Seeking help for getting rid of i2c_clients_command()
Hi Hans,
I know it is 13 years since you wrote that code:
ba8fc39954bf ("V4L/DVB (4270): Add tda9887-specific tuner configuration")
There, you added i2c_clients_command() which looks today like this:
i2c_clients_command(priv->i2c_props.adap, TUNER_SET_CONFIG, &tda9887_cfg);
Now, I would like to get rid of the i2c_clients_command() API, and this is the one remaining user. While trying to convert it into a local function, I started wondering why i2c_clients_command() is used at all. Why do we need to try all devices on the bus? A few lines later we have:
tuner_i2c_xfer_send(&priv->i2c_props, buffer, 4);
so i2c_props.addr seems to have a valid address? Or are there multiple tuners on that bus? Can you kindly shed some light on this?
Thank you!
Wolfram
Quoted 16 lines · Wolfram Sang
Hi Hans,
I know it is 13 years since you wrote that code:
ba8fc39954bf("V4L/DVB (4270): Add tda9887-specific tuner configuration")There, you added
i2c_clients_command()which looks today like this:i2c_clients_command(priv->i2c_props.adap, TUNER_SET_CONFIG, &tda9887_cfg);Now, I would like to get rid of the
i2c_clients_command()API, and this is the one remaining user. While trying to convert it into a local function, I started wondering whyi2c_clients_command()is used at all. Why do we need to try all devices on the bus? A few lines later we have:
Quoted 4 lines
tuner_i2c_xfer_send(&priv->i2c_props, buffer, 4);so i2c_props.addr seems to have a valid address? Or are there multiple tuners on that bus? Can you kindly shed some light on this?
Oh boy... The tuner code is awful for many reasons.
One reason is that for a given video capture card there can be multiple tuner devices: Analog TV, Digital TV, Analog demodulator and/or radio.
The TUNER_SET_CONFIG command is (AFAICT) only used to configure the tda9887 (demodulator), and the problem is that when this code was written the tuner instance that is calling TUNER_SET_CONFIG does not know on which i2c address the demod is.
TUNER_SET_CONFIG is called whenever the TV or radio frequency is changed, and when that happens the demod needs to update its configuration as well. So the tuner_i2c_xfer_send(&priv->i2c_props, buffer, 4); is for the tuner itself (whose i2c address is known), but i2c_clients_command is basically broadcasting to anyone on the bus, and only the tda9987 will actually act on the TUNER_SET_CONFIG command.
However, it looks like this code is only used by hybrid tuners (i.e. supporting both digital and analog TV), and that the available tuners are now added to a global list via hybrid_tuner_request_state().
This should make it possible for tuner-simple.c to actually lookup the i2c address of the demod from that global list and use a direct call.
I've CC-ed a bunch of people who know more about DVB than I do, so I hope they can double-check that I am on the right track.
Wolfram, do you just want to get rid of i2c_clients_command or the i2c command() callback as well?
Regardless, it would be nice if we can get rid of the command() callback in the media subsystem. If I read the code right, then you can get the tuner struct of an i2c_client using 'struct tuner *t = to_tuner(i2c_get_clientdata(c));' and from there you can get the analog_demod_ops that you need to
configure the tda9887.
So I think this would work:
1) walk hybrid_tuner_instance_list to find a tuner with name "tda9887" for the given i2c_adapter.
2) get the i2c_client from the adapter with address state->i2c_props.addr.
3) struct tuner *t = to_tuner(i2c_get_clientdata(c));
4) if (t->fe.ops.analog_ops.set_config)
t->fe.ops.analog_ops.set_config(&t->fe, &config);
Regards,
Hans
Hi Hans!
Quoted 6 lines
TUNER_SET_CONFIGis called whenever the TV or radio frequency is changed, and when that happens the demod needs to update its configuration as well. So thetuner_i2c_xfer_send(&priv->i2c_props, buffer, 4); is for the tuner itself (whose i2c address is known), buti2c_clients_commandis basically broadcasting to anyone on the bus, and only the tda9987 will actually act on theTUNER_SET_CONFIGcommand.
I see. Thanks for the heads up.
Quoted 2 lines
This should make it possible for
tuner-simple.cto actually lookup the i2c address of the demod from that global list and use a direct call.
Sounds awesome!
Quoted 2 lines
I've CC-ed a bunch of people who know more about DVB than I do, so I hope they can double-check that I am on the right track.
Their help would be much appreciated.
Quoted 2 lines
Wolfram, do you just want to get rid of
i2c_clients_commandor the i2ccommand()callback as well?
I'd like to get rid of the callback as well. tuner is again the only in-tree user. And this whole mechanism looks so 2.4ish... I think it can go now.
Thanks for your help,
Wolfram