Skip to contentSkip to conversation

troubles with ARM processor type changes on UEFI 2.11

PATCH RESEND In review Mauro Carvalho Chehab 3 participants 3 messages Jun 22 ACPI

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

PATCH RESEND 1/1 troubles with ARM processor type changes on UEFI 2.11

(as I got no answer, I'm resending it, c/c some ARM people as well)

Hi,

I maintain ACPI HEST support on QEMU and I'm one of the Linux kernel reviewers for the RAS subsystem. I'm also the author and maintainer of Linux rasdaemon, responsible to handle RAS reports (including from GHES) on Linux.

There is an incompatible change at UEFI 2.11 spec at Section N.2.4.4.1, which, according with UEFI 2.11 changelog, it is related to this issue:

2462 - Fix the Type mnemonic description in the ARM Processor Error Information Structure

This is the second time the specs changed the meaning of the type field inside the ARM processor error info:

- Before UEFI 2.9A, the spec has a list of values for error type. From the specs, type, at offset 4 was described as:

- Cache error
- TLB Error
- Bus Error
- Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Yet, there was no information about how this would be encoded.

- UEFI 2.9A defined the actual expected values as:

- Bit 1 - Cache Error
- Bit 2 - TLB Error
- Bit 3 - Bus Error
- Bit 4 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

However, even being an incompatible change, the spec didn't change version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

Linux, QEMU, rasdaemon and likely several BIOS implementations were updated accordingly.

- UEFI 2.11 changed the definition to:

- Bit 0 - Cache Error
- Bit 1 - TLB Error
- Bit 2 - Bus Error
- Bit 3 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Again, another incompatible change and without changing the version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

With the current mess, it is impossible for the OSPM (and RAS apps) to properly map ARM processor error types, as for instance, type=2 can mean:

- Bus error (up to UEFI 2.9)
- Cache error (UEFI 2.9A and UEFI 2.10)
- TLB error (UEFI 2.11)

Please issue an errata incrementing version number, to allow OSPM QEMU and rasdaemon to properly interpret this field.

Thanks,
Mauro

#1 lore raw
Quoted 56 lines · On Mon, 22 Jun 2026 10:25:18 +0200 Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]>…

(as I got no answer, I'm resending it, c/c some ARM people as well)

Hi,

I maintain ACPI HEST support on QEMU and I'm one of the Linux kernel reviewers for the RAS subsystem. I'm also the author and maintainer of Linux rasdaemon, responsible to handle RAS reports (including from GHES) on Linux.

There is an incompatible change at UEFI 2.11 spec at Section N.2.4.4.1, which, according with UEFI 2.11 changelog, it is related to this issue:

2462 - Fix the Type mnemonic description in the ARM Processor Error Information Structure

This is the second time the specs changed the meaning of the type field inside the ARM processor error info:

- Before UEFI 2.9A, the spec has a list of values for error type. From the specs, type, at offset 4 was described as:

- Cache error
- TLB Error
- Bus Error
- Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Yet, there was no information about how this would be encoded.

- UEFI 2.9A defined the actual expected values as:

- Bit 1 - Cache Error
- Bit 2 - TLB Error
- Bit 3 - Bus Error
- Bit 4 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

However, even being an incompatible change, the spec didn't change version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

Linux, QEMU, rasdaemon and likely several BIOS implementations were updated accordingly.

- UEFI 2.11 changed the definition to:

- Bit 0 - Cache Error
- Bit 1 - TLB Error
- Bit 2 - Bus Error
- Bit 3 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Again, another incompatible change and without changing the version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

With the current mess, it is impossible for the OSPM (and RAS apps) to properly map ARM processor error types, as for instance, type=2 can mean:

Quoted 7 lines

- Bus error (up to UEFI 2.9)
- Cache error (UEFI 2.9A and UEFI 2.10)
- TLB error (UEFI 2.11)

Please issue an errata incrementing version number, to allow OSPM QEMU and rasdaemon to properly interpret this field.

FWIW I fully agree that an errata is needed. (Though, even though ambiguous, changing meaning should probably have been done by deprecating that field and adding a new one... too late now!)

It seems a bit odd to do it this way but Mauro, you should be able to file a code first proposal at:
https://github.com/tianocore/edk2/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3Atype%3Acode-first

Make sure it has a code first label. I think you also need someone to take it through the committee though (I'm sadly not in a position to do so at the moment).

Samer or Jose (+CC), can you deal with this one?

Thanks,

Jonathan

Quoted 2 lines

Thanks,
Mauro

#2 lore raw
Quoted 66 lines · On Mon, 22 Jun 2026 09:42:33 +0100 Jonathan Cameron <[email protected]> wrote:
Quoted 56 lines · On Mon, 22 Jun 2026 10:25:18 +0200 Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]>…

(as I got no answer, I'm resending it, c/c some ARM people as well)

Hi,

I maintain ACPI HEST support on QEMU and I'm one of the Linux kernel reviewers for the RAS subsystem. I'm also the author and maintainer of Linux rasdaemon, responsible to handle RAS reports (including from GHES) on Linux.

There is an incompatible change at UEFI 2.11 spec at Section N.2.4.4.1, which, according with UEFI 2.11 changelog, it is related to this issue:

2462 - Fix the Type mnemonic description in the ARM Processor Error Information Structure

This is the second time the specs changed the meaning of the type field inside the ARM processor error info:

- Before UEFI 2.9A, the spec has a list of values for error type. From the specs, type, at offset 4 was described as:

- Cache error
- TLB Error
- Bus Error
- Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Yet, there was no information about how this would be encoded.

- UEFI 2.9A defined the actual expected values as:

- Bit 1 - Cache Error
- Bit 2 - TLB Error
- Bit 3 - Bus Error
- Bit 4 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

However, even being an incompatible change, the spec didn't change version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

Linux, QEMU, rasdaemon and likely several BIOS implementations were updated accordingly.

- UEFI 2.11 changed the definition to:

- Bit 0 - Cache Error
- Bit 1 - TLB Error
- Bit 2 - Bus Error
- Bit 3 - Micro-architectural Error
All other values are reserved

Again, another incompatible change and without changing the version field at Section N.2.4.4.1.

With the current mess, it is impossible for the OSPM (and RAS apps) to properly map ARM processor error types, as for instance, type=2 can mean:

Quoted 7 lines

- Bus error (up to UEFI 2.9)
- Cache error (UEFI 2.9A and UEFI 2.10)
- TLB error (UEFI 2.11)

Please issue an errata incrementing version number, to allow OSPM QEMU and rasdaemon to properly interpret this field.

Quoted 7 lines

FWIW I fully agree that an errata is needed. (Though, even though ambiguous, changing meaning should probably have been done by deprecating that field and adding a new one... too late now!)

It seems a bit odd to do it this way but Mauro, you should be able to file a code first proposal at:
https://github.com/tianocore/edk2/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3Atype%3Acode-first

Thank you to point it to me. I opted to open this as a bug:

	https://github.com/tianocore/edk2/issues/12708

As the root cause for such regression was another bug:

	https://github.com/tianocore/edk2/issues/10524
Quoted 13 lines

Make sure it has a code first label. I think you also need someone to take it through the committee though (I'm sadly not in a position to do so at the moment).

Samer or Jose (+CC), can you deal with this one?

Thanks,

Jonathan

Quoted 2 lines

Thanks,
Maur

Signature · 2 lines
Thanks,
Mauro