truecrypt - what's the real story behind it?
Hi,
the cryptsetup tool supports besides plain and luks, also loopaes and truecrypt.
I now compiled truecrypt-7.1a, and it looks not bad.
I wonder why some people say truecrypt is no more secure.
Which part or method of truecrypt is allegedly broken? Can't be fixed?
And: is full truecrypt functionality integrated in cryptsetup tool? I mean the create-options below.
Here's a manually done "create"-session with the available options:
# truecrypt -c
Volume type:
1) Normal
2) Hidden
Select [1]: 1
Enter file or device path for new volume: /home/testuser/truecrypt-tests/enc.tcf Enter volume size (sizeK/size[M]/sizeG): : 250M
Encryption algorithm:
1) AES
2) Serpent
3) Twofish
4) AES-Twofish
5) AES-Twofish-Serpent
6) Serpent-AES
7) Serpent-Twofish-AES
8) Twofish-Serpent
Select [1]: 3
Hash algorithm:
1) RIPEMD-160
2) SHA-512
3) Whirlpool
Select [1]: 1
Filesystem:
1) None
2) FAT
3) Linux Ext2
4) Linux Ext3
5) Linux Ext4
Select [2]: 3
Signature · 2 lines
cu Uenal
Quoted 3 lines · U.Mutlu
Hi,
the cryptsetup tool supports besides plain and luks, also loopaes and truecrypt. I now compiled truecrypt-7.1a, and it looks not bad.
Please see the https://ciphershed.org project which tries to continue with development.
Quoted 2 lines
I wonder why some people say truecrypt is no more secure. Which part or method of truecrypt is allegedly broken? Can't be fixed?
There is no publicly known serious problem there. But there are license and other non-technical problems. You will get more info on devel list of project above.
Quoted 2 lines
And: is full truecrypt functionality integrated in cryptsetup tool? I mean the create-options below.
There is full support for mapping existing containers (with some exceptions, see man page).
There is intentionally no new container creation support in cryptsetup and I am not planning to add it.
We will better invest time to improving LUKS.
You can use tcplay or older version of truecrypt for that (or ciphershed when released).
Milan
Milan Broz wrote, On 02/08/2015 11:03 AM:
Quoted 5 lines · U.Mutlu
Quoted 3 lines
Hi,
the cryptsetup tool supports besides plain and luks, also loopaes and truecrypt. I now compiled truecrypt-7.1a, and it looks not bad.
Quoted 7 lines
Please see the https://ciphershed.org project which tries to continue with development.
Quoted 2 lines
I wonder why some people say truecrypt is no more secure. Which part or method of truecrypt is allegedly broken? Can't be fixed?
There is no publicly known serious problem there. But there are license and other non-technical problems. You will get more info on devel list of project above.
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)
The License.txt of truecrypt-7.1a says:
"You may modify This Product (thus forming Your Product), derive new works from This Product or portions thereof (thus forming Your Product), include This Product or portions thereof in another product (thus forming Your Product, unless defined otherwise in Chapter I), and You may use (for non-commercial and/or commercial purposes), copy, and/or distribute Your Product."
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 2 lines
And: is full truecrypt functionality integrated in cryptsetup tool? I mean the create-options below.
There is full support for mapping existing containers (with some exceptions, see man page).
There is intentionally no new container creation support in cryptsetup and I am not planning to add it.
We will better invest time to improving LUKS.
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p (btw. what's the status of "Microsoft Linux"? :-), they really shouldn't have dropped their Xenix; I had the pleasure to work on it for about 2 years at the end of the 1980ies... As time goes by...
Quoted 2 lines
You can use tcplay or older version of truecrypt for that (or ciphershed when released).
Thx, as said truecrypt-7.1a works fine here, but a maintained package is of course better, so I think I'll check the ciphershed release. And thx for the link to their project site; I didn't know of them. There I found also this link with some info about truecrypt's future:
https://forum.truecrypt.ch/
Quoted 2 lines
Milan
Signature · 2 lines
cu Uenal
Quoted 3 lines · U.Mutlu
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)
Nobody knows but the Truecrypt devs. IMHO the reasons to abandon TC development was rather financial ones.
