Yet another dt3155 driver for drivers/staging
Hi all,
I would like to propose to your attention a driver for the dt3155 frame grabber I am using in my experiments since the time of 2.6.17 kernel.
It is realized as a character device (not as a v4l device) and is currently able to capture video frames in real time to HDD and display them simultaneously in the application window.
I will really appreciate your comments, suggestions, criticism.
As far as there is another driver already merged in linux-next for the same hardware is it worth to consider this one for merging too?
The driver code could be found here:
http://lfb.issp.bas.bg/~mitov/linux/dt3155pci/
Best regards,
Marin Mitov
Hi Marin,
Quoted 2 lines
dt3155 frame grabber I am using in my experiments since the time of 2.6.17 kernel.
Whoah!
Quoted 1 line
I will really appreciate your comments, suggestions, criticism.
I haven't tried your driver but the code looks much neater than our driver. Still, I am wondering why you chose to implement a device driver from scratch, rather than use an existing one?
http://sourceforge.net/projects/dt3155a/
I'll leave decisions about whether to merge or discard (either driver) to Greg. My 2 cents is that there should only be 1 DT3155 driver for users to choose from.
Scott. :)
Quoted 13 lines · Scott Smedley
Hi Marin,
Quoted 2 lines
dt3155 frame grabber I am using in my experiments since the time of 2.6.17 kernel.
Whoah!
Quoted 1 line
I will really appreciate your comments, suggestions, criticism.
I haven't tried your driver but the code looks much neater than our driver. Still, I am wondering why you chose to implement a device driver from scratch, rather than use an existing one?
Quoted 5 lines
http://sourceforge.net/projects/dt3155a/
I'll leave decisions about whether to merge or discard (either driver) to Greg. My 2 cents is that there should only be 1 DT3155 driver for users to choose from.
I agree, we only need one of them.
Scott, any comparison between the two of them as to which one actually works better?
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 8 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 7 lines · Scott Smedley
Hi Marin,
Quoted 2 lines
dt3155 frame grabber I am using in my experiments since the time of 2.6.17 kernel.
Whoah!
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
I will really appreciate your comments, suggestions, criticism.
I haven't tried your driver but the code looks much neater than our driver. Still, I am wondering why you chose to implement a device driver from scratch, rather than use an existing one?
In fact I used this one before switching to 2.6.17 kernel (see
http://lfb.issp.bas.bg/~mitov/linux/dt3155pci/00README
for details) and it was working well for single image acquisition. (except for the problems with having too much HIGHMEM). For real time acquisition (25 frames per sec), display and write on HDD I needed heavy buffering, otherwise frames are skipped.
Another minor reason was I had already written an OS2 driver for the same hardware and liked to try the same on linux :-).
Scott,
if you have 2 or more boards, could you check if
my driver is working with more than one board? I have only one and cannot do this check. I could send you a multi-threaded program for the test if you need it.
Marin Mitov
Quoted 14 lines
Quoted 4 lines
I'll leave decisions about whether to merge or discard (either driver) to Greg. My 2 cents is that there should only be 1 DT3155 driver for users to choose from.
I agree, we only need one of them.
Scott, any comparison between the two of them as to which one actually works better?
thanks,
greg k-h
Hi Greg & Marin,
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Scott, any comparison between the two of them as to which one actually works better?
I'd be interested in Marin's opinion as he appears to have used both drivers extensively.
I'd like a userspace program to actually try out Marin's driver, but I can still make some general comments:
Things I like about Marin's driver:
- It is only ~1/3rd the size. (by counting new lines)
- The code is much neater.
- It can acquire frames at 25 fps (real-time), according to Marin.
- At least 1 person with intimate knowledge of the code seems keen to maintain it.
Things I like about the sourceforge (SF) driver:
- It works in CCIR mode (768x576) or 640x480 mode.
- It is well tested.
- It works with most kernel versions. ie. 2.2, 2.4, & 2.6. (mostly)
- It works with multiple boards.
- The code is moderately well commented.
