USB attached SATA disk idle spindown
Dear list,
I am looking for what the current state of USB SATA timed spindown of- disks is ata this time. I've been reading documents and mailing lists- for every possible search I can dream up on the subject. Suggested- workable solutions include (but are probably not limited to):
$ hdparm -S
This seems to be the ATA way of telling a disk to spin down, and it
works in some situations, but doesn't appear to work on USB attached
disks under 2.6.25$ sdparm
This is suggested in a small number of locations. Most of which have
examples on how to disable STANDBY on a handful of devices. I am
unable to find any evidence that it can actually be used to enable
power saving.$ scsi_spin
Requires the disk to be unmounted, and I can't find anything saying
that this is how the world is supposed to be.-I'm hoping that perhaps I'm missing something from this list.
I don't really know whether this is a topic for the scsi people, or the- SATA people, or the USB people. So I'm asking here instead to try and get my first hints from the parent group.
Thanks in advance,
hachi
------------------------------------------------------------------------
"She smiled again, shrugged her shoulders, and became a perfect mirror."
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(adding Cc: linux-usb and Johannes Niess)
On 6/24/2008 6:59 AM, Jonathan Steinert wrote at LKML:
Quoted 12 lines
Dear list,
I am looking for what the current state of USB SATA timed spindown of- disks is ata this time. I've been reading documents and mailing lists- for every possible search I can dream up on the subject. Suggested- workable solutions include (but are probably not limited to):
$ hdparm -S This seems to be the ATA way of telling a disk to spin down, and it works in some situations, but doesn't appear to work on USB attached disks under 2.6.25
Quoted 5 lines
$ sdparm
This is suggested in a small number of locations. Most of which have
examples on how to disable STANDBY on a handful of devices. I am
unable to find any evidence that it can actually be used to enable
power saving.I think either of these depend on specific support by the USB to SATA bridge firmware.
I hear some newer bridges and their firmwares implement ATA pass-through. Would that help?
Quoted 3 lines
$ scsi_spin
Requires the disk to be unmounted, and I can't find anything saying
that this is how the world is supposed to be.-Johannes recently informed me that he wrote a script which is used like a background daemon to stop idle USB disks. The script uses
- "cat /sys/block/${device}/stat" to watch disk activity,
- "sdparm -q -C stop /dev/${device}" to stop the motor after longer inactivity.
Quoted 9 lines
I'm hoping that perhaps I'm missing something from this list.
I don't really know whether this is a topic for the scsi people, or the- SATA people, or the USB people. So I'm asking here instead to try and get my first hints from the parent group.
Thanks in advance,
hachi
IMO it is firstly an USB topic because it depends on the features and behaviour of the bridge and its firmware.
(PS: Don't have too high expectations of $15 devices.)
Signature · 3 lines
Stefan Richter -=====-==--- -==- ==--- http://arcgraph.de/sr/
Quoted 5 lines · Stefan Richter
Johannes recently informed me that he wrote a script which is used like a background daemon to stop idle USB disks. The script uses
- "cat/sys/block/${device}/stat" to watch disk activity,
- "sdparm -q -C stop/dev/${device}" to stop the motor after longer inactivity.
PS: I have seen START STOP UNIT with START=0 to be dangerous with some FireWire firmwares. (Motor cannot be restarted after that anymore.) Other firmwares ignore the START bit and look only at the POWER CONDITIONS field. I expect various similar firmware quirks in USB land.
Signature · 3 lines
Stefan Richter -=====-==--- -==- ==--- http://arcgraph.de/sr/
Quoted 21 lines · Stefan Richter
(adding Cc: linux-usb and Johannes Niess)
On 6/24/2008 6:59 AM, Jonathan Steinert wrote at LKML:
Quoted 12 lines
Dear list,
I am looking for what the current state of USB SATA timed spindown of- disks is ata this time. I've been reading documents and mailing lists- for every possible search I can dream up on the subject. Suggested- workable solutions include (but are probably not limited to):
$ hdparm -S This seems to be the ATA way of telling a disk to spin down, and it works in some situations, but doesn't appear to work on USB attached disks under 2.6.25Quoted 5 lines
$ sdparm This is suggested in a small number of locations. Most of which have examples on how to disable STANDBY on a handful of devices. I am unable to find any evidence that it can actually be used to enable power saving.
Quoted 5 lines
I think either of these depend on specific support by the USB to SATA bridge firmware.
I hear some newer bridges and their firmwares implement ATA pass-through. Would that help?
Yeah, ATA pass through is all that's needed for hdparm -S to work.
Signature · 1 line
tejun