Skip to contentSkip to conversation

U-Boot v2019.04 released

U-Boot Tom Rini 3 participants 3 messages Apr 9, 2019 – Apr 23, 2019

lore
Share & tools
lore

Tom Rini

author
#0 lore raw

Hey all,

So it is release day and despite a few last minute regression fixes, I think I'm overall comfortable doing the release today. Our next release is v2019.07 so we once again have time to stabilize things prior to release and not feel rushed.

With this release, we've hit the deadline for DM_MMC conversion (setting aside SPL/TPL) and SPI (but not SPI_FLASH). What does that mean in practice? Well, in some cases we won't be deleting the compatible code yet as other block devices have their deadline being v2019.07 and you cannot mix-and-match DM and not DM block. That was even a last minute regression fix this time. So on those platforms I am confident that people will be finishing related conversions ASAP. And then, if we don't need the code for SPL/TPL, it can go away. In other cases, where things aren't migrated at all, soon some patches will get posted that will require enabling BROKEN to select non-migrated code paths. This isn't happening right away as I know people are working on finishing things up for migration, and again, that whole other block devices thing too.

I'm mentioning this here as v2019.07 has deadlines for the rest of the block drivers as well as video and PCI and SPI flash, and I want expectations to be set.

So with that, the merge window is open and we're looking at doing the v2019.07 release on July 8th, 2019.

Thanks all!

Signature · 8 lines
Tom
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: signature.asc
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 819 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/attachments/20190408/faa1b14a/attachment.sig>
#1 lore raw

Dear Tom,

Quoted 3 lines · In message <20190409014201.GH4664@bill-the-cat> you wrote:

So it is release day and despite a few last minute regression fixes, I think I'm overall comfortable doing the release today.

Thanks, and here is the short version of the release statistics:

Changes between v2019.01 and v2019.04:

* Processed 1193 csets from 182 developers
* 25 employers found
* A total of 76038 lines added, 22237 removed (delta 53801)

Developers with the most changesets

Heinrich Schuchardt         94 (7.9%)
Simon Glass                 90 (7.5%)
Michal Simek                64 (5.4%)
Marek Vasut                 55 (4.6%)
Jagan Teki                  45 (3.8%)
Simon Goldschmidt           32 (2.7%)
Chris Packham               29 (2.4%)
Adam Ford                   26 (2.2%)

Horatiu.Vultur at microchip.com 26 (2.2%)
Fabio Estevam 24 (2.0%)
...

Developers with the most changed lines

Simon Glass               10585 (11.8%)
David Wu                  9172 (10.2%)
Vignesh R                 6854 (7.7%)
Neil Armstrong            5440 (6.1%)
Horatiu.Vultur at microchip.com 5136 (5.7%)
Jagan Teki                4056 (4.5%)
AKASHI Takahiro           3838 (4.3%)
Abel Vesa                 2983 (3.3%)
Heinrich Schuchardt       1925 (2.2%)
Weijie Gao                1757 (2.0%)

...

Developers with the most lines removed
David Wu 4036 (18.1%)

Michal Simek               461 (2.1%)
Eugeniy Paltsev            251 (1.1%)
Peter Robinson             187 (0.8%)
Tom Rini                   148 (0.7%)
Eugeniu Rosca              100 (0.4%)
Tien Fong Chee              39 (0.2%)
Shubhrajyoti Datta          15 (0.1%)
Baruch Siach                14 (0.1%)
Derald D. Woods             13 (0.1%)

...

Developers with the most signoffs (total 252)

Alexander Graf              49 (19.4%)
Stefan Roese                29 (11.5%)
Michal Simek                28 (11.1%)
Minkyu Kang                 16 (6.3%)
Tom Warren                  11 (4.4%)
Tom Rini                     9 (3.6%)
Marek Vasut                  9 (3.6%)
Neil Armstrong               9 (3.6%)
Prabhakar Kushwaha           7 (2.8%)
Jagan Teki                   7 (2.8%)

...

Developers with the most reviews (total 616)

Simon Glass                 87 (14.1%)
Bin Meng                    58 (9.4%)
Tom Rini                    42 (6.8%)
Philipp Tomsich             42 (6.8%)
Prabhakar Kushwaha          41 (6.7%)
Jagan Teki                  34 (5.5%)
Lukasz Majewski             27 (4.4%)
Heiko Schocher              25 (4.1%)
Stefan Roese                23 (3.7%)
Fabio Estevam               23 (3.7%)

...

