Dual-Licensing Linux Kernel with GPL V2 and GPL V3
Quoted 11 lines · Linus Torvalds
Everybody else just cares about the legal reasons.
The "legal terms" is the only reason a license *exists*. That's what a license *is*, for crying out loud!
If you don't care about the legal side, go and read the free software
manifesto. That's the paper you're really arguing about.If you want to argue about the GPLv2 *license*, then you'd better start caring about the legal issues. Because that is what the license is: a _legal_ document.
IMHO, free and open source software seem to differ on one key point:
Quoted 7 lines · The Open Source Definition
9. License Must Not Restrict Other Software
The license must not place restrictions on other software that is distributed along with the licensed software. For example, the license must not insist that all other programs distributed on the same medium must be open-source software.
Quoted 6 lines
Rationale: Distributors of open-source software have the right to make their own choices about their own software.
Yes, the GPL is conformant with this requirement. Software linked with GPLed libraries only inherits the GPL if it forms a single work, not any software with which they are merely distributed.
The way I understand it, programs licensed under the GPLv3 are *not* open source software. FSF is so caught up in their own agenda that they're forgetting the whole point - the freedom of choice. The GPLv2 may be "conformant with this requirement", but it goes against the ethics of the FSF, so we can't expect each new version of the GPL to comply to this right.
Attacking this so-called "tivozation", IMO, finally draws a distinct line between "free" and "open source". We, as open source developers, are not politicians or philosophers; we write software, and we wish to publish our code under a certain set of ten rights.
Yes, the GPL is a legal document, but it was written in order to compliment the GNU Manifesto by setting legal parameters for which they could publish their code under.
Until now, the GPL (v2) has had the same *legal* paramaters the open source developers need in order to do the job we need it to do. We have clearly went our separate ways now, so I think it's time to drop the GPL. (See my other thread about writing an open source license.)
Anyways, that's my $0.02.
Signature · 1 line
It's a commonly known fact that most intruders come in through Windows.
Quoted 1 line · Joshua David Williams
The Open Source Definition
... derived from the Debian Free Software Guidelines, engineered to reflect the Free Software definition ...
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 5 lines · wrote:
9. License Must Not Restrict Other Software
Yes, the GPL is conformant with this requirement. Software linked with GPLed libraries only inherits the GPL if it forms a single work, not any software with which they are merely distributed.
The way I understand it, programs licensed under the GPLv3 are *not* open source software. FSF is so caught up in their own agenda that they're forgetting the whole point - the freedom of choice.
Err... Excuse me? Whole point for whom?
Free Software is not about freedom of choice. That's an OSI slogan for "if you like, you can shoot your own foot, regardless of whether the shrapnel hurts people around you".
http://www.fsfla.org/?q=en/node/139#1
Free Software is about respect for the four freedoms.
I don't think the FSF is at all concerned whether GPLv3 complies with the OSD. They couldn't care less. It was OSI that tried to create a definition that matched exactly the meaning of the Free Software definition under "more objective criteria". We already know they failed, since the Reciprocal Public License is accepted as an OSS license, but it's a non-Free Software license. There may be other examples.
That said, since a number of people already understand the GPLv2 prohibits tivoization, your argument means that either the comment in the OSD is wrong, and GPLv2 already fails to match the OSD, or that GPLv3 complies with it in just the same way.
Signature · 4 lines
Alexandre Oliva http://www.lsd.ic.unicamp.br/~oliva/
FSF Latin America Board Member http://www.fsfla.org/
Red Hat Compiler Engineer aoliva@{redhat.com, gcc.gnu.org}
Free Software Evangelist oliva@{lsd.ic.unicamp.br, gnu.org}