softmac: remove netif_tx_disable when scanning
Subsystems (2)
PATCH 1/1 softmac: remove netif_tx_disable when scanning
From: Michael Buesch <[email protected]>
In the scan section of ieee80211softmac, network transmits are disabled. Clearly, this does not make any sense as transmit is necessary for active scanning, and transmits are not used when passive scanning. In addition, when SoftMAC re-enables transmits, it may override the wishes of a driver that may have very good reasons for disabling transmits. No specific problems can be blamed directly on this bug, but it may be responsible for some unexplained behavior.
---
John,
Please apply this to wireless-2.6 and push it upstream for inclusion in 2.6.19, if possible. I will be submitting it to 2.6.18.Y.
Larry
net/ieee80211/softmac/ieee80211softmac_scan.c +0 -2
@@ -47,7 +47,6 @@ ieee80211softmac_start_scan(struct ieee8 sm->scanning =1 ;spin_unlock_irqrestore (&sm->lock, flags); -netif_tx_disable (sm->ieee->dev); ret = sm->start_scan (sm->dev);if (ret) {spin_lock_irqsave (&sm->lock, flags);
@@ -248,7 +246,6 @@ void ieee80211softmac_scan_finished(struif (net) sm->set_channel (sm->dev, net->channel); } -netif_wake_queue (sm->ieee->dev);ieee80211softmac_call_events (sm,IEEE80211SOFTMAC_EVENT_SCAN_FINISHED ,NULL ); }EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL (ieee80211softmac_scan_finished);
---
Quoted 3 lines · Larry Finger
In the scan section of ieee80211softmac, network transmits are disabled. Clearly, this does not make any sense as transmit is necessary for active scanning, and transmits are not used when passive scanning.
Probe request frames are generated by softmac and do not go through the TX queue. Disabling the TX queue has no effect on that.
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
Daniel
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Drake
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to netif_tx_disable but make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.
johannes
Quoted 10 lines · Johannes Berg
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Drake
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
Quoted 7 lines
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to
netif_tx_disablebut make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.
Yeah, but I don't think it's worth fixing. ;) Simply removing this tx_disable in softmac fixes a _big_ bug and that must be applied. The bug of being able to scan while calibrating is very minor and not worth to fix. Fixing this will likely introduce other bugs. It's simply not worth it anymore.
This tx_disable remove patch must be applied, because it fixes actual locking issues in the driver(s). And I think it is responsible for several mysterious bugs we have seen in the past. I cannot prove that, but I am pretty sure.
It must also be pushed for inclusion in -stable.
Signature · 1 line
Greetings Michael.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 18 lines · Michael Buesch
Quoted 9 lines · Johannes Berg
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Drake
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
Quoted 7 lines
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to
netif_tx_disablebut make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.
Quoted 6 lines
Yeah, but I don't think it's worth fixing. ;) Simply removing this
tx_disablein softmac fixes a _big_ bug and that must be applied. The bug of being able to scan while calibrating is very minor and not worth to fix. Fixing this will likely introduce other bugs. It's simply not worth it anymore.
I actually found one of these while testing WX locking as suggested by Dan Williams. His method has two scripts running at the same time with one of them doing an 'iwlist ethX scan' and the other executing an 'iwconfig ethX' as fast as possible. Running this test for 36 hours failed to indicate any locking errors, but running it without the patch under discussion led to a number of the following errors:
kernel: bcm43xx: ASSERTION FAILED (!ring->suspended) at:
drivers/net/wireless/bcm43xx/bcm43xx_dma.c:71:request_slot()
This error _NEVER_ happened when softmac was not allowed to disable TX.
Larry
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 32 lines · Larry Finger
Quoted 18 lines · Michael Buesch
Quoted 9 lines · Johannes Berg
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Drake
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
Quoted 7 lines
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to
netif_tx_disablebut make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.Quoted 6 lines
Yeah, but I don't think it's worth fixing. ;) Simply removing this
tx_disablein softmac fixes a _big_ bug and that must be applied. The bug of being able to scan while calibrating is very minor and not worth to fix. Fixing this will likely introduce other bugs. It's simply not worth it anymore.I actually found one of these while testing WX locking as suggested by Dan Williams. His method has two scripts running at the same time with one of them doing an 'iwlist ethX scan' and the other executing an 'iwconfig ethX' as fast as possible. Running this test for 36 hours failed to indicate any locking errors, but running it without the patch under discussion led to a number of the following errors:
Quoted 4 lines
kernel: bcm43xx: ASSERTION FAILED (!ring->suspended) at:
drivers/net/wireless/bcm43xx/bcm43xx_dma.c:71:request_slot()This error _NEVER_ happened when softmac was not allowed to disable TX.