Developers with the most test credits (total 111)

Jagan Teki                  17 (15.3%)
Stefan Roese                13 (11.7%)
Simon Goldschmidt           13 (11.7%)
Horatiu.Vultur at microchip.com   12 (10.8%)
Anand Moon                   9 (8.1%)
Bin Meng                     5 (4.5%)
Fabio Estevam                4 (3.6%)
Simon Glass                  3 (2.7%)
Michal Simek                 3 (2.7%)
Heinrich Schuchardt          2 (1.8%)

...

Developers who gave the most tested-by credits (total 111)
Vignesh R 55 (49.5%)

Krzysztof Kozlowski          9 (8.1%)
Adam Ford                    6 (5.4%)
Fabio Estevam                4 (3.6%)
Lukas Auer                   4 (3.6%)
Jagan Teki                   3 (2.7%)
Simon Goldschmidt            3 (2.7%)
Tom Rini                     3 (2.7%)
Baruch Siach                 3 (2.7%)
Daniel Schwierzeck           2 (1.8%)

...

Developers with the most report credits (total 21)

Alexander Graf               3 (14.3%)
Leigh Brown                  2 (9.5%)
Lukas Auer                   1 (4.8%)
Michal Simek                 1 (4.8%)
Heinrich Schuchardt          1 (4.8%)
Stephen Warren               1 (4.8%)
Vagrant Cascadian            1 (4.8%)
Frank Wunderlich             1 (4.8%)
Breno Matheus Lima           1 (4.8%)

...

Developers who gave the most report credits (total 21)

Alexander Graf               3 (14.3%)
Chris Packham                3 (14.3%)
Heinrich Schuchardt          2 (9.5%)
Fabio Estevam                2 (9.5%)
Simon Goldschmidt            2 (9.5%)
Baruch Siach                 2 (9.5%)
Masahiro Yamada              2 (9.5%)
Jagan Teki                   1 (4.8%)
Bin Meng                     1 (4.8%)
Martyn Welch                 1 (4.8%)

...

Top changeset contributors by employer
(Unknown) 542 (45.4%)
NXP 107 (9.0%)

Google, Inc.                90 (7.5%)
Xilinx                      82 (6.9%)
Texas Instruments           60 (5.0%)
Amarula Solutions           49 (4.1%)
DENX Software Engineering   44 (3.7%)
Linaro                      42 (3.5%)
Novell                      22 (1.8%)
Intel                       20 (1.7%)

...

Top lines changed by employer

(Unknown)                 34442 (38.5%)
Google, Inc.              10585 (11.8%)
NXP                       9333 (10.4%)
Texas Instruments         7505 (8.4%)
Linaro                    6284 (7.0%)
BayLibre SAS              5704 (6.4%)
Amarula Solutions         4081 (4.6%)

DENX Software Engineering 2541 (2.8%)
Xilinx 2254 (2.5%)
Collabora Ltd. 1891 (2.1%)
...

Employers with the most signoffs (total 252)

Novell                      51 (20.2%)
(Unknown)                   35 (13.9%)
NXP                         34 (13.5%)
DENX Software Engineering   29 (11.5%)
Xilinx                      29 (11.5%)
BayLibre SAS                16 (6.3%)
Samsung                     16 (6.3%)
NVidia                      11 (4.4%)

Konsulko Group 9 (3.6%)
Amarula Solutions 8 (3.2%)
...

Employers with the most hackers (total 184)

(Unknown)                   87 (47.3%)
NXP                         27 (14.7%)
Texas Instruments           10 (5.4%)
Linaro                       8 (4.3%)
Xilinx                       6 (3.3%)
BayLibre SAS                 6 (3.3%)
Intel                        5 (2.7%)
DENX Software Engineering    4 (2.2%)
Toradex                      4 (2.2%)
Bootlin                      4 (2.2%)

...

The full statistics are available here: [1]

[1] http://www.denx.de/wiki/U-Boot/UbootStat_2019_04

Best regards,

Wolfgang Denk

Signature · 4 lines
DENX Software Engineering GmbH,      Managing Director: Wolfgang Denk
HRB 165235 Munich, Office: Kirchenstr.5, D-82194 Groebenzell, Germany
Phone: (+49)-8142-66989-10 Fax: (+49)-8142-66989-80 Email: wd at denx.de
A failure will not appear until a unit has passed final inspection.