Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Thunderbird behaviour with Reply-To header

mlmmj David Demelier 2 participants 5 messages Jan 29, 2017 – Feb 5, 2017

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello,

For my mailing lists I prefer to have the address of the mailing list instead of the original poster. This makes easier contributions for people not used to mailing list which only use "Reply" instead of Reply All or Reply List.

I've tried to add Reply-To as custom header with the mailing list.

When sending a mail to the list, I get the original post (fine), hitting the simple "Reply" button makes thunderbird answering twice:

To: thelist@thedomain
Reply-To: thelist@thedomain

Without the Reply-To header, clicking the Reply button makes thunderbird answering the original poster and not the mailing list address.

It looks like it's the only mail application doing that but I wonder if I should add more settings or use something else?

What's your thoughts on it?

Regards

Signature · 1 line
David Demelier
#1 lore raw
Quoted 18 lines · David Demelier

Hello,

For my mailing lists I prefer to have the address of the mailing list instead of the original poster. This makes easier contributions for people not used to mailing list which only use "Reply" instead of Reply All or Reply List.

I've tried to add Reply-To as custom header with the mailing list.

When sending a mail to the list, I get the original post (fine), hitting the simple "Reply" button makes thunderbird answering twice:

To: thelist@thedomain
Reply-To: thelist@thedomain

Without the Reply-To header, clicking the Reply button makes thunderbird answering the original poster and not the mailing list address.

Quoted 7 lines

It looks like it's the only mail application doing that but I wonder if I should add more settings or use something else?

What's your thoughts on it?

Regards

Adding List-Id and all List-* headers belong the Reply-To header fixes the problem!

Regards,

Signature · 1 line
David Demelier
#2 lore raw
In reply to David Demelier

This doesn't make sense to me. I am a Thunderbird user and I don't recall having any problem. What do you mean by "answering twice"? Did you change some setting in Thunderbird as well as change the configuration of the mailing list, perhaps? Could you have an extension which is causing the problem? Are you just not wanting to see your own posts, so might be interested in the 'notmetoo' tunable?

Ben

Quoted 24 lines · David Demelier

Hello,

For my mailing lists I prefer to have the address of the mailing list instead of the original poster. This makes easier contributions for people not used to mailing list which only use "Reply" instead of Reply All or Reply List.

I've tried to add Reply-To as custom header with the mailing list.

When sending a mail to the list, I get the original post (fine), hitting the simple "Reply" button makes thunderbird answering twice:

To: thelist@thedomain
Reply-To: thelist@thedomain

Without the Reply-To header, clicking the Reply button makes thunderbird answering the original poster and not the mailing list address.

It looks like it's the only mail application doing that but I wonder if I should add more settings or use something else?

What's your thoughts on it?

Regards

#3 lore raw
In reply to David Demelier
Quoted 6 lines · Ben Schmidt

This doesn't make sense to me. I am a Thunderbird user and I don't recall having any problem. What do you mean by "answering twice"? Did you change some setting in Thunderbird as well as change the configuration of the mailing list, perhaps? Could you have an extension which is causing the problem? Are you just not wanting to see your own posts, so might be interested in the 'notmetoo' tunable?

Yeah, my assumptions were wrong, in fact the thunderbird window reply twice only if I try to answer my own emails.

I have no extensions at all.

See the attached screenshot.

Signature · 1 line
David Demelier
#4 lore raw
In reply to David Demelier
Quoted 8 lines · David Demelier
Quoted 6 lines · Ben Schmidt

This doesn't make sense to me. I am a Thunderbird user and I don't recall having any problem. What do you mean by "answering twice"? Did you change some setting in Thunderbird as well as change the configuration of the mailing list, perhaps? Could you have an extension which is causing the problem? Are you just not wanting to see your own posts, so might be interested in the 'notmetoo' tunable?

Quoted 6 lines

Yeah, my assumptions were wrong, in fact the thunderbird window reply twice only if I try to answer my own emails.

I have no extensions at all.

See the attached screenshot.

I've verified that I don't see this behaviour, and disabled the extensions I have which might have been interfering.

Perhaps if you post

- what you have for your customheaders tunable
- what you have for your delheaders tunable
- complete headers of one of your messages arriving at the list (that causes the strange reply behaviour)

then I or others can offer suggestions.

However, does it actually matter? If you have Mlmmj configured to add the Reply-To header anyway, it won't matter if it's already there from Thunderbird, will it?

Smiles,

Ben