Nigel's work and the future of Suspend2.
Hi all.
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
Users of Suspend2 can rest assured that I will not allow the patches to suffer bitrot. I will be continuing to use them myself, and will therefore have the best of incentives to keep them up-to-date.
Now for the downside: I won't, however, be making any sort of concerted effort at getting them merged into the vanilla kernel after my move, and am not inclined to make a big effort beforehand. Recent discussions on LKML clearly showed that Pavel doesn't want to see them merged, and I didn't see much in the way of other kernel developers expressing a desire contrary to Pavel's wishes. I don't want to waste my time and effort, so I don't see the point to doing anything but maintaining the patches as they stand.
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Cyclades for their employment and support of the project.
Regards,
Nigel
Signature · 2 lines
See our web page for Howtos, FAQs, the Wiki and mailing list info. http://www.suspend2.net IRC: #suspend2 on Freenode
Hi Nigel,
congratulations and all the best, although this sounds like a sad goodbye and resignation. I always hoped for inclusion in mainline and followed the "discussions" on lkml, although Pavel never made an effort to hide his ignorant arrogance. Mainline swsusp never worked for me and so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume. Or maybe I'll try that "patched" MacOS for x86 :). To you, again, all the best and thanks for providing some hope in one of the darker Linux corners for quite some time.
Regards, Thomas.
Am Dienstag, den 07.03.2006, 10:05 +1000 schrieb Nigel Cunningham:
Quoted 28 lines
Hi all.
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
Users of Suspend2 can rest assured that I will not allow the patches to suffer bitrot. I will be continuing to use them myself, and will therefore have the best of incentives to keep them up-to-date.
Now for the downside: I won't, however, be making any sort of concerted effort at getting them merged into the vanilla kernel after my move, and am not inclined to make a big effort beforehand. Recent discussions on LKML clearly showed that Pavel doesn't want to see them merged, and I didn't see much in the way of other kernel developers expressing a desire contrary to Pavel's wishes. I don't want to waste my time and effort, so I don't see the point to doing anything but maintaining the patches as they stand.
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Cyclades for their employment and support of the project.
Regards,
Nigel
_______________________________________________
Suspend2-announce mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.suspend2.net/mailman/listinfo/suspend2-announce
Quoted 6 lines · Thomas Maier
Hi Nigel,
congratulations and all the best, although this sounds like a sad goodbye and resignation. I always hoped for inclusion in mainline and followed the "discussions" on lkml, although Pavel never made an effort to hide his ignorant arrogance.
At least you can't say I was dishonest :-/.
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.
Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
[stripped suspend2 lists -- I guess that's offtopic there.]
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Web maintainer for suspend.sf.net (www.sf.net/projects/suspend) wanted...
Am Mittwoch, den 08.03.2006, 13:25 +0100 schrieb Pavel Machek:
Quoted 9 lines · Thomas Maier
Quoted 6 lines
Hi Nigel,
congratulations and all the best, although this sounds like a sad goodbye and resignation. I always hoped for inclusion in mainline and followed the "discussions" on lkml, although Pavel never made an effort to hide his ignorant arrogance.
At least you can't say I was dishonest :-/.
:).
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
This is sort of a mandelbug to me. Might you give me a hint what to do
if I only got problems every now and then? Because it works sometimes
but hangs my machine silently occasionally on resume (suspend actually always works). Sometimes I get 20 suspend/resume cycles, sometimes I do not even get a single one. With growing kernel versions (from 2.6.9 to 2.6.13 or 14 (last one I checked)) the number of cycles seemed to drop down to lower values (like two to five), although I do not really have collected data and this is more of a feeling. I doubt it is a different set of modules loaded as my typical session is always very similar with always the same hardware plugged in (a notebook, Gnome, Firefox, Evolution, Eclipse, several terminals). I use the hibernate script from the hibernate Debian package.
