Questions about Multi-touch Protocal
Hi, all.
I have some questions about Multi-touch(MT) Protocal.
First, what is the purpose of ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR event? I wonder how it is used at userspace side.
Should the ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR be the mininum set of events for multi touch? I'm not sure whether this question is valid because of first question.
Finally, what is difference of ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR and ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR?
I read the MT Protocol document of kernel, but i cannot understand above things clearly.
Thanks.
Hi Joonyoung,
Quoted 1 line
I have some questions about Multi-touch(MT) Protocal.
Let me start by answering your last question:
Quoted 2 lines
Finally, what is difference of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORandABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR?
The TOUCH and WIDTH parameters have a geometrical interpretation; imagine looking through a window at someone gently holding a finger against the glass. You will see two regions, one inner region consisting of the part of the finger actually touching the glass, and one outer region formed by the perimeter of the finger. The diameter of the inner region is the ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR, the diameter of the outer region is ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR. Now imagine the person pressing the finger harder against the glass. The inner region will increase, and in general, the ratio ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR / ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR, which is always smaller than unity, is related to the finger pressure.
In addition to the MAJOR parameters, the oval shape of the finger can be described by adding the MINOR parameters, such that MAJOR and MINOR are the major and minor axis of an ellipse. Finally, the orientation of the oval shape can be describe with the ORIENTATION parameter.
Quoted 2 lines
First, what is the purpose of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORevent? I wonder how it is used at userspace side.
In a graphical program it can of course be used as is, but in the specific application of creating gesture events, the TOUCH and WIDTH parameters can be used to, e.g., approximate finger pressure or distinguish between index finger and thumb. With the addition of the MINOR parameters, one can also distinguish between a sweeping finger and a pointing finger, and with ORIENTATION, one can detect twisting of fingers.
Quoted 3 lines
Should the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORbe the mininum set of events for multi touch? I'm not sure whether this question is valid because of first question.
Each finger packet should have an ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR value. In can be computed from various types of sensory input, e.g., the size of the contact area or a pressure sensor.
Hope this explains it a bit further.
Quoted 10 lines
The TOUCH and WIDTH parameters have a geometrical interpretation; imagine looking through a window at someone gently holding a finger against the glass. You will see two regions, one inner region consisting of the part of the finger actually touching the glass, and one outer region formed by the perimeter of the finger. The diameter of the inner region is the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR, the diameter of the outer region isABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR. Now imagine the person pressing the finger harder against the glass. The inner region will increase, and in general, the ratioABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR/ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR, which is always smaller than unity, is related to the finger pressure.
Quoted 6 lines
In addition to the MAJOR parameters, the oval shape of the finger can be described by adding the MINOR parameters, such that MAJOR and MINOR are the major and minor axis of an ellipse. Finally, the orientation of the oval shape can be describe with the ORIENTATION parameter.
Hope this explains it a bit further.
Very interesting writeup, thanks a lot. Is there any currently any hardware which is available to end-users and does support these features? AFAIR most capacitive touchscreens don't have high enough resolution to actually detect, e.g., twisting. If there's a commercial option, I'd like to hear about it..
Florian
Signature · 1 line
0666 - Filemode of the Beast
Florian Echtler wrote:
[..]
Quoted 5 lines
Very interesting writeup, thanks a lot. Is there any currently any hardware which is available to end-users and does support these features? AFAIR most capacitive touchscreens don't have high enough resolution to actually detect, e.g., twisting. If there's a commercial option, I'd like to hear about it..
The post-2008 MacBooks all have a touchpad (bcm5974) which is capable of detecting finger twisting. A patch to enable the MT protocol in the bcm5974 driver is on it's way into the 2.6.33 kernel.
Quoted 38 lines · Henrik Rydberg
Hi Joonyoung,
Quoted 1 line
I have some questions about Multi-touch(MT) Protocal.
Let me start by answering your last question:
Quoted 2 lines
Finally, what is difference of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORandABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR?The TOUCH and WIDTH parameters have a geometrical interpretation; imagine looking through a window at someone gently holding a finger against the glass. You will see two regions, one inner region consisting of the part of the finger actually touching the glass, and one outer region formed by the perimeter of the finger. The diameter of the inner region is the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR, the diameter of the outer region isABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR. Now imagine the person pressing the finger harder against the glass. The inner region will increase, and in general, the ratioABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR/ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR, which is always smaller than unity, is related to the finger pressure.In addition to the MAJOR parameters, the oval shape of the finger can be described by adding the MINOR parameters, such that MAJOR and MINOR are the major and minor axis of an ellipse. Finally, the orientation of the oval shape can be describe with the ORIENTATION parameter.
Quoted 2 lines
First, what is the purpose of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORevent? I wonder how it is used at userspace side.In a graphical program it can of course be used as is, but in the specific application of creating gesture events, the TOUCH and WIDTH parameters can be used to, e.g., approximate finger pressure or distinguish between index finger and thumb. With the addition of the MINOR parameters, one can also distinguish between a sweeping finger and a pointing finger, and with ORIENTATION, one can detect twisting of fingers.