Quoted 2 lines
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p
If you use Wind*ws as your platform, you'll most likely have a lot more serious security problems than a simple "how reliable is TC"... ;-)
Quoted 7 lines · Heinz Diehl
Quoted 4 lines · U.Mutlu
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among
the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)
Quoted 8 lines
Nobody knows but the Truecrypt devs. IMHO the reasons to abandon TC development was rather financial ones.
Quoted 2 lines
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p
If you use Wind*ws as your platform, you'll most likely have a lot more serious security problems than a simple "how reliable is TC"... ;-)
Also, while IIRC it doesn't support encrypted rootfs, there _is_ FreeOTFE for opening LUKS volumes on Windows.
Quoted 12 lines · Alex Elsayed
Quoted 10 lines · Heinz Diehl
Quoted 4 lines · U.Mutlu
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among
the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)Nobody knows but the Truecrypt devs. IMHO the reasons to abandon TC development was rather financial ones.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p
If you use Wind*ws as your platform, you'll most likely have a lot more serious security problems than a simple "how reliable is TC"... ;-)
Also, while IIRC it doesn't support encrypted rootfs, there _is_ FreeOTFE for opening LUKS volumes on Windows.
Correction; it seems FreeOTFE died while I wasn't looking. This seems to be the replacement: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DoxBox
Quoted 13 lines · Alex Elsayed
Quoted 11 lines · Heinz Diehl
Quoted 5 lines · U.Mutlu
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the
authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among
the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)Nobody knows but the Truecrypt devs. IMHO the reasons to abandon TC development was rather financial ones.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p
If you use Wind*ws as your platform, you'll most likely have a lot more serious security problems than a simple "how reliable is TC"... ;-)
Also, while IIRC it doesn't support encrypted rootfs, there _is_ FreeOTFE for opening LUKS volumes on Windows.
Not for -plain64 and/or GPT though. DoxBox is trying to fix these (and some further) things, after Sarah Dean disappeared alltogether and FreeOTFE is no longer maintained.
Heinz Diehl wrote, On 02/08/2015 01:02 PM:
Quoted 6 lines · U.Mutlu
Quoted 4 lines
Then I wonder if the NSA/CIA/DHS etc. was involved in the decision of the authors to abondon truecrypt developement, or was there maybe a mole among the devs?... conspiracy mode off :-)
Quoted 8 lines
Nobody knows but the Truecrypt devs. IMHO the reasons to abandon TC development was rather financial ones.
Quoted 2 lines
The advantage of truecrypt, as I see it, is that it is a multiplatform solution; works even under the Windows cr*p
If you use Wind*ws as your platform, you'll most likely have a lot more serious security problems than a simple "how reliable is TC"... ;-)
That's true, of course, but I was thinking of the mass of the other users ie. a million (or billion) fruit-flies can't be wrong... :-)
Signature · 2 lines
cu Uenal
Quoted 9 lines · Milan Broz
Quoted 4 lines · U.Mutlu
Hi,
the cryptsetup tool supports besides plain and luks, also loopaes and truecrypt.
I now compiled truecrypt-7.1a, and it looks not bad.Please see the https://ciphershed.org project which tries to continue with development.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
I wonder why some people say truecrypt is no more secure. Which part or method of truecrypt is allegedly broken? Can't be fixed?
There is no publicly known serious problem there. But there are license and other
non-technical problems. You will get more info on devel list of project above.
AFAIK the preset for number of rounds (iterations) in key derivation is rather low with truecrypt. A good key and/or keyfile with entropy should fix that though.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 4 lines
And: is full truecrypt functionality integrated in cryptsetup tool? I mean the
create-options below.
Quoted 7 lines
There is full support for mapping existing containers (with some exceptions,
see man page).There is intentionally no new container creation support in cryptsetup and I am not planning to add it.
We will better invest time to improving LUKS.
I agree, sooner or later we will have LUKSv2 ;-).
Quoted 11 lines
You can use tcplay or older version of truecrypt for that (or ciphershed when
released).Milan
_______________________________________________
dm-crypt mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.saout.de/mailman/listinfo/dm-crypt
-Sven