Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Reply-To header munging (was: Reply to the list)

DISCUSSION Neale Pickett 3 participants 4 messages Aug 2, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · Allan Joergensen
Quoted 3 lines · Neale Pickett
Quoted 1 line

It may because the REPLY-TO is not forced...(?)

http://www.unicom.com/pw/reply-to-harmful.html

http://www.metasystema.net/essays/reply-to.mhtml

Normally I'd side with Charlie's "please drop it" argument. But since this subject is actually pretty on-topic for this list, I'll keep going.

RFC 2822 (which supercedes RFC 822, which is what both of our URLs cite) is very clear about the use of the Reply-To header. 3.6.2 states:

When the "Reply-To:" field is present, it indicates the mailbox(es) to which the author of the message suggests that replies be sent.

The author, mind. Not the list owner or any other middle-man.

I used this functionality just yesterday to post a message to a list on behalf of my wife. I didn't want to get follow-ups. There would have been no way for me to do this if they munged the Reply-To header.

Also see section 3.4 of RFC 2369:

The List-Post field describes the method for posting to the list. This is typically the address of the list, but MAY be a moderator, or potentially some other form of submission. For the special case of a list that does not allow posting (e.g., an announcements list), the List-Post field may contain the special value "NO".

And, in fact, my mail client (KMail, mentioned specifically in your URL) has four options for replying:

Reply
Replies to the List-Post address, the Reply-To address, or From address, in
that order.

Reply to All
Replies to all addresses in Reply-To or From, the To, and the Cc fields

Reply to Author
Replies to the Reply-To or From address

Reply to List
Replies to the List-Post address

The first two are the "primary" ones, the latter two aren't bound to a hot-key. I think this behavior implies that they want lists not to munge the Reply-To header, especially since there's no way to have it ignore the Reply-To header. Munging it *would* penalize me, and in fact I have a number of procmail rules which remove the dumb header for silly lists that set it.

Okay, your turn Allan :)

#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Neale Pickett

Reply to List
Replies to the List-Post address

Outlook and Thunderbird does not have this functionality.

Quoted 1 line

Okay, your turn Allan :)

I don't like getting a copy of answers to mailing lists when people do a group reply but besides that I don't really care; it's just that the "reply-to munging is harmful" URL pops up every time anyone mentions the subject.

Signature · 3 lines
Allan Willems Joergensen

"Phew! This smells like the boss' clothes hamper." - Greasepit
#2 lore raw
In reply to Neale Pickett
Quoted 5 lines · Allan Joergensen
Quoted 2 lines · Neale Pickett

Reply to List
Replies to the List-Post address

Quoted 8 lines

Outlook and Thunderbird does not have this functionality.

Quoted 1 line

Okay, your turn Allan :)

I don't like getting a copy of answers to mailing lists when people do a group reply but besides that I don't really care; it's just that the "reply-to munging is harmful" URL pops up every time anyone mentions the subject.

Quite reasonably so, since the RFC Neale quotes is quite unambiguous about the intended use of Reply-To.

#3 lore raw
In reply to Neale Pickett
Quoted 9 lines · Charlie Brady
Quoted 4 lines · Allan Joergensen

I don't like getting a copy of answers to mailing lists when people do a group reply but besides that I don't really care; it's just that the "reply-to munging is harmful" URL pops up every time anyone mentions the subject.

Quite reasonably so, since the RFC Neale quotes is quite unambiguous about the intended use of Reply-To.

This comes up so frequently that I decided to take the time to write up a web page about it, so everybody can just post my URL and hopefully not waste any more list bandwidth on beating this dead horse.

http://woozle.org/~neale/papers/reply-to-still-harmful.html

Comments and Suggestions are welcome, but please send them *privately*. Just use the "reply" action in your mail program. Since Mads doesn't set Reply-To, it'll do the right thing :)

Neale