audit user space build problems
Hello,
Recently, distributions moved to building against gcc-12 for their latest OS composes. It's been found in at least 2 distributions that the user space package is failing to build. It's natural to think this is related to gcc-12 since it's the obvious change.
However, the problem is a combination of 2 things:
1) SWIG is making buggy code
2) The kernel changed to using flexible array members
The issue specifically is with struct audit_rules_data. At the bottom, it was using buf[0]; But on 5.17, it uses buf[]; It turns out that gcc-12 is just a coincidence and anything using gcc-12 also has the newest kernel.
The options are:
1) Report this as a SWIG bug and wait
2) Rewrite the libaudit python bindings to not use SWIG
3) Ask for buf[0]; to be reinstated in the kernel.
Of these, I think option 2 is the only viable long term option. It will take some time to write new python bindings that preserve the SWIG api.
A short term fix might be for distros to copy the kernel header into the lib directory and patch it to restore buf[0];, then change libaudit.c to include "audit.h" instead of <linux/audit.h>. There may be other approaches.
Just wanted to let everyone know that new builds in distributions are running into a problem. And a real fix will take a while.
Best,
-Steve
--
Linux-audit mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-audit
Hello,
Quoted 4 lines · EST Steve Grubb
A short term fix might be for distros to copy the kernel header into the lib directory and patch it to restore buf[0];, then change
libaudit.cto include "audit.h" instead of <linux/audit.h>. There may be other approaches.
You can find a patch that solves this here:
http://people.redhat.com/sgrubb/files/audit-3.0.8-flex-array-workaround.patch
Before applying this patch, the build script needs to copy /usr/include/linux/audit.h to lib/ in the build directory.
Cheers,
-Steve
--
Linux-audit mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-audit
Hello,
Quoted 20 lines · EST Steve Grubb
Recently, distributions moved to building against gcc-12 for their latest OS composes. It's been found in at least 2 distributions that the user space package is failing to build. It's natural to think this is related to gcc-12 since it's the obvious change.
However, the problem is a combination of 2 things:
1) SWIG is making buggy code
2) The kernel changed to using flexible array membersThe issue specifically is with struct
audit_rules_data. At the bottom, it was using buf[0]; But on 5.17, it uses buf[]; It turns out that gcc-12 is just a coincidence and anything using gcc-12 also has the newest kernel.The options are:
1) Report this as a SWIG bug and wait
2) Rewrite the libaudit python bindings to not use SWIG
3) Ask for buf[0]; to be reinstated in the kernel.
Quoted 7 lines
Of these, I think option 2 is the only viable long term option. It will take some time to write new python bindings that preserve the SWIG api.
A short term fix might be for distros to copy the kernel header into the lib directory and patch it to restore buf[0];, then change
libaudit.cto include "audit.h" instead of <linux/audit.h>. There may be other approaches.
An update on this topic...I have worked around this on rawhide. The temporary fix is kind of ugly and I also have no idea how long this temporary fix will be needed. Rewriting the python bindings will be a big task. Anyways...the first patch can be found here:
https://src.fedoraproject.org/rpms/audit/blob/rawhide/f/audit-3.0.8-flex-array-workaround.patch
Prior to applying the patch, I do this is the %prep part of the spec file:
cp /usr/include/linux/audit.h lib/
then the patch applies cleanly. The only problem is that if you leave it this way, then you wind up with other packages not building because they can't find audit.h. (See bz 2057735 for example) The fix for this is after the audit scripts do the install to the buildroot, you need to undo the change in libaudit.h. That patch can be found here:
https://src.fedoraproject.org/rpms/audit/blob/rawhide/f/audit-3.0.8-undo-flex-array.patch
After that, rpm grabs all the files and everything works as intended. As I said before, this is an ugly fix...but it works for now.
Hope this helps with packaging...
-Steve
--
Linux-audit mailing list
[email protected]
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-audit