Quoted 3 lines
Should the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORbe the mininum set of events for multi touch? I'm not sure whether this question is valid because of first question.
Quoted 6 lines
Each finger packet should have an
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORvalue. In can be computed from various types of sensory input, e.g., the size of the contact area or a pressure sensor.Hope this explains it a bit further.
Very nice explanation, Henrik. Any chance you could turn it into a patch to Documentation/input/multi-touch-protocol.txt?
Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
Quoted 9 lines · Henrik Rydberg
Hi Joonyoung,
Quoted 1 line
I have some questions about Multi-touch(MT) Protocal.
Let me start by answering your last question:
Quoted 2 lines
Finally, what is difference of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORandABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR?
Quoted 10 lines
The TOUCH and WIDTH parameters have a geometrical interpretation; imagine looking through a window at someone gently holding a finger against the glass. You will see two regions, one inner region consisting of the part of the finger actually touching the glass, and one outer region formed by the perimeter of the finger. The diameter of the inner region is the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR, the diameter of the outer region isABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR. Now imagine the person pressing the finger harder against the glass. The inner region will increase, and in general, the ratioABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR/ABS_MT_WIDTH_MAJOR, which is always smaller than unity, is related to the finger pressure.
Aha, i understand :)
Quoted 15 lines
In addition to the MAJOR parameters, the oval shape of the finger can be described by adding the MINOR parameters, such that MAJOR and MINOR are the major and minor axis of an ellipse. Finally, the orientation of the oval shape can be describe with the ORIENTATION parameter.
Quoted 2 lines
First, what is the purpose of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORevent? I wonder how it is used at userspace side.In a graphical program it can of course be used as is, but in the specific application of creating gesture events, the TOUCH and WIDTH parameters can be used to, e.g., approximate finger pressure or distinguish between index finger and thumb. With the addition of the MINOR parameters, one can also distinguish between a sweeping finger and a pointing finger, and with ORIENTATION, one can detect twisting of fingers.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Should the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORbe the mininum set of events for multi touch? I'm not sure whether this question is valid because of first question.Each finger packet should have an
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORvalue. In can be computed from various types of sensory input, e.g., the size of the contact area or a pressure sensor.
Hmm, I think ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR is similar to ABS_PRESSURE, of course it can be used other purposes. If the device doesn't support the pressure, the driver doesn't report ABS_PRESSURE, so if the device cannot get a touching size of the finger, how can the driver report it?
The ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR needs for several things as you explain, but i think it isn't essential event for multi-touch such ABS_PRESSURE. If we can get only the coodinates of each fingers, is it full enough for minimum supporting of multi-touch?
Thanks for explanation.
Joonyoung Shim wrote:
[..]
Quoted 5 lines
The
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORneeds for several things as you explain, but i think it isn't essential event for multi-touch suchABS_PRESSURE. If we can get only the coodinates of each fingers, is it full enough for minimum supporting of multi-touch?
Yes, it will be fine, one can drop ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR for minimal support of the MT protocol. I will change the documentation accordingly.
Henrik
Quoted 19 lines · Joonyoung Shim
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 2 lines
First, what is the purpose of
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORevent? I wonder how it is used at userspace side.In a graphical program it can of course be used as is, but in the specific application of creating gesture events, the TOUCH and WIDTH parameters can be used to, e.g., approximate finger pressure or distinguish between index finger and thumb. With the addition of the MINOR parameters, one can also distinguish between a sweeping finger and a pointing finger, and with ORIENTATION, one can detect twisting of fingers.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Should the
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORbe the mininum set of events for multi touch? I'm not sure whether this question is valid because of first question.Each finger packet should have an
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORvalue. In can be computed from various types of sensory input, e.g., the size of the contact area or a pressure sensor.
Quoted 4 lines
Hmm, I think
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORis similar toABS_PRESSURE, of course it can be used other purposes. If the device doesn't support the pressure, the driver doesn't reportABS_PRESSURE, so if the device cannot get a touching size of the finger, how can the driver report it?
Note that ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJOR complements ABS_PRESSURE but cannot substitute it. The nature of our fingures usually mean that with increasing pressure the touch size increases as the finger flattens. This is only useful as a relative indicator though, as fingers differ greatly in size.
Cheers,
Peter
Peter Hutterer wrote:
[..]
Quoted 4 lines
Note that
ABS_MT_TOUCH_MAJORcomplementsABS_PRESSUREbut cannot substitute it. The nature of our fingures usually mean that with increasing pressure the touch size increases as the finger flattens. This is only useful as a relative indicator though, as fingers differ greatly in size.
Ok, in my book this makes the third voice for an ABS_MT_PRESSURE parameter, so it should most likely be added. I will write a patch for it.
Cheers,
Henrik