Yeah, that's the error I expected.
Nice that you proved my point for this being an important patch. ;)
Signature · 1 line
Greetings Michael.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 3 lines · Johannes Berg
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
I agree with that part. However the other reason for the patch (transmit queue needed for active scanning) is bogus, and the patch introduces a problem where session frames may be transmitted during scanning (using TX queue control avoids that problem).
Quoted 7 lines
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to
netif_tx_disablebut make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.
Stack-level refcounted TX control like this would also be beneficial for zd1211rw, currently we have a semi-ugly implementation inside the driver.
Quoted 3 lines
Also, for bcm43xx this isn't a problem since the firmware (optionally but we use that afaik) takes care of not transmitting frames that are tagged for a different channel than currently tuned to.
zd1211 has no such functionality :(
Quoted 2 lines · Michael Buesch
Softmac ignoring
this queue-disabled flag is just yet another bug.
Agreed, but this one isn't going to be fixed any time soon. This was the first point I raised against softmac during early zd1211rw development a long while back.
I agree with the objectives of this patch but the way I see it is that it trades one bug for another. A proper solution, as suggested by Johannes (refcounted stack-level TX control) would not be hard to implement and would solve the bug without introducing another.
Daniel
Quoted 2 lines · Daniel Drake
However the other reason for the patch (transmit
queue needed for active scanning) is bogus,
I think that was just a misunderstanding.
Quoted 3 lines
and the patch introduces a
problem where session frames may be transmitted during scanning (using TX queue control avoids that problem).
Which is really the reason why we put that there in the first place :)
Quoted 7 lines
Stack-level refcounted TX control like this would also be beneficial for zd1211rw, currently we have a semi-ugly implementation inside the driver.
I agree with the objectives of this patch but the way I see it is that it trades one bug for another. A proper solution, as suggested by Johannes (refcounted stack-level TX control) would not be hard to implement and would solve the bug without introducing another.
Would you actually need a fully refcounted enable/disable? Because for the stack it wouldn't be required if it'd simply not start scanning when queue is disabled and stop scanning immediately when queue stop is requested.
johannes
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 1 line · Johannes Berg
Would you actually need a fully refcounted enable/disable?
No, we could stick with our existing setup if the stack did something different.
Quoted 4 lines
Because for
the stack it wouldn't be required if it'd simply not start scanning when queue is disabled and stop scanning immediately when queue stop is requested.
That would work, assuming there is a way to make the stack listen for the "TX queue stopped" event (or would the ieee80211_tx_disable wrapper take care of that?).
Daniel
Quoted 2 lines · Daniel Drake
No, we could stick with our existing setup if the stack did something different.
But you do need full refcounting I guess.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Because for
the stack it wouldn't be required if it'd simply not start scanning when queue is disabled and stop scanning immediately when queue stop is requested.That would work, assuming there is a way to make the stack listen for the "TX queue stopped" event (or would the
ieee80211_tx_disablewrapper take care of that?).
A wrapper is what I had in mind, I don't think there's any notification for these things.
johannes
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): 1164566436.22909.26.camel-YfaajirXv214zXjbi5bjpg@public.gmane.org
Quoted 11 lines · Johannes Berg
Quoted 2 lines · Daniel Drake
No, we could stick with our existing setup if the stack did something different.
But you do need full refcounting I guess.
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Because for
the stack it wouldn't be required if it'd simply not start scanning when queue is disabled and stop scanning immediately when queue stop is requested.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
That would work, assuming there is a way to make the stack listen for the "TX queue stopped" event (or would the
ieee80211_tx_disablewrapper take care of that?).A wrapper is what I had in mind, I don't think there's any notification for these things.
If someone will prepare a patch that will fix this, I can test it. Otherwise, I'm prepared to substitute the bug that doesn't hurt anything for the one that I have shown does cause problems.
Larry
Quoted 6 lines · Johannes Berg
Quoted 2 lines · Daniel Drake
No, we could stick with our existing setup if the stack did something different.
But you do need full refcounting I guess.
