New filesystem for Linux
Quoted 8 lines · Albert Cahalan
Quoted 7 lines · Jan-Benedict Glaw
Quoted 5 lines · Albert Cahalan
BTW, a person with disk recovery experience told me that drives will sometimes reorder the sectors. Sector 42 becomes sector 7732, sector 880880 becomes sector 12345, etc. The very best filesystems can handle with without data loss. (for example, ZFS) Merely great filesystems will at least recognize that the data has been trashed.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Uh? This should be transparent to the host computer, so logical sector numbers won't change.
"should be" does not imply "won't" :-)
On a drive which is capable of remapping sectors, imagine what happens if the remapping data itself is corrupted. (the user data is perfectly fine and is not being relocated)
I would consider this a defective drive.
Quoted 5 lines
What I mean is that the logical sector numbers not only change, but they are the only thing changing. The user data never moves to a different physical location, and is never intended to move. The user data is perfectly readable. It just appears in the wrong place as viewed by the OS.
Just like defective drive electronics; the data is ok, but the electronics corrupts the I/O.
No FS could help you there, AFAIK.
BTW, why is this thread not on fsdevel?
Thanks!
--
Al