- It includes simple (user space) example programs.
Clearly each driver has strengths over the other.
It would probably be easier to upgrade Marin's driver to match the strengths of the SF driver than the other way around. The only difficulty might be in making Marin's driver work with older kernel versions. IMO, that's probably an acceptable sacrifice to make. (For users of legacy systems, we could point them to the (unmaintained) driver on SF.)
Quoted 2 lines
if you have 2 or more boards, could you check if
my driver is working with more than one board?
Sorry, I only have 1 board available to test with.
Marin, if you are considering upgrading your driver, I propose we send an email to the DT3155 SF mailing list & ask for help testing. (I already know of 1 other person who is happy to help test.) I recommend making userspace programs (like examples/acquire & examples/Xview in the SF driver) available first. Ideally, these example programs & user space libraries would become the major component of the evolved DT3155 SF project.
What do you think?
Scott. :)
Quoted 27 lines · Scott Smedley
Hi Greg & Marin,
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Scott, any comparison between the two of them as to which one actually works better?
I'd be interested in Marin's opinion as he appears to have used both drivers extensively.
I'd like a userspace program to actually try out Marin's driver, but I can still make some general comments:
Things I like about Marin's driver:
- It is only ~1/3rd the size. (by counting new lines)
- The code is much neater.
- It can acquire frames at 25 fps (real-time), according to Marin.
- At least 1 person with intimate knowledge of the code seems keen to maintain it.Things I like about the sourceforge (SF) driver:
- It works in CCIR mode (768x576) or 640x480 mode.
- It is well tested.
- It works with most kernel versions. ie. 2.2, 2.4, & 2.6. (mostly)
- It works with multiple boards.
- The code is moderately well commented.
- It includes simple (user space) example programs.
Quoted 8 lines
Clearly each driver has strengths over the other.
It would probably be easier to upgrade Marin's driver to match the strengths of the SF driver than the other way around. The only difficulty might be in making Marin's driver work with older kernel versions. IMO, that's probably an acceptable sacrifice to make. (For users of legacy systems, we could point them to the (unmaintained) driver on SF.)
We don't need to worry about older kernel versions from here on out. That will make the one in the staging tree smaller as well, as the compatibility code will soon be deleted.
So that leaves the functionality issues. Is the only difference that
one can capture faster than the other? They should be using the v4l apis so userspace shouldn't be a difference either, right?
thanks,
greg k-h
Hi Greg,
Quoted 1 line
We don't need to worry about older kernel versions from here on out.
Ok.
Quoted 2 lines
So that leaves the functionality issues. Is the only difference that
one can capture faster than the other?
As mentioned, Marin's driver only supports CCIR mode & it hasn't been tested with multiple boards.
Quoted 2 lines
They should be using the v4l
apis so userspace shouldn't be a difference either, right?
No. They are both standalone drivers. If we want V4L2 compatibility we would have to modify (either) driver significantly.
Scott. :)
Quoted 11 lines · Scott Smedley
Hi Greg,
Quoted 1 line
We don't need to worry about older kernel versions from here on out.
Ok.
Quoted 2 lines
So that leaves the functionality issues. Is the only difference that
one can capture faster than the other?As mentioned, Marin's driver only supports CCIR mode & it hasn't been tested with multiple boards.
Ah, ok.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
They should be using the v4l
apis so userspace shouldn't be a difference either, right?No. They are both standalone drivers. If we want V4L2 compatibility we would have to modify (either) driver significantly.
Well, that will be the requirement to get it merged into the main portion of the kernel tree. No special interfaces are allowed, sorry.
Anyway, I suggest the two of you decide on a plan forward.
thanks,
greg k-h
Hi Greg,
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
No. They are both standalone drivers. If we want V4L2 compatibility we would have to modify (either) driver significantly.
Both are character drivers. My one uses open, read, mmap, ioctl, close. Mainly tested on read. mmap works, but not yet extensively tested. ioctl is used to start/stop acquisition, get info about buffer length, and some error statistics collected during acquisitions.
see:
http://lfb.issp.bas.bg/~mitov/linux/dt3155pci/00README
for more detailed description.
