Skip to contentSkip to conversation

ck vs. cfs : realtime audio performance

DISCUSSION Lenar Lõhmus 3 participants 4 messages Jul 31, 2007 – Aug 2, 2007 2 messages not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): 1185870355.7933.55.camel@klaus-laptop

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): 1185886161.7397.11.camel@klaus-laptop

#2 lore raw

Cc'd to LKML & Ingo.

L.

Quoted 74 lines · Klaus Schulz

Hi there.

Am Dienstag, den 31.07.2007, 10:26 +0200 schrieb Klaus Schulz:

Quoted 22 lines

Hi folks.

I am currently testing the 2.6.22.1 cfs-rt9 vs. ck1 on my rather pure
realtime high-end-audio setup. (NO X, just a terminal, streaming .wav. I am using my own written player and brutefir as the audio engine.)
Comment: This is not a standard (amarok or xmms setup), all buffers in
the chain are very small. Any problem will immidetialy end up in xruns.
The sounddriver, HW (pci-bus etc.) are tweaked accordingly

Until now ck1 on 2.6.22 is giving me better results (less audible
distortions) and runs extremely stable compared to cfs. Under ck I ran my player with schedtool -R -p 98, which was better than running it e.g. with nice -20 Both setups under cfs were giving me worse results than ck.
With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened
with ck.

However:

When looking at the latest performance statistics cfs vs. ck which are spread around here, I am wondering, what might cause the differences.

With ck I tweaked the rr_interval to 6 and was running at 10000Hz, which caused obvious improvements.

Quoted 7 lines

These options I do not have with CFS.

I am wondering if sched_granularity_ns should be touched when using cfs. I googled somewhere that bringing it down to e.g. 250000 instead of 4000000 would smoothen the audio playback. I havn't tried it yet. I am wondering if this tweak is still applicable.

I did test now decreasing the sched_granularity_ns to 250000.
There is still a clearly audible difference comparing ck and cfs. ck Ídelivers cristal clear sound. With cfs I still get quite some distortions.

Any hints how to improve the situtation are welcome.

Quoted 10 lines

I'd be happy to get a hint on how to tweak the system parameters best to give cfs a fair chance. I am also wondering how the timer freqency could by increased under a cfs-patched kernel.

Info: dynamic ticks and IRQ balancing are off for the time being.
/proc/sys/dev/rtc is set to 4096 (gave me best results) ( I don't have a clue how all the (rtc)-timers in the OS interact,
To me it is just a trial and error exercise to figure out which setup sounds best)

Quoted 5 lines

THX for your advise.

Cheers
\Klaus

Cheers
\Klaus

_______________________________________________
http://ck.kolivas.org/faqs/replying-to-mailing-list.txt
ck mailing list - mailto: [email protected]
http://vds.kolivas.org/mailman/listinfo/ck

#3 lore raw
Quoted 26 lines
Quoted 26 lines

Am Dienstag, den 31.07.2007, 10:26 +0200 schrieb Klaus Schulz:

Quoted 23 lines

I am currently testing the 2.6.22.1 cfs-rt9 vs. ck1 on my rather pure realtime high-end-audio setup. (NO X, just a terminal, streaming .wav. I am using my own written player and brutefir as the audio engine.)
Comment: This is not a standard (amarok or xmms setup), all buffers in the chain are very small. Any problem will immidetialy end up in xruns. The sounddriver, HW (pci-bus etc.) are tweaked accordingly

Until now ck1 on 2.6.22 is giving me better results (less audible distortions) and runs extremely stable compared to cfs. Under ck I ran my player with schedtool -R -p 98, which was better than running it e.g. with nice -20
Both setups under cfs were giving me worse results than ck. With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened with ck.

However:

When looking at the latest performance statistics cfs vs. ck which are spread around here, I am wondering, what might cause the differences.

With ck I tweaked the rr_interval to 6 and was running at 10000Hz, which caused obvious improvements.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines

These options I do not have with CFS.

I am wondering if sched_granularity_ns should be touched when using cfs. I googled somewhere that bringing it down to e.g. 250000 instead of 4000000 would smoothen the audio playback. I havn't tried it yet. I am wondering if this tweak is still applicable.

(re-sending my earlier reply to Klaus here on lkml too)

Klaus,

since you are using -rt, have you tried chrt-ing not only your audio player but your audio IRQ as well? While playback is going on could you create a system snapshot with the following tool:

http://people.redhat.com/mingo/cfs-scheduler/tools/cfs-debug-info.sh

and send me the output file.

i'm also wondering why HZ=10000 makes a difference - audio interrupts have no Linux-timer aspect normally (they are hardware timers in essence themselves) - which portion of the workload is timing out so that HZ shows up? Does the enabling of CONFIG_HIGH_RES_TIMERS help perhaps?

Also, do you have any advice for me how to reproduce your problem? I've got a couple of PCs with various low-end/chipset-based audio hw, but the buffers are generally large (around 500 msecs) so i rarely run into any xrun problems. Is your player available for download so i could try it?

Ingo

#4 lore raw
In reply to Lenar Lõhmus
Quoted 11 lines · Lenar Lõhmus
Quoted 10 lines · Klaus Schulz
Quoted 10 lines

I am currently testing the 2.6.22.1 cfs-rt9 vs. ck1 on my rather pure
realtime high-end-audio setup. (NO X, just a terminal, streaming .wav. I am using my own written player and brutefir as the audio engine.)
Comment: This is not a standard (amarok or xmms setup), all buffers in
the chain are very small. Any problem will immidetialy end up in xruns.
The sounddriver, HW (pci-bus etc.) are tweaked accordingly
Until now ck1 on 2.6.22 is giving me better results (less audible
distortions) and runs extremely stable compared to cfs. Under ck I ran my player with schedtool -R -p 98, which was better than running it e.g. with nice -20 Both setups under cfs were giving me worse results than ck.
With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened
with ck.

See, this is exactly the problem of the SD ranters. A ranter posts a problem, doesn't give reproducability hints, and neither provides technical detail, not even the slightest relevant stats. And the most irritating part is that the code that the OP wrote (or at least its relevant parts) is not even available for download.

I was wondering why the OP need timers for audio playback. What type of audio? PCM, MIDI? Once does not need timers for PCM playback but for MIDI.

SD ranters. Pure rants.

Thank you very much.

Best Regards,

Carlo

Signature · 27 lines
Carlo Florendo
Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator
Astra Philippines Inc.
UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman
1101 Quezon City, Philippines
http://www.astra.ph

--
The Astra Group of Companies
5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City
Tokyo 206-0011, Japan
http://www.astra.co.jp


-- 
Carlo Florendo
Softare Engineer/Network Co-Administrator
Astra Philippines Inc.
UP-Ayala Technopark, UP Campus Diliman
1101 Quezon City, Philippines
http://www.astra.ph

--
The Astra Group of Companies
5-3-11 Sekido, Tama City
Tokyo 206-0011, Japan
http://www.astra.co.jp
#5 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Carlo Florendo
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

With CFS I also experienced XRUNS from time to time, what never happened with ck.

See, this is exactly the problem of the SD ranters. A ranter posts a problem, doesn't give reproducability hints, and neither provides technical detail, not even the slightest relevant stats. And the most irritating part is that the code that the OP wrote (or at least its relevant parts) is not even available for download.

actually, there was no "SD ranting" going on at all. Klaus reported a problem, Martin forwarded it to me, i replied to it and Klaus gave me lots of debug info in a very professional way. So please calm down and lets get back to the tech topics, ok? (and i'd like to apologize here to Karl and Martin for the rough and unjust treatment they received on lkml.)

Ingo