Skip to contentSkip to conversation

PCI/e with dual DVB-T + AV-in?

DISCUSSION Jed 4 participants 14 messages Sep 3, 2009 – Sep 11, 2009 6 messages not in the archive Media (V4L/DVB)

lore
Share & tools
lore

Jed

author
#0 lore raw

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?* As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being
my final choice.

author
#1 lore raw

I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working. Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important... So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Wish me luck! :-D

Quoted 16 lines · Jed

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?* As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up
being my final choice.

#2 lore raw
Quoted 30 lines · Jed
Quoted 15 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know.
Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

Quoted 7 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
 I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being my final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 2 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported not for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com

I hope this helps.

Regards,

Mike

#3 lore raw
Quoted 42 lines · Michael Krufky
Quoted 30 lines · Jed
Quoted 15 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know.
Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

Quoted 7 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
 I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being my final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 2 lines

Wish me luck!   :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only.  It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface.  It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux.  Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode.  (although not yet in Linux)  This probably is the device for you.

Quoted 8 lines

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com

I hope this helps.

Regards,

Mike

Yikes -- typo (corrected above)

HVR2200 is in well supported *now* for digital-only

-Mike

author
#4 lore raw
In reply to Michael Krufky
Quoted 44 lines
Quoted 32 lines
Quoted 16 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know.
Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated!
:-D

Quoted 8 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being my
final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 3 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

Quoted 9 lines

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com

I hope this helps.

Regards,

Mike

Thanks Michael for your efforts to make a suggestion!

I know about this one and so far it looks to be the best candidate in-terms of overall features + support. Unless people on this list believe there's something that's _potentially_ better?

Cheers,
Jed

author
#5 lore raw
Quoted 41 lines
Quoted 41 lines
Quoted 32 lines
Quoted 15 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know.
Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated!
:-D

Quoted 9 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up
being my
final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 3 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com I hope this helps.

Regards,
Mike

Hi saa7164 devs, once(if) the software support is in place for A/V-in...
Do you know if it'd be possible to bypass hw encode and dump uncompressed HD/SD with this card? Or is it limited hardware-wise to even do this?

Cheers,
Jed

author
#6 lore raw
Quoted 51 lines
Quoted 42 lines
Quoted 42 lines
Quoted 33 lines
Quoted 16 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know.
Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated!
:-D

Quoted 9 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up
being my
final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 3 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com I hope this helps.

Regards,
Mike

Quoted 6 lines

Hi saa7164 devs, once(if) the software support is in place for A/V-in...
Do you know if it'd be possible to bypass hw encode and dump uncompressed HD/SD with this card? Or is it limited hardware-wise to even do this?

Cheers,
Jed

Hi, could I possibly get a response to this please?

Cheers,
Jed

#7 lore raw
Quoted 55 lines · Jed
Quoted 55 lines
Quoted 54 lines
Quoted 54 lines
Quoted 38 lines
Quoted 20 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was
wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has
dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the
best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated!
:-D

Quoted 8 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being my
final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided
AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other
features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 2 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com I hope this helps.

Regards,
Mike

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 7 lines

Hi saa7164 devs, once(if) the software support is in place for A/V-in... Do you know if it'd be possible to bypass hw encode and dump uncompressed HD/SD with this card?
Or is it limited hardware-wise to even do this?

Cheers,
Jed

Hi, could I possibly get a response to this please?

No idea, I have yet to look into this. All things considered I doubt it's worth spending time on raw analog when the goal for most people is to have the mpeg2/4/wmv hardware encoder working.

Signature · 2 lines
Steven Toth - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
author
#8 lore raw
Quoted 61 lines · Steven Toth
Quoted 60 lines · Jed
Quoted 60 lines
Quoted 46 lines
Quoted 46 lines
Quoted 38 lines
Quoted 20 lines

Hi Ya'll,

Going on response levels thus far I'm not expecting much :-D but I was
wondering if someone could possibly help me out here.

