Skip to contentSkip to conversation

New idea about RAID and SSD

DISCUSSION Massimo Maggi 3 participants 3 messages Sep 1, 2009 Btrfs file system

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,
SSDs have low latency but a high price per GB,
Traditional hard disks have high latency, but high sequential read/write speed and low price per GB.
Is possibile to use a SSD for metadata, which requires many seeks and is relatively small, in a special "RAID mode" with a traditional hard disk for the extents of the real data?
A cheap but performant SSD (maybe 32 GB) + a big and fast HD (maybe 1.5 TB, or two in RAID0 - 3TB ), wouldn't create an array much cheaper than a ssd-only array of the same size, and much faster (in not-only-sequential workload) than one or two traditional HDs in RAID0? Would it work?
Thank you for your precious time!
Massimo Maggi
[email protected]

#1 lore raw

Hello Massimo,

Massimo Maggi wrote (ao):

Quoted 11 lines

SSDs have low latency but a high price per GB,
Traditional hard disks have high latency, but high sequential read/write speed and low price per GB.
Is possibile to use a SSD for metadata, which requires many seeks and is relatively small, in a special "RAID mode" with a traditional hard disk for the extents of the real data?
A cheap but performant SSD (maybe 32 GB) + a big and fast HD (maybe 1.5 TB, or two in RAID0 - 3TB ), wouldn't create an array much cheaper than a ssd-only array of the same size, and much faster (in not-only-sequential workload) than one or two traditional HDs in RAID0? Would it work?

If you talk RAID0 (eg no redundancy), you could RAID0 one or several traditional disks, and use the SSD as a journal device. That would be ext3/4 only btw.

With mdadm you could create a RAID1 and use --write-mostly:

-W, --write-mostly
subsequent devices listed in a --build, --create, or --add com- mand will be flagged as 'write-mostly'. This is valid for RAID1 only and means that the 'md' driver will avoid reading from these devices if at all possible. This can be useful if mirror- ing over a slow link.

Where the 'slow link' would be the traditional disk. But this is raid1 and doesn't help in your case (but couldn't resist the need to mention it :-)

Sander

Signature · 2 lines
Humilis IT Services and Solutions
http://www.humilis.net
#2 lore raw
In reply to Massimo Maggi
Quoted 7 lines · Massimo Maggi

Hi,
SSDs have low latency but a high price per GB,
Traditional hard disks have high latency, but high sequential read/write speed and low price per GB.
Is possibile to use a SSD for metadata, which requires many seeks and is relatively small, in a special "RAID mode" with a traditional hard disk for the extents of the real data?

Quoted 8 lines

A cheap but performant SSD (maybe 32 GB) + a big and fast HD (maybe 1.5 TB, or two in RAID0 - 3TB ), wouldn't create an array much cheaper than a ssd-only array of the same size, and much faster (in not-only-sequential workload) than one or two traditional HDs in RAID0? Would it work?
Thank you for your precious time!
Massimo Maggi
[email protected]

well, it is not a "new" idea.

yes people are thinking about it, but it is not the most critical work on the list of things to do for btrfs or any other linux fs.

jim