Unfortunately, I am not kernel developer's darling, as I will not be able to test different kernel versions and/or patches quickly. This is my work machine and it is my only one, so I can at most hack it on weekends (and these days I even work on weekends). Plus I am more the luser kind of user. Sure, I patched and compiled several kernels but I always felt uncomfortable doing it :).
The only useful thing I could imagine is to try to boot a very minimal system and try a lot of cycles and see if it hangs there, too. But even then I see only little hope to file a helpful bug report that might lead to finding a solution.
Suggestions? Thomas.
Quoted 2 lines · Thomas Maier
Am Mittwoch, den 08.03.2006, 13:25 +0100 schrieb Pavel Machek:
Quoted 1 line · Thomas Maier
}-- snip --{
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.
Frankly that's something I really don't understand. swsusp is supposed to work (actually with 2.6.16-rc5-mm2 it works for me 100% of the time) and if it doesn't work for you, there's a bug and it should be fixed. Yet, you don't report it, so it is unknown to anyone except for you and there's no hope anyone will actually work on fixing it.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
Quoted 8 lines
This is sort of a mandelbug to me. Might you give me a hint what to do
if I only got problems every now and then? Because it works sometimes
but hangs my machine silently occasionally on resume (suspend actually always works). Sometimes I get 20 suspend/resume cycles, sometimes I do not even get a single one. With growing kernel versions (from 2.6.9 to 2.6.13 or 14 (last one I checked)) the number of cycles seemed to drop down to lower values (like two to five), although I do not really have collected data and this is more of a feeling.
Then could you please get some data? Also full dmesg and lsmod listing from your system will help, as well as the output of lspci -vvv.
Quoted 11 lines
I doubt it is a different set of modules loaded as my typical session is always very similar with always the same hardware plugged in (a notebook, Gnome, Firefox, Evolution, Eclipse, several terminals). I use the hibernate script from the hibernate Debian package.
Unfortunately, I am not kernel developer's darling, as I will not be able to test different kernel versions and/or patches quickly. This is my work machine and it is my only one, so I can at most hack it on weekends (and these days I even work on weekends). Plus I am more the luser kind of user. Sure, I patched and compiled several kernels but I always felt uncomfortable doing it :).
If you can try 2.6.16 when it's out and see how it works for you wrt suspend/resume, that will help either.
Greetings,
Rafael
Quoted 9 lines · Rafael J. Wysocki
Quoted 2 lines · Thomas Maier
Am Mittwoch, den 08.03.2006, 13:25 +0100 schrieb Pavel Machek:
Quoted 1 line · Thomas Maier
}-- snip --{
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.
Quoted 5 lines
Frankly that's something I really don't understand. swsusp is supposed to work (actually with 2.6.16-rc5-mm2 it works for me 100% of the time) and if it doesn't work for you, there's a bug and it should be fixed. Yet, you don't report it, so it is unknown to anyone except for you and there's no hope anyone will actually work on fixing it.
I have the opposite problem, more or less (S3 not swsusp):
I have two identical (except for different model drives) Thinkpad T42 laptops that exhibit the same behavior. S3 mostly works but occasionally fails to resume, for values of occasionally that vary between 1-2 successful resumes before failure to several dozens.
Unfortunately, having recently been bitten by kernel-userspace API breakages (probably udev but it's been a while ago and I don't really care anymore) for the first time in a decade of constant Linux usage, I have not tracked mainline since about 2.6.12 and instead rely on my vendor kernel plus private patches as recommended over and over on this list. Therefore, no bug report from me. But I have the highest confidence that someone with a Centrino laptop and enough free time to run the most recent vanilla kernel will eventually file a bug and some kernel developer will eventually fix it. In the meantime, I just rely on swsusp or pray that a pre-S3 "sync" and ext3 journalling will be good enough. Sad but true.
If anyone is willing to work with me on tracking down the issue in a vendor kernel (Ubuntu Dapper), I would be more than happy to apply debug patches and supply any debug info requested.
