Skip to contentSkip to conversation

good job guys with the anti-spam !

OT Willy Tarreau 3 participants 6 messages Jul 31, 2007 – Sep 2, 2007

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi all,

eventhough people often write only when they have something to complain about, I for once would like to congratulate Matti and David, our mail admins, for the wonderful job they've done with the spams lately. This month, I might have seen maybe one or two instead of perhaps 30 per day earlier. While it did not bother me that much earlier, I can say that the list is more pleasant to read every day, and I think that's great.

Kudos guys !

Willy

PS: please do not start another one of those long useless threads from now on

#1 lore raw

* Tue, 31 Jul 2007 23:40:11 +0200

Quoted 1 line

[]

Quoted 7 lines

eventhough people often write only when they have something to complain about, I for once would like to congratulate Matti and David, our mail admins, for the wonderful job they've done with the spams lately. This month, I might have seen maybe one or two instead of perhaps 30 per day earlier. While it did not bother me that much earlier, I can say that the list is more pleasant to read every day, and I think that's great.

Quoted 6 lines

Kudos guys !

Willy

PS: please do not start another one of those long useless threads from now on

Instead let me share an idea and see what will happen (if any). The mailing list policy:

1. sent mails must have in-reply-to (rfc2821 SHOULD) with valid, i.e. existing in archives, message-id;

2. otherwise sender gets response about creating new thread. Replying to that message will enable (1).

I don't know how performance of ever increasing anti-spam rules/software grow vs message-id lookup will be affected.

Gmane shows good performance on load, which is times bigger than LKML's. News server requires unique ids, so...

Ah, if spammers will become smart and will reply with appropriate headers set up, everything will fall apart.

Finally. What i see:
* no spam,
* big patch-bombs in one thread (easy to skip)
* more order, if useless/obsolete footers removed, but such info is sent in (2).

* easy blacklisting if rules are not obeyed since day X

Oh, no, don't say we value bug reports. Reports must be organized in other way, one of which i've described as development tracking system. Such e-mail policy is unavoidable part of this it. E-mail is everything it requires. Of course some html, css, javascript, perl guys will be free to implement any web-face they like. But story if git-web have something to learn instead.
--
-o--=O`C
#oo'L O
<___=E M

#2 lore raw
Quoted 17 lines · Oleg Verych

* Tue, 31 Jul 2007 23:40:11 +0200

Quoted 1 line

[]

Quoted 7 lines

eventhough people often write only when they have something to complain about, I for once would like to congratulate Matti and David, our mail admins, for the wonderful job they've done with the spams lately. This month, I might have seen maybe one or two instead of perhaps 30 per day earlier. While it did not bother me that much earlier, I can say that the list is more pleasant to read every day, and I think that's great.

Quoted 6 lines

Kudos guys !

Willy

PS: please do not start another one of those long useless threads from now on

Quoted 8 lines

Instead let me share an idea and see what will happen (if any). The mailing list policy:

1. sent mails must have in-reply-to (rfc2821 SHOULD) with valid, i.e. existing in archives, message-id;

2. otherwise sender gets response about creating new thread. Replying to that message will enable (1).

Ehrm, you want everyone who wants to start a new thread to:

- send an email
- await response from the mail server
- send the same email again as a reply to the first one

Did I get that right? If so, good luck running from anyone who doesn't send his patch series as a bunch of replies to a 00/XX message.

Although it would likely be fun to see the next guy that sends a 600 emails patch bomb getting buried alive in "Please confirm that you want to create a new thread" emails.

Björn

#3 lore raw

On Sun, Sep 02, 2007 at 02:39:36AM +0200, Bj?rn Steinbrink wrote:
[]

Quoted 6 lines

Ehrm, you want everyone who wants to start a new thread to:

- send an email
- await response from the mail server
- send the same email again as a reply to the first one

No. Send a ticket request and then organize patch bomb with gotten ticket in references:' or in-reply-to'. New discussion thread: be organized have a pull of tickets, care about what you post, how you post, etc.

Those new posters will get current footer with more info -- no problem.

People in thread need no work at all. Linus, Andrew, Jeff, DaveM etc. are likely to be in white list with no additional work also.

It's anti-spam thing, but maybe it can be kind of netiquette, which is forgotten in modern XML Internet world. I didn't live in that time, but that's my impression. In case if efficient algo/logic will be implemented it will save CPU power, because all processing is done in header part of the message and it's a token lookup. Switch on your imagination and think, what can be done in another way, why not?
____

#4 lore raw
Quoted 18 lines · Oleg Verych

On Sun, Sep 02, 2007 at 02:39:36AM +0200, Bj?rn Steinbrink wrote:
[]

Quoted 6 lines

Ehrm, you want everyone who wants to start a new thread to:

- send an email
- await response from the mail server
- send the same email again as a reply to the first one

No. Send a ticket request and then organize patch bomb with gotten ticket in references:' or in-reply-to'. New discussion thread: be organized have a pull of tickets, care about what you post, how you post, etc.

Those new posters will get current footer with more info -- no problem.

People in thread need no work at all. Linus, Andrew, Jeff, DaveM etc. are likely to be in white list with no additional work also.

Quoted 6 lines

It's anti-spam thing, but maybe it can be kind of netiquette, which is forgotten in modern XML Internet world. I didn't live in that time, but that's my impression. In case if efficient algo/logic will be implemented it will save CPU power, because all processing is done in header part of the message and it's a token lookup. Switch on your imagination and think, what can be done in another way, why not?

While probably efficient for a few months, it will be terribly boring to use. I would most probably unsubscribe from then. The most efficient system against spammers is not to annoy the users, but the spammers. Otherwise they win.

Your method makes it trivial for them to request 1 ticket, then send 10000 mails which will be accepted without ever being filtered. It will result in an increase of the number of spams and a great annoyance for the users. Not for me, thanks :-/

Willy

#5 lore raw

On Sun, Sep 02, 2007 at 10:18:36AM +0200, Willy Tarreau wrote:
[]

Quoted 2 lines

Your method

as i mentioned

Quoted 3 lines

makes it trivial for them to request 1 ticket, then send 10000 mails which will be accepted without ever being filtered. It will result in an increase of the number of spams and a great annoyance for the users.

It's metter of experiment to know how much spammers today

* compose messages with non outloock default headers

* have *valid* reply address
** if it's valid and message to get ticket looks spammy as well as message
after ticket does, address gets blacklisted forever

* bother about published email address' policy

Quoted 1 line

Not for me, thanks :-/

You know, after requests like "we need more man power to handle mail lists" i wonder in what century we are leaving XXI or IIX?

OTHO Gmane is an excellent example of applying NNTP structure, that is very superior to mailing lists concept. But as i mentioned, i don't know whole story about USENET vs Mailing lists. I just speculate, that latter was established as an private entity, that groups of people can handle as they need and want.

But NNTP isn't USENET, and only Gmane shows how it lets people like me to handle tens of thousand emails in nearly 60 mailing lists (not only reading up to date, but archives easily). And frankly, i just pissed off by "6 day lkml archive, please", "Adrian, your email is bouncing, bla bla...". I'd better see spam, then dumb things like that, see?
____