POLL: for/against dropping support for kernels < 2.6.22
Hi Hans,
Quoted 8 lines
There are lot's of discussions, but it can be hard sometimes to actually determine someone's opinion.
So here is a quick poll, please reply either to the list or directly to me with your yes/no answer and (optional but welcome) a short explanation to your standpoint. It doesn't matter if you are a user or developer, I'd like to see your opinion regardless.
Quoted 5 lines
Please DO NOT reply to the replies, I'll summarize the results in a week's time and then we can discuss it further.
Should we drop support for kernels <2.6.22 in our v4l-dvb repository?
X: Yes
Quoted 5 lines
_: No
Optional question:
Why:
The cost to preserve backwards compatibility for these old kernels is much too high compared to the remaining user-base. I can only repeat the points I have made in the past week:
* Maintained distributions aimed at home users (Fedora, openSUSE) run kernels >= 2.6.22 by now.
* Enterprise-class distributions (RHEL, SLED) are not the right target for the v4l-dvb repository, so we don't care which kernels these are running.
* Engineering time which is put into backwards compatibility would be better spent on improving the drivers upstream and adding support for new hardware faster.
* v4l-dvb depends on subsystems which do evolve, and when these changes are too important (e.g. new i2c device driver binding model) backwards compatibility comes are an unbearable complexity and cost. That kind of cost sucks the time of current developers, might turn them into ex-developers when they realize they lost all the fun, and prevents new developers from joining the project because of the complexity of the compatibility layer.
So let's just drop support for kernels < 2.6.22 and focus on better supporting upstream and recent kernels.
Thanks,
Signature · 1 line
Jean Delvare
Quoted 8 lines · Jean Delvare
Quoted 8 lines
There are lot's of discussions, but it can be hard sometimes to actually determine someone's opinion.
So here is a quick poll, please reply either to the list or directly to me with your yes/no answer and (optional but welcome) a short explanation to your standpoint. It doesn't matter if you are a user or developer, I'd like to see your opinion regardless.
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Please DO NOT reply to the replies, I'll summarize the results in a week's time and then we can discuss it further.
Should we drop support for kernels <2.6.22 in our v4l-dvb repository?
Does this mean keep our current system and move the backward compatibility point to 2.6.22?
Or not have any backward compatibilty at all?
Quoted 3 lines · Jean Delvare
* Enterprise-class distributions (RHEL, SLED) are not the right target for the v4l-dvb repository, so we don't care which kernels these are running.
I think you should be aware that the mythtv and ATrpms communities include a significant number of people who have chosen to use the CentOS_5 series in the hope of getting systems that do not need to be reinstalled every few months. I hope you won't disappoint them.
John P
Quoted 10 lines · John Pilkington
Quoted 3 lines · Jean Delvare
* Enterprise-class distributions (RHEL, SLED) are not the right target for the v4l-dvb repository, so we don't care which kernels these are running.
I think you should be aware that the mythtv and ATrpms communities include a significant number of people who have chosen to use the
CentOS_5series in the hope of getting systems that do not need to be reinstalled every few months. I hope you won't disappoint them.John P
just had a quick look at mythtv-users
there are a handful using centos
--
simon
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Hi John,
(re-adding linux-media on Cc as I doubt you dropped it on purpose...)
Quoted 10 lines · John Pilkington
Quoted 3 lines · Jean Delvare
* Enterprise-class distributions (RHEL, SLED) are not the right target for the v4l-dvb repository, so we don't care which kernels these are running.
I think you should be aware that the mythtv and ATrpms communities include a significant number of people who have chosen to use the
CentOS_5series in the hope of getting systems that do not need to be reinstalled every few months. I hope you won't disappoint them.
CentOS is a parasite, if it dies I can't care less. CentOS users have the recurrent habit to expect professional support from the community without giving anything in return. Even worse: they consider that running an antediluvian OS is the default and they don't understand why upstream developers won't help them.
You said it yourself: they expect to be able to keep the same system for a long time. This is a service you normally get from Red Hat or Novell, and you pay for it. This is something the community is generally not willing to offer for free, because it is not fun.
If the MythTV community cares that much about the v4l-dvb tree, they are free to fork it right before support for kernel 2.6.18 is dropped, and maintain that copy themselves. But their model is broken to start with:
sticking to a several-year-old kernel and OS, and OTOH picking critical (for their use case) kernel drivers from a development tree which evolves continuously by definition, makes little sense. Then again, I would be happy to keep support for them if the cost wasn't too high. But right now, the cost _is_ too high.
Your view of community distributions is a bit too negative BTW. You don't need to go to the extreme CentOS_5 is to not have to reinstall every few months. openSUSE distributions are maintained for 2 years for example.
Signature · 1 line
Jean Delvare
Hi Jean:
Quoted 3 lines · Jean Delvare
Hi John,
(re-adding linux-media on Cc as I doubt you dropped it on purpose...)
Right: I do subconsciously expect 'reply' to go to the list, and don't always remember to check first. No doubt you got two copies.
Quoted 15 lines · John Pilkington
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines · Jean Delvare
* Enterprise-class distributions (RHEL, SLED) are not the right target for the v4l-dvb repository, so we don't care which kernels these are running.
I think you should be aware that the mythtv and ATrpms communities include a significant number of people who have chosen to use the
CentOS_5series in the hope of getting systems that do not need to be reinstalled every few months. I hope you won't disappoint them.CentOS is a parasite, if it dies I can't care less. CentOS users have the recurrent habit to expect professional support from the community without giving anything in return. Even worse: they consider that running an antediluvian OS is the default and they don't understand why upstream developers won't help them.
Quoted 4 lines
You said it yourself: they expect to be able to keep the same system for a long time. This is a service you normally get from Red Hat or Novell, and you pay for it. This is something the community is generally not willing to offer for free, because it is not fun.
I know there is a range of visions from linux-as-playground to linux-as-tool. Sometimes just learning to use the tool is not a trivial matter, and shows enthusiasm too. I recognize that enthusiasm is the great driver of development, but would still hope that users might expect to be able to slow their personal treadmills without actually falling off. :-)
Quoted 15 lines
If the MythTV community cares that much about the v4l-dvb tree, they are free to fork it right before support for kernel 2.6.18 is dropped, and maintain that copy themselves. But their model is broken to start with:
sticking to a several-year-old kernel and OS, and OTOH picking critical (for their use case) kernel drivers from a development tree which evolves continuously by definition, makes little sense. Then again, I would be happy to keep support for them if the cost wasn't too high. But right now, the cost _is_ too high.Your view of community distributions is a bit too negative BTW. You don't need to go to the extreme
CentOS_5is to not have to reinstall every few months. openSUSE distributions are maintained for 2 years for example.