Slower performance with lookupcache (2.6.30.2)
Subsystems (2)
Hello :)
I just noticed something interesting while benchmarking NFSv3 versus GlusterFS. With lookupcache enabled (all or positive), it seems that successive executions of "du" are slower the second and further times. With lookupcache disabled, second and further executions are slightly faster than the first but still slower than with lookupcache enabled:
# umount /nfs ; mount -t nfs 10.10.52.30:/home/nfs /nfs -o lookupcache=positive && repeat 3 /bin/sh -c 'time du -s /nfs/test ; sleep 3' 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m1.670s user 0m0.028s sys 0m0.344s 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m4.030s user 0m0.052s sys 0m0.536s 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m4.025s user 0m0.060s sys 0m0.608s
With lookupcache=none:
# umount /nfs ; mount -t nfs 10.10.52.30:/home/nfs /nfs -o lookupcache=none && repeat 3 /bin/sh -c 'time du -s /nfs/test ; sleep 3' 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m5.362s user 0m0.044s sys 0m0.924s 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m4.496s user 0m0.060s sys 0m0.828s 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m4.497s user 0m0.052s sys 0m0.780s
In this case, /nfs/test is just a copy of /usr made on the server. The only difference is "lookupcache". When set to "all" or "positive", the first sweep is much faster than "none", but the following sweeps are slower.
nfsstat shows that "getattr" is called many more times on the second and third sweeps:
# umount /nfs ; mount -t nfs 10.10.52.30:/home/nfs /nfs -o lookupcache=all && repeat 3 /bin/sh -c 'cat /proc/net/rpc/nfs > /tmp/x ; time du -s /nfs/test ; nfsstat -c3 -S /tmp/x ; sleep 3' 494616 /nfs/test
real 0m1.684s user 0m0.036s sys 0m0.316s Client rpc stats: calls retrans authrefrsh 8622 0 0
Client nfs v3:
null getattr setattr lookup access readlink
0 0% 3649 42% 0 0% 820 9% 1826 21% 0 0%
read write create mkdir symlink mknod
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
remove rmdir rename link readdir readdirplus
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 8 0% 2319 26%
fsstat fsinfo pathconf commit
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
494616 /nfs/test
real 0m3.975s user 0m0.052s sys 0m0.672s Client rpc stats: calls retrans authrefrsh 25076 0 0
Client nfs v3:
null getattr setattr lookup access readlink
0 0% 25076 100% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
read write create mkdir symlink mknod
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
remove rmdir rename link readdir readdirplus
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
fsstat fsinfo pathconf commit
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
494616 /nfs/test
real 0m4.010s user 0m0.056s sys 0m0.616s Client rpc stats: calls retrans authrefrsh 25076 0 0
Client nfs v3:
null getattr setattr lookup access readlink
0 0% 25076 100% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
read write create mkdir symlink mknod
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
remove rmdir rename link readdir readdirplus
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
fsstat fsinfo pathconf commit
0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
Adding "echo 1 > /proc/sys/vm/drop_caches" to the repeat loop makes the readdirplus calls happen each time, but still with increased getattrs. With "echo 2 > /proc/sys/vm/drop_caches" instead, behaviour is always fast (~1.6 seconds).
The lookupcache here seems to be increasing initial performance but then seems to slow down cached performance by causing more getattrs than with no lookupcache, perhaps for revalidation tests.
This is stock 2.6.30.2 on the server and client, NFSv3, EXT3 on the server.
Simon-
Quoted 3 lines · Simon Kirby
The lookupcache here seems to be increasing initial performance but then seems to slow down cached performance by causing more getattrs than with no lookupcache, perhaps for revalidation tests.
Yes. This is expected behaviour.
When you look up a dentry, you are also retrieving its attributes, so the stat() call, can be entirely handled by the single LOOKUP rpc call.
If you are caching the dentries, then your stat() call doesn't need to do a lookup, but it still needs to return valid attributes. Since acregmin=3 seconds, then your test is likely to have to revalidate a couple of times. However as long as there are no changes to the file, then the attribute caching algorithm should get progressively more aggressive. I'd therefore expect that if you change that to 'repeat 10' or so, then the lookupcache=all/positive cases should show an improvement.
Trond
Quoted 10 lines · Trond Myklebust
Quoted 3 lines · Simon Kirby
The lookupcache here seems to be increasing initial performance but then seems to slow down cached performance by causing more getattrs than with no lookupcache, perhaps for revalidation tests.
Yes. This is expected behaviour.
When you look up a dentry, you are also retrieving its attributes, so the
stat()call, can be entirely handled by the single LOOKUP rpc call.
Quoted 8 lines
If you are caching the dentries, then your
stat()call doesn't need to do a lookup, but it still needs to return valid attributes. Since acregmin=3 seconds, then your test is likely to have to revalidate a couple of times. However as long as there are no changes to the file, then the attribute caching algorithm should get progressively more aggressive. I'd therefore expect that if you change that to 'repeat 10' or so, then the lookupcache=all/positive cases should show an improvement.
Ahh, yes, I see, there is. If I run it longer, I see that it gets even faster (0.6 seconds) for the forth run and then after a few more, back up to 4 seconds once. That makes sense now.
You say that LOOKUP is returning the attributes as well -- is it not possible to operate the same way doing revalidation? I was surprised that there are so many fewer RPC calls during the first run (8622 calls versus 25076 calls). But, I suppose it's just readdirplus batching some information together in a single call (since there are 23,650 files and directories in the tree), and we probably wouldn't want to readdir all the time.
Cheers,
Simon-
Quoted 2 lines · Simon Kirby
You say that LOOKUP is returning the attributes as well -- is it not possible to operate the same way doing revalidation?
I'm not sure I understand you. Do you mean issue LOOKUP calls instead of GETATTR calls when revalidating the file attribute information? Sure we could, but LOOKUP is a more expensive operation than GETATTR on most
platforms: it requires the server to retrieve and process information from both the parent directory and the file.
Trond