re Issue #194: virtio-net: clarify coalescing parameters settings
Hello!
The ballot on issue #194 is set to conclude however some comments by TC members made me think some members were confused about the voting process. In particular two members abstained leaving
a comment which makes me think they were actually against merging the proposal.
I would like to clarify two things:
- 1.4 release (for which this is targeted) is not imminent. there's no reason to merge a controversial patch, we can work until there is a rough consensus.
- even with a non released spec we do try to maintain compatibility so it's a level of commitment to accept a patch.
Further the ballot was part of a big batch of 5 ballots at the same time, and the description in the commit log and the text itself do not 100% align.
Given all this, I am inclined to let the discussion go on a bit longer, and re-do the vote with a new version of the proposal.
Objections?
Signature · 1 line
MST
Quoted 6 lines · Michael S. Tsirkin
Hello!
The ballot on issue #194 is set to conclude however some comments by TC members made me think some members were confused about the voting process. In particular two members abstained leaving
a comment which makes me think they were actually against merging the proposal.
Have the comments from Pasic, Halil and Liu, Si-Wei been addressed? I don't see an updated response. If you have more comments, please reply :)
Quoted 26 lines
I would like to clarify two things:
- 1.4 release (for which this is targeted) is not imminent. there's no reason to merge a controversial patch, we can work until there is a rough consensus.
- even with a non released spec we do try to maintain compatibility so it's a level of commitment to accept a patch.
Further the ballot was part of a big batch of 5 ballots at the same time, and the description in the commit log and the text itself do not 100% align.
Given all this, I am inclined to let the discussion go on a bit longer, and re-do the vote with a new version of the proposal.
Objections?
Signature · 1 line
MST