Skip to contentSkip to conversation

OpenBMC Solution To CVE issues

DISCUSSION Yonghui YH21 Liu 4 participants 4 messages Aug 13, 2019

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

HI All,
I saw there are some solutions to public CVE issues, some solution are not enable by default setting.
As we know, there are some new coming CVE issues. Could you help confirm whether below issues will be fixed? Is yes, when will be ready?

CVE-2019-12900
CVE-2018-20843
CVE-2019-9169
CVE-2018-20750
CVE-2019-13404

Thank your great support in advance!

Thanks

#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · On 8/12/19 10:21 PM, Yonghui YH21 Liu wrote:

HI All,

         I saw there are some solutions to public CVE issues, some solution are not enable by default setting.

I've provided by initial thoughts about how these CVEs affect OpenBMC.  This is from the point of view of code running on OpenBMC 2.7.0 systems.  My responses disregard vulnerabilities which may affect the build host.

Will BMC subject matter experts review the information below and provide answers?

- Joseph

Quoted 4 lines

         As we know, there are some new coming CVE issues. Could you help confirm whether below issues will be fixed? Is yes, when will be ready?

      CVE-2019-12900

The problem: BZ2 decompress - affects bzip2 through 1.0.6
Impact: we are impacted, we are at bzip2 1.0.6
How to exploit?  Do any OpenBMC interfaces use BZ2 compression? Image upload?  Web interfaces?  If so, we may be impacted.

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2018-20843

The problem: affects Expat XML before 2.2.7
Impact: Not applicable, OpenBMC does not use XML

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2019-9169

The problem: glibc/libc6 regexec proceed_next_node
Impact: we are impacted, we are on glibc 2.29
How to exploit?  Do any OpenBMC interfaces parse regular expressions?  If so we may be impacted?  If not, this will be hared to exploit.

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2018-20750

The problem: libvncserver/rfbserver.c, affects LibVNC through 0.9.12
Impact: we may be impacted, we are on 0.9.12
Does our KVM use vncserver?

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2019-13404

The problem: Python installer, applies to Windows
Impact: not applicable, note that OpenBMC removed Python from the image

Quoted 4 lines

Thank your great support in advance!

Thanks

#2 lore raw
Quoted 34 lines · Joseph Reynolds
Quoted 6 lines · On 8/12/19 10:21 PM, Yonghui YH21 Liu wrote:

HI All,

I saw there are some solutions to public CVE issues, some
solution are not enable by default setting.

I've provided by initial thoughts about how these CVEs affect OpenBMC. This is from the point of view of code running on OpenBMC 2.7.0 systems. My responses disregard vulnerabilities which may affect the build host.

Will BMC subject matter experts review the information below and provide answers?

- Joseph

Quoted 6 lines

As we know, there are some new coming CVE issues. Could you
help confirm whether below issues will be fixed? Is yes, when will be ready?

      CVE-2019-12900

The problem: BZ2 decompress - affects bzip2 through 1.0.6
Impact: we are impacted, we are at bzip2 1.0.6
How to exploit? Do any OpenBMC interfaces use BZ2 compression? Image upload? Web interfaces? If so, we may be impacted.

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2018-20843

The problem: affects Expat XML before 2.2.7
Impact: Not applicable, OpenBMC does not use XML

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2019-9169

The problem: glibc/libc6 regexec proceed_next_node
Impact: we are impacted, we are on glibc 2.29
How to exploit? Do any OpenBMC interfaces parse regular expressions? If so we may be impacted? If not, this will be hared to exploit.

We parse regular expressions, however they're pre-programmed, versus allowing user-input. This makes them difficult to exploit. I don't know if bmcweb offers that type of input from the user, but I can't imagine -- but someone can follow-up.

Quoted 17 lines
Quoted 3 lines

CVE-2018-20750

The problem: libvncserver/rfbserver.c, affects LibVNC through 0.9.12
Impact: we may be impacted, we are on 0.9.12
Does our KVM use vncserver?

Quoted 2 lines

CVE-2019-13404

The problem: Python installer, applies to Windows
Impact: not applicable, note that OpenBMC removed Python from the image

Quoted 4 lines

Thank your great support in advance!

Thanks

#3 lore raw
In reply to Joseph Reynolds
Quoted 5 lines · Joseph Reynolds
Quoted 1 line

The problem: BZ2 decompress - affects bzip2 through 1.0.6
Impact: we are impacted, we are at bzip2 1.0.6
How to exploit?  Do any OpenBMC interfaces use BZ2 compression? Image upload?  Web interfaces?  If so, we may be impacted.

The web doesn't implement BZ2 compression, only GZIP.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

CVE-2018-20843

The problem: affects Expat XML before 2.2.7
Impact: Not applicable, OpenBMC does not use XML

Do we even use libexpat anywhere? We use XML in several places, but I can't think of anywhere we use Expat.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

CVE-2019-9169

The problem: glibc/libc6 regexec proceed_next_node
Impact: we are impacted, we are on glibc 2.29
How to exploit?  Do any OpenBMC interfaces parse regular expressions? If so we may be impacted?  If not, this will be hared to exploit.

I just audited all uses of std::regex in bmcweb. They are all using compile-time strings for generating their expression. Also, all uses are post-authentication (on purpose) so even if there was an exploit, it would be a relatively low CVE score, as it would require valid credentials to exploit.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

CVE-2018-20750

The problem: libvncserver/rfbserver.c, affects LibVNC through 0.9.12
Impact: we may be impacted, we are on 0.9.12
Does our KVM use vncserver?

Yes. We will just need to upgrade the package version when the new release is available.

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 3 lines

CVE-2019-13404

The problem: Python installer, applies to Windows
Impact: not applicable, note that OpenBMC removed Python from the image

Quoted 4 lines

Thank your great support in advance!

Thanks