neverallow and attributes
If I do:
attribute A;
type T1_t;
type T2_t;
typeattribute T2_t A;
allow A T1_t:file read;
neverallow T2_t T1_t:file read;I can compile and load the corresponding module. I can even do:
allow A T1_t:file read;
neverallow A T1_t:file read;without problems.
I cannot do:
allow T2_t T1_t:file read;
neverallow A T1_t:file read;The neverallow assertion does not find any allows that are constituted by allowing something for an attribute.
Is this normal behaviour?
Ole
Quoted 28 lines · Ole Kliemann
If I do:
attribute A; type T1_t; type T2_t; typeattribute T2_t A; allow A T1_t:file read; neverallow T2_t T1_t:file read;I can compile and load the corresponding module. I can even do:
allow A T1_t:file read; neverallow A T1_t:file read;without problems.
I cannot do:
allow T2_t T1_t:file read; neverallow A T1_t:file read;
Quoted 4 lines
The neverallow assertion does not find any allows that are constituted by allowing something for an attribute.
Is this normal behaviour?
I would call that a bug. However, I'm not surprised, as Fedora disables the neverallow checking by default (expand-check=0
in /etc/selinux/semanage.conf), so it doesn't get much testing these days. Possibly the neverallow checking has never been updated to account for preservation of attributes in the kernel policy (originally all attributes were expanded at compile-time).
Signature · 8 lines
Stephen Smalley National Security Agency -- This message was distributed to subscribers of the selinux mailing list. If you no longer wish to subscribe, send mail to [email protected] with the words "unsubscribe selinux" without quotes as the message.