Is there anything with half-decent driver support that is PCI/e, and has
dual DVB-T + A/V-in?*
As a bonus it would be dual Hybrid and have hardware encode, but I wouldn't expect either to work at this stage.

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the
best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated!
:-D

Quoted 8 lines

Cheers,
Jed
*Is HVR-2200 the only option?
I wish there was something with better AV-in but it might end-up being my
final choice.

Jed wrote:
I've stopped looking for an alternative card, going to have a crack at getting my 7162-based device working.
Still, any suggestions in the meantime are most welcome! I've also decided
AV-in isn't that important...
So just a known, nicely working PCI/e + dual DVB-T card, having the other
features is nice but they needn't be working yet.

Quoted 2 lines

Wish me luck! :-D

HVR2200 is in well supported now for digital-only. It is a dual tuner board using a PCI-E interface. It has A/V capabilities that are not *yet* supported in Linux. Don't know when A/V will be supported, but it will probably happen, eventually.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines

It is a dual hybrid, and it does do hardware encode. (although not yet in Linux) This probably is the device for you.

To follow the development more closely, see the blog on kernellabs.com I hope this helps.

Regards,
Mike

Hi saa7164 devs, once(if) the software support is in place for A/V-in... Do you know if it'd be possible to bypass hw encode and dump uncompressed HD/SD with this card?
Or is it limited hardware-wise to even do this?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Cheers,
Jed

Hi, could I possibly get a response to this please?

No idea, I have yet to look into this. All things considered I doubt it's worth spending time on raw analog when the goal for most people is to have the mpeg2/4/wmv hardware encoder working.

Huh, but Hauppaguge site says hvr-2200 only does mpeg2 encode?
My rationale was more flexibility by using software encode and free cpu cycles, I think it would be appealing to quite a few ;-)

good night/morn

#9 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines

Huh, but Hauppaguge site says hvr-2200 only does mpeg2 encode? My rationale was more flexibility by using software encode and free cpu cycles, I think it would be appealing to quite a few ;-)

That's correct, the Windows driver does mpeg2 encode only. All of the other codecs are available by default.

Signature · 2 lines
Steven Toth - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

#15 lore raw

Re: PCI/e with dual DVB-T + AV-in (HVR-2200?)

Quoted 46 lines · Jed
Quoted 46 lines
Quoted 24 lines
Quoted 24 lines
Quoted 8 lines

Yeah I realised after seeing your 2nd email that Hauppauge only says mpeg2 because that's all the Windows dvr does! :-D

I also noticed on the website that it only talks about hw encode being for the analog rf tuners, is there no hw encode for av-in?! It seems to be other way round for most other cards....

Quoted 7 lines

Having the *option* to bypass hw encode whether it be on the analog rf-in or av-in would be a very handy feature!
Because one could instead use CPU/GPGPU resources (if suited) and more flexible software, or even dedicated encoder/transcoder addon devices.
Or in the case of video editing leave it raw for easier editing, and then transocde it as required...

Hi, I came across these two pdf's which seem to suggest that the references cards that the hvr-2200/2250 are based-on can do component in!
Could it be that (like the limitation with hw encode in Windows to mpeg2) component in is also not advertised, simply because it's not supported in Windows?
Assuming the cards are based-on the reference cards, then the hardware support seems to be there!

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines

Can someone please address my earlier points above too if you have an answer/opinion? Thanks heaps!

Jed

Hi Kernellabs or anyone involved with driver development of the HVR-2200,

I know this is long waaaay down the priority list of features to be added, if ever!
But I'm wanting to know if the *possibility* is there 'hardware-wise' for the following:

1) h.263/mpeg4/VC-1/DivX/Xvid hardware encode of A/V-in
2) Component input for the A/V-in
3) Hw encode bypass for A/V-in
4) Is Hw encode purely for A/V-in? (hauppauge's site seems to suggest otherwise but it may be a typo)
5) If not then questions 1) & 3) also apply to RF-in!

