Determining Simon Glass's future in the U-Boot project
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/
And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both. Simon needs to accept that some things he think are good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?
Signature · 1 line
Tom
Hi Tom,
Quoted 17 lines · Tom Rini
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/
Quoted 3 lines
And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both.
+1.
Since I was involved in enough ... I don't mind reviewing patches and giving feedback. That's what I signed up for. Reading the same 30+ series patches though with only 10% of the feedback addressed is just not working.
Quoted 6 lines
Simon needs to accept that some things he think are
good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
FWIW I think you are doing an excellent job and I'd like the situation to remain as is.
Quoted 11 lines
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?
Thanks
/Ilias
Quoted 3 lines
--
Tom
Quoted 39 lines · Ilias Apalodimas
Hi Tom,
Quoted 17 lines · Tom Rini
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/Quoted 3 lines
And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both.
+1.
Since I was involved in enough ... I don't mind reviewing patches and giving feedback. That's what I signed up for. Reading the same 30+ series patches though with only 10% of the feedback addressed is just not working.
Quoted 6 lines
Simon needs to accept that some things he think are
good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
Quoted 2 lines
FWIW I think you are doing an excellent job and I'd like the situation to remain as is.
I'm backing Ilias and Casey here, you're doing an excellent job, maintaining such project is difficult and you do the job.
Neil
Quoted 18 lines
Quoted 9 lines
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
Quoted 3 lines
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?Thanks
/IliasQuoted 3 lines
--
Tom
Quoted 32 lines · Tom Rini
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both. Simon needs to accept that some things he think are good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
Quoted 3 lines
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?
I've since had emails with Simon and while he said he will send something in public himself, for now he's going to take a break from the project. I believe that as a community we need to figure out some things as a follow-up here, but that belongs in its own thread which I will do probably on Monday. Thanks for your understanding everyone.
Signature · 1 line
Tom
Hi Tom,
Quoted 25 lines · Tom Rini
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both. Simon needs to accept that some things he think are good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
Quoted 6 lines
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
You've been nothing but encouraging to me as a new contributor and custodian, and I really can't imagine U-Boot without you leading the charge.
Simon has been repeatedly engaging with people unproductively, wasting time and delaying valuable contributions. His complains tend to come in the form of vague hand waving about how things should be with seemingly no attention given to the actual intentions of the patch and dealing with the reality of how U-Boot works today. With so much attention given to his ever-diverging fork I can only imagine increasing confusion about how U-Boot actually works when it comes to reviewing upstream patches.
Referring back to: https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/[email protected]/
Simon seems to think that his arbitrary *implementation* of a boot flow is the only correct design, and there is no other usecase where something else would be desirable.
After many repeated discussions with the same themes (and having witnessed many of yours) I struggle to see Simons engagements as anything other than bad faith, particularly when it's so hard to pin down what the technical disagreements here actually are.
The patches in Simons U-Boot fork all appear to be either picked from the list (often earlier versions that what actually made it upstream) by other folks or his own patches that have been rejected for totally valid reasons that he doesn't seem to want to get into good enough shape to upstream.
You have repeatedly and publicly explained what it would take to get his features merged upstreamed, and to be honest I think you have offered him far more grace than other people in your position would.
Quoted 4 lines
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?
Maybe rather than this we could form a U-Boot board (via voting) and this board would be responsible for managing the project and associated resources, having and enforcing a code of conduct, etc etc.
There are various organisations which can help with this like the Linux Foundation, NLNet (I have experience with this from postmarketOS) and it would give the U-Boot community a way to be represented when it comes to difficult situations like this as well as provide a way for the project to grow sustainable as it increases in scope.
Quoted 1 line
Signature · 1 line
Casey (she/they)
Quoted 35 lines · Casey Connolly
Hi Tom,
Quoted 25 lines · Tom Rini
Hey all,
First, I am not happy to be writing this email. But at this point, I feel I have no other choice, for the good of the overall project and community.
Back in January[0] of this year I made a post with almost this same subject line. At that point there had already been a number of problems working with Simon and the overall community. I did not include a list of links. At that point the easiest answer would be to go to the mailing list archive, pick any thread that Simon and I had and see the long disagreements. This trend has fundamentally not changed. And while I started this out with some threads and my summaries of them, instead I want to point to this email I sent this mornig:
https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/20250528170533.GE100073@bill-the-cat/And to repeat what I said there, Simon needs to decide if it's more important to work with the community or have his way every time. Simon cannot have both. Simon needs to accept that some things he think are good ideas have been rejected or he needs to fork off from U-Boot. Or he can ask the community to take over as the project head. If the community wants Simon to run things, I will step down and just be an individual contributor again. Five months of this experiment shows me that it's not working at all and will only be a bigger problem as time goes on.
Quoted 6 lines
And, I mean it. I cannot take the additional stress of what new problems await me every morning. I do not take the above lightly, but I do not think the project can become healthy moving forward without some resolution here and quickly. While I won't claim my time as the head of the project has been perfect, I have tried my best to always be honest and fair and to seek compromise.
Quoted 3 lines
You've been nothing but encouraging to me as a new contributor and custodian, and I really can't imagine U-Boot without you leading the charge.
Simon has been repeatedly engaging with people unproductively, wasting time and delaying valuable contributions. His complains tend to come in the form of vague hand waving about how things should be with seemingly no attention given to the actual intentions of the patch and dealing with the reality of how U-Boot works today. With so much attention given to his ever-diverging fork I can only imagine increasing confusion about how U-Boot actually works when it comes to reviewing upstream patches.
fwiw I am missing a lot of history here which I probably should have considered more while writing this. I have had good discussions without Simon about some topics, but particularly in the last few months it has become much more difficult.
Quoted 21 lines
Referring back to: https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/1c1bcd1e- [email protected]/
Simon seems to think that his arbitrary *implementation* of a boot flow is the only correct design, and there is no other usecase where something else would be desirable.
After many repeated discussions with the same themes (and having witnessed many of yours) I struggle to see Simons engagements as anything other than bad faith, particularly when it's so hard to pin down what the technical disagreements here actually are.
The patches in Simons U-Boot fork all appear to be either picked from the list (often earlier versions that what actually made it upstream) by other folks or his own patches that have been rejected for totally valid reasons that he doesn't seem to want to get into good enough shape to upstream.
You have repeatedly and publicly explained what it would take to get his features merged upstreamed, and to be honest I think you have offered him far more grace than other people in your position would.
Quoted 4 lines
With respect to voting, would anyone volunteer to run a poll from
https://civs1.civs.us/ (which is used by the Yocto Project / OpenEmbedded and likely other FOSS projects/communities) ?Maybe rather than this we could form a U-Boot board (via voting) and this board would be responsible for managing the project and associated resources, having and enforcing a code of conduct, etc etc.
There are various organisations which can help with this like the Linux Foundation, NLNet (I have experience with this from postmarketOS) and it would give the U-Boot community a way to be represented when it comes to difficult situations like this as well as provide a way for the project to grow sustainable as it increases in scope.
Quoted 1 line
Signature · 1 line
Casey (she/they)