Quoted 3 lines
Well, that will be the requirement to get it merged into the main portion of the kernel tree. No special interfaces are allowed, sorry.
I do not quite understand V4L2 lib in particular how can I get a contiguous buffer in physical memory which do not cross 4MB boundary (hardware requirement).
Thanks,
Marin Mitov
Quoted 10 lines · Marin Mitov
Hi Greg,
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
No. They are both standalone drivers. If we want V4L2 compatibility we would have to modify (either) driver significantly.
Both are character drivers. My one uses open, read, mmap, ioctl, close. Mainly tested on read. mmap works, but not yet extensively tested. ioctl is used to start/stop acquisition, get info about buffer length, and some error statistics collected during acquisitions.
Quoted 5 lines
see:
http://lfb.issp.bas.bg/~mitov/linux/dt3155pci/00README
for more detailed description.
Thanks, but the code needs to use the v4l interface, as it is a video device.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Well, that will be the requirement to get it merged into the main portion of the kernel tree. No special interfaces are allowed, sorry.
I do not quite understand V4L2 lib in particular how can I get a contiguous buffer in physical memory which do not cross 4MB boundary (hardware requirement).
Try asking on the linux-media mailing list, I don't think this is a big deal, as you have already done it in the driver, so that would not have to be reworked.
thanks,
greg k-h
Hi Scot & Greg,
Quoted 3 lines
I'd be interested in Marin's opinion as he appears to have used both drivers extensively.
I have successfully used SourceForge(SF) driver since 2003 on 2.4.xx kernels till the time of 2.6.17 kernel when I switched to 2.6.17 as described in
http://lfb.issp.bas.bg/~mitov/linux/dt3155pci/00README
At this time I needed 1 fps, so the SF driver was OK for me.
Quoted 2 lines
I'd like a userspace program to actually try out Marin's driver
I have one using KDE 3.5 libraries. If you use KDE 3.5 I could send it to you.
Quoted 7 lines
, but
I can still make some general comments:Things I like about Marin's driver:
- It is only ~1/3rd the size. (by counting new lines)
- The code is much neater.
- It can acquire frames at 25 fps (real-time), according to Marin.
Since today it could do 30 fps as well :-). Updated.
Quoted 5 lines
- At least 1 person with intimate knowledge of the code seems keen to maintain it.
Things I like about the sourceforge (SF) driver:
- It works in CCIR mode (768x576) or 640x480 mode.
Since today - here also.
Quoted 2 lines
- It is well tested.
- It works with most kernel versions. ie. 2.2, 2.4, & 2.6. (mostly)
Production tested/used (every day use) on 2.6.27.43-i686. Compile tested on 2.6.33.-rc4-x86_64 :-)
Quoted 1 line
- It works with multiple boards.
Here in principal - also, but not tested.
Quoted 13 lines
- The code is moderately well commented.
- It includes simple (user space) example programs.Clearly each driver has strengths over the other.
It would probably be easier to upgrade Marin's driver to match the strengths of the SF driver than the other way around. The only difficulty might be in making Marin's driver work with older kernel versions. IMO, that's probably an acceptable sacrifice to make. (For users of legacy systems, we could point them to the (unmaintained) driver on SF.)
Quoted 3 lines
Marin, if you are considering upgrading your driver, I propose we send an email to the DT3155 SF mailing list & ask for help testing.
OK. I agree. Which kind of upgrade you mean?
If CCIR/RS-170 - it is already done (but not tested on RS-170, I have no such camera).
I would ask your help for contacting "the DT3155 SF mailing list & ask for help"
Quoted 5 lines
(I already know of 1 other person who is happy to help test.) I recommend making userspace programs (like examples/acquire & examples/Xview in the SF driver) available first. Ideally, these example programs & user space libraries would become the major component of the evolved DT3155 SF project.
Here I could propose a KDE program, but it needs KDE, I am not familiar with GNOME programing.
Marin Mitov