No, I don't think we would need to move away from our existing method:
spin_lock_irqsave(&mac->lock, flags);
if (mac->updating_rts_rate == 0 && mac->updating_basic_rates == 0)
netif_wake_queue(mac->netdev);
spin_unlock_irqrestore(&mac->lock, flags);That said, it is in some ways comparable to refcounting without a
counter: if both flags are set to 0, the above code is guaranteed to be executed twice (each time after one flag is toggled)
Daniel
Quoted 31 lines · Daniel Drake
Quoted 3 lines · Johannes Berg
The problem is that queue disabling isn't refcounted so that a scan that collides with bcm43xx having disabled the queue for calibration might re-enable the queue while bcm43xx is still calibrating.
I agree with that part. However the other reason for the patch (transmit queue needed for active scanning) is bogus, and the patch introduces a problem where session frames may be transmitted during scanning (using TX queue control avoids that problem).
Quoted 7 lines
Clearly, this doesn't fully fix the problem because softmac will try to transmit frames during the calibration. Hence, a proper fix would be to not remove the calls to
netif_tx_disablebut make them go through softmac (ieee80211_tx_disable) to make sure that softmac doesn't try to scan while the queues are disabled, which would fix the aforementioned problem of softmac enabling the queue while the driver needs it disabled for free.Stack-level refcounted TX control like this would also be beneficial for zd1211rw, currently we have a semi-ugly implementation inside the driver.
Quoted 3 lines
Also, for bcm43xx this isn't a problem since the firmware (optionally but we use that afaik) takes care of not transmitting frames that are tagged for a different channel than currently tuned to.
zd1211 has no such functionality :(
Quoted 2 lines · Michael Buesch
Softmac ignoring
this queue-disabled flag is just yet another bug.
Quoted 6 lines
Agreed, but this one isn't going to be fixed any time soon. This was the first point I raised against softmac during early zd1211rw development a long while back.
I agree with the objectives of this patch but the way I see it is that it trades one bug for another. A proper solution, as suggested by
Yeah, it trades one fat big bug against a very minor one. AND!! Currently it's possible to transmit frames while scanning, too. Don't forget that. Today we have both bugs. With this patch we have only one left. The only "issue" is that today the "transmit packet while scanning" bug is less likely to trigger. But it's still possible (because of disabling not being refcounted).
Quoted 2 lines
Johannes (refcounted stack-level TX control) would not be hard to implement and would solve the bug without introducing another.
So, please do so.
But please apply this one regardless of what you do. ;) It fixes a nasty kind of bug. With this trivial to fix bug in the tree I won't look at periodic work "bugs" anymore, that are reported now and then, because I really thing they are all caused by this hidden bug.
I also saw a real life bugreport of the asserion in the DMA code triggering. I didn't know back than how that was possible to happen, but now I know.
Besides that, what's the problem with some bogus frames being transmitted throughout the short period of scanning? I don't really see how that can hurt anyone (besides consuming minor bandwidth).
I already said it in the past. We _have_ to trade one bug for the other in softmac, because it's buggy by design. And it really doesn't make sense to fix them all. Well, actually it does. Because fixing all these bugs would mean replacing softmac by d80211. There's no real other way. ;)
Signature · 1 line
Greetings Michael.
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 3 lines · Daniel Drake
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
Also, for bcm43xx this isn't a problem since the firmware (optionally but we use that afaik) takes care of not transmitting frames that are tagged for a different channel than currently tuned to. This is necessary because the packets travel through a FIFO and radio tuning is done by the driver without it knowing how much is still in the FIFO and a full disable is quite expensive (in terms of the time needed.)
johannes
_______________________________________________
Bcm43xx-dev mailing list [email protected]
https://lists.berlios.de/mailman/listinfo/bcm43xx-dev
Quoted 7 lines · Daniel Drake
Quoted 3 lines · Larry Finger
In the scan section of ieee80211softmac, network transmits are disabled. Clearly, this does not make any sense as transmit is necessary for active scanning, and transmits are not used when passive scanning.
Probe request frames are generated by softmac and do not go through the TX queue. Disabling the TX queue has no effect on that.
That's just yet another problem. ;)
The driver has its damn good reasons to disable the queue. (And only the driver should be allowed to disable that queue). Softmac ignoring this queue-disabled flag is just yet another bug.
Quoted 3 lines
Surely disabling the queue actually makes sense, in order to avoid frames designated for the "current session" being transmitted on different channels during scanning?
This should be avoided by mechanisms in the firmware, as that's the only race-free place where a "Am I on the correct channel" check can happen. Additionally, the ieee80211 stack should keep track of the currently set channel and don't transmit frames on the wrong channel.
But I don't really think this is worth fixing, as it's all already fixed in d80211 (Well, these bugs have never been in there afaik ;) ).
Signature · 1 line
Greetings Michael.