Signature · 2 lines
Write a wise saying and your name will live forever.
-- AnonymousQuoted 10 lines · Tom Marshall
I have the opposite problem, more or less (S3 not swsusp):
I have two identical (except for different model drives) Thinkpad T42 laptops that exhibit the same behavior. S3 mostly works but occasionally fails to resume, for values of occasionally that vary between 1-2 successful resumes before failure to several dozens.
If anyone is willing to work with me on tracking down the issue in a vendor kernel (Ubuntu Dapper), I would be more than happy to apply debug patches and supply any debug info requested.
AFAIK Ubuntu always uses "vbetool post" and "vbetool vbestate save/restore" on most Thinkpads.
I'd say - get rid of this and instead put "acpi_sleep=s3_bios,s3_mode" on the kernel command line. The whole vbetool magic is a bit suspicious to me.
Signature · 3 lines
Stefan Seyfried \ "I didn't want to write for pay. I QA / R&D Team Mobile Devices \ wanted to be paid for what I write." SUSE LINUX Products GmbH, Nürnberg \ -- Leonard Cohen
Quoted 12 lines · Tom Marshall
Quoted 11 lines
I have the opposite problem, more or less (S3 not swsusp):
I have two identical (except for different model drives) Thinkpad T42 laptops that exhibit the same behavior. S3 mostly works but occasionally fails to resume, for values of occasionally that vary between 1-2 successful resumes before failure to several dozens.
If anyone is willing to work with me on tracking down the issue in a vendor kernel (Ubuntu Dapper), I would be more than happy to apply debug patches and supply any debug info requested.
Try Randy Dunlop's libata-acpi patches -- they cured suspend/resume (RAM) on my (Dell) notebook, which previously suffered like your Thinkpad.
-ml
Hi!
Quoted 4 lines
The only useful thing I could imagine is to try to boot a very minimal system and try a lot of cycles and see if it hangs there, too. But even then I see only little hope to file a helpful bug report that might lead to finding a solution.
Yes, that would be useful. If it works on minimal system (text-only, as little modules as possible), and breaks on full system, you should be able to binary-search for module breaking it...
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Web maintainer for suspend.sf.net (www.sf.net/projects/suspend) wanted...
Quoted 14 lines · Pavel Machek
Quoted 6 lines · Thomas Maier
Hi Nigel,
congratulations and all the best, although this sounds like a sad goodbye and resignation. I always hoped for inclusion in mainline and followed the "discussions" on lkml, although Pavel never made an effort to hide his ignorant arrogance.
At least you can't say I was dishonest :-/.
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.
didnt work on my laptop either, or one of my friends where i tried.. however, swsusp2 does..
Quoted 4 lines
Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
yeah well.. IMO merging suspend2 is more productive, as i see it, it has no downsides as to software suspend as of now, except IA64 support, and it has ALOT of upsides.
Quoted 3 lines
[stripped suspend2 lists -- I guess that's offtopic there.]
Pavel
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.didnt work on my laptop either, or one of my friends where i tried.. however, swsusp2 does..
bugzilla IDs?
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
yeah well.. IMO merging suspend2 is more productive, as i see it, it has no downsides as to software suspend as of now, except IA64 support, and it has ALOT of upsides.
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
So yes, filling bugzilla entries would be more productive than flaming me.
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Web maintainer for suspend.sf.net (www.sf.net/projects/suspend) wanted...
Quoted 8 lines · Pavel Machek
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.didnt work on my laptop either, or one of my friends where i tried.. however, swsusp2 does..
bugzilla IDs?
have none, and i know this is very bad, however i didnt feel like i had any useful information to contribute, all i get is black screen, nothing to syslog, i have no serial port on my laptop..
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Your choice... But it would be more productive to read the docs, go to the latest kernel, and if it does not work there, file bugzilla.kernel.org report.
yeah well.. IMO merging suspend2 is more productive, as i see it, it has no downsides as to software suspend as of now, except IA64 support, and it has ALOT of upsides.
