Wonky PS2-USB converter issues...
Quite some time ago, I posted about a problematic PS2-USB converter that I used to connect an old PS2-connector keyboard to my laptop dock, where the keyboard wouldn't be recognized at boot unless I unplugged and reconnected it.
Well, I've recently figured out (partly by obtaining a converter from a different vendor) that the converters both work correctly when plugged into a USB port that's physically on my Dell Latitude laptop - but they have issues and require a reconnect cycle when plugged into the docking station for the laptop. (It took a long time to figure this out, because *of course* you plug this sort of stuff into the docking station specifically so you don't have to plug it in every morning).
So obviously, it isn't the converter that is the problem, but the docking station is doing "something stupid". Anybody have suggestions on figuring out what it's doing wrong?
Quoted 14 lines · Valdis Kletnieks
Quite some time ago, I posted about a problematic PS2-USB converter that I used to connect an old PS2-connector keyboard to my laptop dock, where the keyboard wouldn't be recognized at boot unless I unplugged and reconnected it.
Well, I've recently figured out (partly by obtaining a converter from a different vendor) that the converters both work correctly when plugged into a USB port that's physically on my Dell Latitude laptop - but they have issues and require a reconnect cycle when plugged into the docking station for the laptop. (It took a long time to figure this out, because *of course* you plug this sort of stuff into the docking station specifically so you don't have to plug it in every morning).
Quoted 3 lines
So obviously, it isn't the converter that is the problem, but the docking station is doing "something stupid". Anybody have suggestions on figuring out what it's doing wrong?
PS-2 connectors can not normally handle hotplugging, the protocol doesn't allow it, and for some unlucky devices, it could actually fry the motherboard or the PS-2 device.
So that's probably the issue here, the device just doesn't support it, sorry.
greg k-h
Quoted 6 lines · Greg Kroah-Hartman
PS-2 connectors can not normally handle hotplugging, the protocol doesn't allow it, and for some unlucky devices, it could actually fry the motherboard or the PS-2 device.
So that's probably the issue here, the device just doesn't support it, sorry.
You mis-understood the problem.
This works:
PS/2 keyboard plugged into this device:
Bus 006 Device 002: ID 0e8f:0020 GreenAsia Inc. USB to PS/2 Adapter USB side of device plugged into USB port on the Latitude laptop. Power up, boot - the keyboard works.
If you plug the USB side of the GreenAsia adapter into a USB slot on the dock, the keyboard is dead and not recognized by the system. However, replugging the USB, or unplug/plug the PS/2 side, and it becomes recognized and starts working.
This tells me that the dock is doing something busted with USB that the laptop does correctly, and not enumerating devices until something happens to whack it upside the head. I was hoping to identify it and maybe quirk it.
Quoted 18 lines · On Wed, 20 Feb 2013 [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 6 lines · Greg Kroah-Hartman
PS-2 connectors can not normally handle hotplugging, the protocol doesn't allow it, and for some unlucky devices, it could actually fry the motherboard or the PS-2 device.
So that's probably the issue here, the device just doesn't support it, sorry.
You mis-understood the problem.
This works:
PS/2 keyboard plugged into this device:
Bus 006 Device 002: ID 0e8f:0020 GreenAsia Inc. USB to PS/2 Adapter USB side of device plugged into USB port on the Latitude laptop. Power up, boot - the keyboard works.
Quoted 8 lines
If you plug the USB side of the GreenAsia adapter into a USB slot on the dock, the keyboard is dead and not recognized by the system. However, replugging the USB, or unplug/plug the PS/2 side, and it becomes recognized and starts working.
This tells me that the dock is doing something busted with USB that the laptop does correctly, and not enumerating devices until something happens to whack it upside the head. I was hoping to identify it and maybe quirk it.
What happens if you prevent ehci-hcd from being loaded during boot and then load it manually afterward? Does the keyboard/adapter/dock combination work then?
If it doesn't, try recording a usbmon trace.
Alan Stern