Repeatable hang on boot with PCMCIA card present
[I sent the following to the person responsible for the patch but haven't heard anything so I assume he's unavailable...]
Hi,
With recent kernel releases I have started seeing consistent hangs during boot when a PCMCIA card is present in the slot (the card in question is a Linksys wireless-B card). The symptoms are:
If the card is present during boot an error of "Unknown interrupt or fault at EIP ..." appears.
If the card is not present there is no error.
The card can be plugged-in post-boot without problems.
Using git-bisect I have narrowed down the error to one commit, namely "use bitfield instead of p_state and state". The commit# is
e2d4096365e06b9a3799afbadc28b4519c0b3526
However I am still seeing this problem with the latest -RC releases.
Additional information:
Machine: Dell Inspiron 8100
Distribution: Ubuntu Dapper
Please let me know if you need any more information.
Regards,
Steve Smith
Quoted 14 lines · On Sat, 16 Sep 2006 15:03:31 +1000 [email protected] (Steve Smith) wrote:
[I sent the following to the person responsible for the patch but haven't heard anything so I assume he's unavailable...]
Hi,
With recent kernel releases I have started seeing consistent hangs during boot when a PCMCIA card is present in the slot (the card in question is a Linksys wireless-B card). The symptoms are:
If the card is present during boot an error of "Unknown interrupt or fault at EIP ..." appears.
If the card is not present there is no error.
Quoted 8 lines
The card can be plugged-in post-boot without problems.
Using git-bisect I have narrowed down the error to one commit, namely "use bitfield instead of
p_stateand state". The commit# ise2d4096365e06b9a3799afbadc28b4519c0b3526However I am still seeing this problem with the latest -RC releases.
Thanks for doing that.
Damn, that was a huge patch. Have you been able to grab a copy of the oops output? It would really help. Even a photo of the screen..
Quoted 3 lines · Andrew Morton
Damn, that was a huge patch. Have you been able to grab a copy of the oops output? It would really help. Even a photo of the screen..
No oops I'm afraid, just the hang and EIP message. The numbers with the message change each time but I can send them when I get to the machine later. Is there another way to coax more information out of the kernel?
Thanks,
Steve
Quoted 8 lines · On Tue, 19 Sep 2006 12:25:41 +1000 [email protected] (Steve Smith) wrote:
Quoted 3 lines · Andrew Morton
Damn, that was a huge patch. Have you been able to grab a copy of the oops output? It would really help. Even a photo of the screen..
No oops I'm afraid, just the hang and EIP message. The numbers with the message change each time but I can send them when I get to the machine later.
hm, ugly.
Quoted 2 lines
Is there another way to coax more information out
of the kernel?
I don't expect so - if it doesn't print anything useful to the console we're rather stuck. You probably don't have a serial port. If you have a lan port then netconsole _might_ work, but I'd say it's unlikely.
Dunno. You _might_ be able to get a better trace by changing settings such as CONFIG_FRAME_POINTER, CONFIG_4KSTACKS, CONFIG_UNWIND_INFO, and CONFIG_DEBUG_*.
Quoted 24 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 21 lines · On Sat, 16 Sep 2006 15:03:31 +1000 [email protected] (Steve Smith) wrote:
[I sent the following to the person responsible for the patch but haven't heard anything so I assume he's unavailable...]
Hi,
With recent kernel releases I have started seeing consistent hangs during boot when a PCMCIA card is present in the slot (the card in question is a Linksys wireless-B card). The symptoms are:
If the card is present during boot an error of "Unknown interrupt or fault at EIP ..." appears.
If the card is not present there is no error.
The card can be plugged-in post-boot without problems.
Using git-bisect I have narrowed down the error to one commit, namely "use bitfield instead of
p_stateand state". The commit# ise2d4096365e06b9a3799afbadc28b4519c0b3526
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line
However I am still seeing this problem with the latest -RC releases.
Thanks for doing that.
Damn, that was a huge patch. Have you been able to grab a copy of the oops output? It would really help. Even a photo of the screen..
Hmm, not sure why you CCed me unless you remembered I have Inspiron 8100. What chipset does that Linksys card use? I just tried one of my PCMCIA cards with orinoco_cs and it booted fine on today's pull from Linus...
Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
Quoted 27 lines · On Mon, 18 Sep 2006 23:37:52 -0400 Dmitry Torokhov <[email protected]> wrote:
Quoted 26 lines · Andrew Morton
Quoted 22 lines · On Sat, 16 Sep 2006 15:03:31 +1000 [email protected] (Steve Smith) wrote:
[I sent the following to the person responsible for the patch but haven't heard anything so I assume he's unavailable...]
Hi,
With recent kernel releases I have started seeing consistent hangs during boot when a PCMCIA card is present in the slot (the card in question is a Linksys wireless-B card). The symptoms are:
If the card is present during boot an error of "Unknown interrupt or fault at EIP ..." appears.
If the card is not present there is no error.
The card can be plugged-in post-boot without problems.
Using git-bisect I have narrowed down the error to one commit, namely "use bitfield instead of
p_stateand state". The commit# ise2d4096365e06b9a3799afbadc28b4519c0b3526However I am still seeing this problem with the latest -RC releases.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Thanks for doing that.
Damn, that was a huge patch. Have you been able to grab a copy of the oops output? It would really help. Even a photo of the screen..
Hmm, not sure why you CCed me unless you remembered I have Inspiron 8100.
oop, I get my Dominiks and Dmitrys mixed up for some reason, sorry.
Quoted 5 lines
What chipset does that Linksys card use? I just tried one of my PCMCIA cards with
orinoco_csand it booted fine on today's pull from Linus...Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
Quoted 2 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Hmm, not sure why you CCed me unless you remembered I have Inspiron 8100. What chipset does that Linksys card use?
It's a WPC11, one of the prism family ones. It's using the HostAP driver.
Quoted 2 lines
I just tried one of my PCMCIA cards with
orinoco_csand it booted fine on today's pull from Linus...
OK, I'll try it with the orinoco driver when I get a chance.
Cheers,
Steve