To Linus: kdb in 2.4?
I'm wondering about the possibility of re-examining the idea of a kernel debugger option distributed with 2.4.
I'm thinking that it could be a great teaching tool to break and examine structures, variables, process states, as well as an aid to people who may not have a grasp of the entire kernel but need to write device drivers.
It's easy for someone who's "grown up" with Linux to know it all so thoroughly that such a tool seems fluff. But even the best mechanics on new cars use complex diagnostic tools to do car repair. Sure there may be experts that designed the engine that wouldn't need it, but large numbers of people need to repair cars or modify them for their purposes. Having tools to aid in that isn't so much a crutch as it is a learning tool. It's like being able to look at the characters of the alphabet individually before one learns to comprehend the entirety of the writings of Buddha.
Certainly Buddha doesn't need to know how to read to know his own writings -- and certainly, if everyone meditates and 'evolves' to their Buddha nature, they wouldn't need to read the texts or recognize the letters either.
But not everyone is at the same place on the mountain (or even the same mountain, for that matter).
In wisdom, one would, I posit, understand others are in different places and may find it useful to have tools to learn to read before they comprehend.
Just my 2-4 cents on the matter...
Signature · 2 lines
L A Walsh | Trust Technology, Core Linux, SGI [email protected] | Voice: (650) 933-5338
Quoted 2 lines · [email protected] said:
I'm wondering about the possibility of re-examining the idea of a kernel debugger option distributed with 2.4.
First off, I'd like to say that I'm highly sympathetic to this, assuming that a kernel debugger doesn't change the kernel's behavior.
However,
Quoted 4 lines
I'm thinking that it could be a great teaching tool to break and examine structures, variables, process states, as well as an aid to people who may not have a grasp of the entire kernel but need to write device drivers.
you might look at UML (http://user-mode-linux.sourceforge.net) for this. A number of kernel hackers are very successfully using UML for doing filesystem and mm development and debugging. With some help from the host, it's also possible to do driver development under UML.
I also know of a number of people using UML to further their education by using it to poke around a running kernel.
Quoted 4 lines
Certainly Buddha doesn't need to know how to read to know his own writings -- and certainly, if everyone meditates and 'evolves' to their Buddha nature, they wouldn't need to read the texts or recognize the letters either.
So, if you can't convince Buddha of the wisdom of your arguments (or even if you can) check out UML. It makes a perfectly good kernel debugger available, and it's a lot easier to deal with than a native kernel.
Jeff