I've attached the reference cards spec. sheets again for your perusal. I would be proactive in providing as much feed-back as needed for the dev. of such features.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Most Sincerely,
Jed

For some inexplicable reason my last two posts have not appeared on the ML, it seems I've been scrubbed!
Hence I'm forwarding straight to you to answer or forward to colleagues to answer when possible.

Oh, I saw your posting to the list. It's in my inbox, along with many other emails I'd like to respond to over the next few weeks. Nothing personal, I'm just too busy right now to deal with your ongoing daily list of questions.

Please post all your questions to the ML and people will respond when they can, if they can.

Signature · 2 lines
Steven Toth - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

#17 lore raw

Re: PCI/e with dual DVB-T + AV-in (HVR-2200?)

Jed's email isn't hitting the mailing list -- lets see if I can send it.

Quoted 59 lines · Jed
Quoted 41 lines
Quoted 22 lines
Quoted 22 lines
Quoted 7 lines

Yeah I realised after seeing your 2nd email that Hauppauge only says mpeg2 because that's all the Windows dvr does!  :-D

I also noticed on the website that it only talks about hw encode being for the analog rf tuners, is there no hw encode for av-in?! It seems to be other way round for most other cards....

Quoted 6 lines

Having the *option* to bypass hw encode whether it be on the analog rf-in or av-in would be a very handy feature!
Because one could instead use CPU/GPGPU resources (if suited) and more flexible software, or even dedicated encoder/transcoder addon devices. Or in the case of video editing leave it raw for easier editing, and then transocde it as required...

Hi, I came across these two pdf's which seem to suggest that the references cards that the hvr-2200/2250 are based-on can do component in! Could it be that (like the limitation with hw encode in Windows to mpeg2) component in is also not advertised, simply because it's not supported in Windows?
Assuming the cards are based-on the reference cards, then the hardware support seems to be there!

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines

Can someone please address my earlier points above too if you have an answer/opinion? Thanks heaps!

Jed

Hi Kernellabs or anyone involved with driver development of the HVR-2200,

I know this is long waaaay down the priority list of features to be added, if ever!
But I'm wanting to know if the *possibility* is there 'hardware-wise' for the following:

1) h.263/mpeg4/VC-1/DivX/Xvid hardware encode of A/V-in
2) Component input for the A/V-in
3) Hw encode bypass for A/V-in
4) Is Hw encode purely for A/V-in? (hauppauge's site seems to suggest otherwise but it may be a typo)
5) If not then questions 1) & 3) also apply to RF-in!

Quoted 6 lines

I've attached the reference cards spec. sheets again for your perusal. I would be proactive in providing as much feed-back as needed for the dev. of such features.

Most Sincerely,
Jed

For some inexplicable reason my last two posts have not appeared on the ML, it seems I've been scrubbed!
Hence I'm forwarding straight to you to answer or forward to colleagues to answer when possible.

Regards,
Jed
P.S.
I have been posting in plain text

#18 lore raw
In reply to Jed
Quoted 4 lines · Jed

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

I've been searching for a PCI-e device with an MPEG-2 hardware encoder for analogue input for months, there's nothing on the market with linux support.

There are a few h.264 encoders, mainly aimed at CCTV applications, but they're no good for me.

Analogue encoding support on the HVR devices seems the only likely solution but it won't happen any time soon it seems.

If you find anything, please post details!

Thanks,

Lou

author
#19 lore raw

will do, no longer looking atm, seeing if i can get my existing quattroS partially working
http://www.linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/Saa7162_devices#DNTV_PCI_Express_cards

Quoted 18 lines · Lou Otway
Quoted 4 lines · Jed

I'm still trawling through mail-lists & wiki's etc, so I may yet find the best solution, but I was hoping some might already know. Any advice or even just a response to chastise me is greatly appreciated! :-D

I've been searching for a PCI-e device with an MPEG-2 hardware encoder for analogue input for months, there's nothing on the market with linux support.

There are a few h.264 encoders, mainly aimed at CCTV applications, but they're no good for me.

Analogue encoding support on the HVR devices seems the only likely solution but it won't happen any time soon it seems.

If you find anything, please post details!

Thanks,

Lou