Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Removal of security/root_plug.c

DISCUSSION Anne Thrax 3 participants 4 messages Jun 10, 2006 – Jun 11, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore

Anne Thrax

author
#0 lore raw

Hello all,

Apparently security/root_plug.c was written for a Linux Journal article, and while it does do a good job of explaining LSM, I don't see much use for it in the mainstream kernel. I suggest that it be removed, because I don't think that it serves much purpose. I doubt that anyone actually uses this, for if they did, I think that it would be modified and have many additions. Even the author states that it is just a starting point. Maybe the article (if Linux Journal is okay with it) along with the code should be moved to Documentation/?

#1 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Anne Thrax

Hello all,

Apparently security/root_plug.c was written for a Linux Journal article, and while it does do a good job of explaining LSM, I don't see much use for it in the mainstream kernel. I suggest that it be removed, because I don't think that it serves much purpose. I doubt that anyone actually uses this, for if they did, I think that it would be modified and have many additions. Even the author states that it is just a starting point. Maybe the article (if Linux Journal is okay with it) along with the code should be moved to Documentation/?

No, it should stay for the same reasons I gave a month or so ago on this list when someone asked the same question (please search the archives for details.)

And surprisingly, people actually use this lsm module for real...

thanks,

greg k-h

#2 lore raw
In reply to Anne Thrax
Quoted 11 lines

Hello all,

Apparently security/root_plug.c was written for a Linux Journal article, and while it does do a good job of explaining LSM, I don't see much use for it in the mainstream kernel. I suggest that it be removed, because I don't think that it serves much purpose. I doubt that anyone actually uses this, for if they did, I think that it would be modified and have many additions. Even the author states that it is just a starting point. Maybe the article (if Linux Journal is okay with it) along with the code should be moved to Documentation/?

At least it should be kept in the new DDK Greg released, if it is going to be removed from mainline.

Jan Engelhardt

#3 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Jan Engelhardt
Quoted 11 lines

Hello all,

Apparently security/root_plug.c was written for a Linux Journal article, and while it does do a good job of explaining LSM, I don't see much use for it in the mainstream kernel. I suggest that it be removed, because I don't think that it serves much purpose. I doubt that anyone actually uses this, for if they did, I think that it would be modified and have many additions. Even the author states that it is just a starting point. Maybe the article (if Linux Journal is okay with it) along with the code should be moved to Documentation/?

Quoted 2 lines

At least it should be kept in the new DDK Greg released, if it is going to be removed from mainline.

It's not going to be removed any time soon.

thanks,

greg k-h