it is much more important to raise the market share above a minimal necessary level?
This problem exists, but even ATI and NVIDIA both recognize that there is a market for linux users. So they provide (some) level of effort to write drivers. It's probably their concerns about IP and the IP climate that keep their drivers closed.
Quoted 5 lines
So if Linux should finally become widespread used by everybody my “cross-platform development” initiative (see
http://wyoguide.sourceforge.net/index.php?page=Cross-platform.html) has to succeed. Only then becomes a Linux system attractive for the ordinary users and therefore for the vendors and the manufactures.
I don't see how cross-platform development makes Linux attractive to "ordinary" (non-developer) users. I don't think asking everyone to swallow some red pill is going to make anything any bit better.
Cross platform toolkits like GTK and Qt already exist. Last I heard, Trolltech even had some large customers (Adobe, etc), so who knows - maybe Photoshop on X isn't so long off?
Quoted 6 lines
You may ask now why do I tell this here and wonder what you have to do with. Well first it was Greg Kroah-Hartman proposal to the OSDL and second because I think my proposal will solve many of the limitations you currently face in your work. I think you are well advised to advocate this to the OSDL so they finally look for a desktop architect in their fellowship program
The limitations kernel developers currently face is in the availability of documentation and the cooperation of manufacturers. While the rise of Linux adoption will help this, it's up to the desktop people (read: desktop architects) to worry about desktop stuff. I'm a subscriber there too, and I realize you didn't feel all that at home with your guidelines, but don't you think LKML is the wrong place to be airing them?
I read Greg's words on OSDL too, and it seems (from where I stand, anyways) that things are going well in that area. But that initiative is focused on the kernel and kernel developers, and yours is focused on desktop.
Quoted 1 line
O. Wyss
Cheers,
Chase
Quoted 3 lines · Chase Venters
I read Greg's words on OSDL too, and it seems (from where I stand, anyways) that things are going well in that area.
Thanks, I hope so. Only time will tell :)
Quoted 2 lines
But that initiative is focused on the kernel and kernel developers, and yours is focused on desktop.
Exactly. Desktop developers already have their own foundatations and orginizations where discussing desktop things, like tool kits, are best brought up. This is a kernel specific mailing list and initiative with OSDL.
thanks,
greg k-h