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
one of them being the operative word, afaik, nigel was unwilling to work on the issues needed for merging for the reason that it wouldnt be merged..
out of personal interrest, why is it that prevents suspend2 from being merged?
Quoted 2 lines
So yes, filling bugzilla entries would be more productive than flaming me.
my post wasnt flaming, and wasnt intended to do so either.
Quoted 1 line
Pavel
Quoted 5 lines · Kasper Sandberg
Quoted 4 lines · Pavel Machek
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Mainline swsusp never worked for me and
so with you leaving I am tempted to leave Linux behind after more than ten years and switch to that other OS that at least has working suspend and resume.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines
didnt work on my laptop either, or one of my friends where i tried.. however, swsusp2 does..
bugzilla IDs?
have none, and i know this is very bad, however i didnt feel like i had any useful information to contribute, all i get is black screen, nothing to syslog, i have no serial port on my laptop..
printk/mdelay seems to work pretty well for swsusp debugging. As does trying it again with as little modules as possible.
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
one of them being the operative word, afaik, nigel was unwilling to work on the issues needed for merging for the reason that it wouldnt be merged..
out of personal interrest, why is it that prevents suspend2 from being merged?
Mostly doing too much stuff in kernel, see archives for details.
Signature · 1 line
Thanks, Sharp!
Hi.
Quoted 6 lines · Kasper Sandberg
Quoted 2 lines
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
one of them being the operative word, afaik, nigel was unwilling to work on the issues needed for merging for the reason that it wouldnt be merged..
Yes. The only reason I'm not going to commit myself to getting carried away with seeking to merge it is that you've clearly stated that you don't want to see it merged, and you haven't been overruled by other kernel maintainers (with perhaps the occasional exception, sometimes privately). If they came along to the party and said "Pavel, get your act together. Suspend2 isn't as invasive or ugly as you're making it out to be." (or something similar), I'd see some point to working on merging it. If they want to tell me to submit it again or prove that's the case, I'm more than willing to hear that. But while the only feedback is users saying "I wish it was merged" and Pavel saying "Ain't going to happen", what am I meant to do?
Regards,
Nigel
Quoted 6 lines · Nigel Cunningham
Hi.
Quoted 3 lines · Kasper Sandberg
Quoted 2 lines
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
one of them being the operative word, afaik, nigel was unwilling to work on the issues needed for merging for the reason that it wouldnt be merged..
Yes. The only reason I'm not going to commit myself to getting carried away with seeking to merge it is that you've clearly stated that you don't want to see it merged, and you haven't been overruled by other kernel maintainers
Unless I'm missing something, Kasper is not the one who stated anything about merging suspend2...
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
163:
Quoted 11 lines · Pavel Machek
Quoted 10 lines · Nigel Cunningham
Hi.
Quoted 6 lines · Kasper Sandberg
Quoted 2 lines
Except that suspend2 is not going to be merged, for variety of reasons. One of them is that noone is working on merging it...
one of them being the operative word, afaik, nigel was unwilling to work on the issues needed for merging for the reason that it wouldnt be merged..
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Yes. The only reason I'm not going to commit myself to getting carried away with seeking to merge it is that you've clearly stated that you don't want to see it merged, and you haven't been overruled by other kernel maintainers
Unless I'm missing something, Kasper is not the one who stated anything about merging suspend2...
i do wish suspend2 to get merged, however, if there are issues so that its a risk, i can understand it wont being merged just now, but as nigel just said, he is willing to work on it, if it then will be merged, which puts the ball in your hand.
i hope for this to happen :)
Quoted 1 line
Pavel
Hi!
Quoted 3 lines
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
Good luck in whatever you'll do!
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Web maintainer for suspend.sf.net (www.sf.net/projects/suspend) wanted...
Hi.
