Microsoft, WSL, and the Linux trademark
In reading the news today, I stumbled across an article talking about a $20 "linux-based distro" app for Windows 10.
This is just a bundled userspace for WSL, there is no actual Linux in this thing, yet the trademarked Linux name is used throughout.
Did Microsoft license the trademark or something? Did I miss a memo? Does their joining the Linux Foundation as a Platinum member two years ago include such use of the trademark?
I'm confused by what seems to be total silence about what _appears_ to be an obvious large-scale trademark abuse in everything WSL-related.
Could somebody informed please shed some light on this?
The situation strikes me as harmful to the kernel as the majority of folks being introduced to "Linux" this way will be tricked into thinking they're using/supporting Linux.
Has the Linux Foundation deliberately turned a blind eye to this trademark abuse because MS is throwing money at them or is it a formal licensing situation? Do we, the community, even have any right to know what's going on?
Cheers,
Vito Caputo
Quoted 6 lines · Vito Caputo
In reading the news today, I stumbled across an article talking about a $20 "linux-based distro" app for Windows 10.
This is just a bundled userspace for WSL, there is no actual Linux in this thing, yet the trademarked Linux name is used throughout.
Quoted 8 lines
Did Microsoft license the trademark or something? Did I miss a memo? Does their joining the Linux Foundation as a Platinum member two years ago include such use of the trademark?
I'm confused by what seems to be total silence about what _appears_ to be an obvious large-scale trademark abuse in everything WSL-related.
Could somebody informed please shed some light on this?
For information about for the Linux Trademark, please see:
I'll note that while Microsoft's Subsystem for Linux does not *contain* Linux, it certainly can run Linux binaries. WSL is not unique in that regard. Google's gVisor, which is used[1] in Google Compute Engine's App Engine is implemented in Go and is a Userspace Kernel, that can also run Linux binaries.
I can't speak to whether Microsoft registered and received a sublicense for WSL, or not. Per the FAQ[2] on the Linux Mark Institute's web site, it would appear that anyone who wants to use Linux in a product name, whether it's "Red Hat Enterprise Linux" or "SuSE Linux Enterprise Server" must request a free sublicense and agree to the terms of the Sublicense Agreement[3]. Technically, "Windows Subsystem for Linux" is not product name, but a feature. I'm not a trademark lawyer, so I can't speak to whether this would be required or whether it would fall under Fair Use of a trademark. For certain, it would appear to me that "WLinux", Microsoft's distribution derived from Debian, would be much like "Red Hat Enterprise Linux" as requiring a trademark sublicense.
If you have further questions that are not answered by the FAQ, the web site directs people to send inquiries to [email protected].
[2] https://www.linuxmark.org/programs/legal/trademark/faq
[3] https://www.linuxmark.org/programs/legal/trademark/sublicense-agreement
Cheers,
- Ted