Quoted 8 lines · Pavel Machek
Hi!
Quoted 4 lines
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
Good luck in whatever you'll do!
Thanks.
You haven't gotten confused like slashdot and kerneltrap, have you? I'm not going away. Just switching careers back to Christian ministry. I'll still be maintaining the suspend2 patches.
Regards,
Nigel
Signature · 2 lines
See our web page for Howtos, FAQs, the Wiki and mailing list info. http://www.suspend2.net IRC: #suspend2 on Freenode
Quoted 5 lines · Nigel Cunningham
Hi all.
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
Users of Suspend2 can rest assured that I will not allow the patches to suffer bitrot. I will be continuing to use them myself, and will therefore have the best of incentives to keep them up-to-date.
I think you for all your work, and I hope that your new calling will be satisfying!
Quoted 2 lines
Now for the downside: I won't, however, be making any sort of concerted effort at getting them merged into the vanilla kernel after my move, and am not inclined to make a big effort beforehand. Recent discussions on LKML clearly showed that Pavel doesn't want to see them merged, and I didn't see much in the way of other kernel developers expressing a desire contrary to Pavel's wishes. I don't want to waste my time and effort, so I don't see the point to doing anything but maintaining the patches as they stand.
I have never had any problems with Suspend1 in terms of SUSPEND, although I was hoping at some time that RESUME functionality would be added as well ;-) Suspend2 has worked for my laptops, and I'm delighted that you will be continuing your work.
Quoted 2 lines
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Cyclades for their employment and support of the project.
Signature · 3 lines
-bill davidsen ([email protected]) "The secret to procrastination is to put things off until the last possible moment - but no longer" -me
Quoted 3 lines · Bill Davidsen
I have never had any problems with Suspend1 in terms of SUSPEND, although I was hoping at some time that RESUME functionality would be added as well ;-)
Got a link to the bug report?
Lee
Hi.
Quoted 6 lines · Bill Davidsen
Quoted 3 lines
Users of Suspend2 can rest assured that I will not allow the patches to suffer bitrot. I will be continuing to use them myself, and will therefore have the best of incentives to keep them up-to-date.
I think you for all your work, and I hope that your new calling will be satisfying!
Thanks :)
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 8 lines
Now for the downside: I won't, however, be making any sort of concerted effort at getting them merged into the vanilla kernel after my move, and am not inclined to make a big effort beforehand. Recent discussions on LKML clearly showed that Pavel doesn't want to see them merged, and I didn't see much in the way of other kernel developers expressing a desire contrary to Pavel's wishes. I don't want to waste my time and effort, so I don't see the point to doing anything but maintaining the patches as they stand.
Quoted 4 lines
I have never had any problems with Suspend1 in terms of SUSPEND, although I was hoping at some time that RESUME functionality would be added as well ;-) Suspend2 has worked for my laptops, and I'm delighted that you will be continuing your work.
I don't think of swsusp as suspend1 - in my mind, Suspend1 was the version I released before suspend2 :). That said, I obviously know what you mean. It should work - they're basically the same. The main difference that would make Suspend2 work for you would be that I've sometimes included the odd driver fix in the suspend2 patch to save people having to go searching, and have (my bad) been too slow at pushing them upstream.
Regards,
Nigel
Signature · 2 lines
See our web page for Howtos, FAQs, the Wiki and mailing list info. http://www.suspend2.net IRC: #suspend2 on Freenode
Quoted 6 lines · Nigel Cunningham
Hi all.
I'm delighted to announce that I've accepted a call to serve a congregation in Victoria, Australia, as a Home Missionary elder. As a result, some time in the next month or two, I will stop working for Cyclades and make the move.
That's a new term for me. What is "Home Missionary elder" and what church will you be serving at?
j----- k-----
Signature · 3 lines
Joshua Kugler PGP Key: http://pgp.mit.edu/ CDE System Administrator ID 0xDB26D7CE http://distance.uaf.edu/