Binary only module overview
Hi,
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
Greetings,
Arjan van de Ven
Hardware drivers
----------------
4-Front - soundcard drivers
Adaptec - Fiberchannel cards
Agilent - Fiberchannel cards
aureal - driver for soundcard
Conexant - winmodem driver
Emulex - Fiberchannel cards
Highpoint - lowlevel IDE driver + software raid
IBM - All hardware networkdrivers for S/390
Lucent - driver for winmodem
Motorola - driver for winmodem
M-Systems - flash chips
NVidia - 3D driver for their hardware
Olicom - tokenring networkcard
PCTel - winmodem driver
Philips - webcam driver
Promise - lowlevel IDE driver + software raid
Sigma designs - driver for soundcard
Highlevel drivers
-----------------
Cisco - IPSEC
Hewlet Packard - High level security modules (LSM)
Intel - IPSEC
Netraverse - Win4lin
SGI - XFS cluster extensions
- High level security modules (LSM)
Sistina - GFS and cluster extensions for LVM
Veritas - Filesystem and Software RAID clusterextensions
Wirex - High level security modules (LSM)
Quoted 3 lines
IBM - All hardware networkdrivers for S/390
Philips - webcam driver
Compression for - the driver itself is free, and is usable without
Quoted 1 line
Sigma designs - driver for soundcard
Mpeg card
Intel btw also have a binary only winmodem driver (HaM)
Motorola SM56 winmodem
Quoted 6 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
Rasmus
Signature · 5 lines
-- [ Rasmus 'Møffe' Bøg Hansen ] ---------------------------------------
ATA100 is another testimony to the fact that pigs can be
made to fly given sufficient thrust (to borrow an RFC)
-Alan Cox
--------------------------------- [ moffe at amagerkollegiet dot dk ] --Quoted 10 lines · Rasmus Bøg Hansen
Quoted 6 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
Yes, but they do provide source, so they lie in a grey area.
Signature · 1 line
Ignacio Vazquez-Abrams <[email protected]>
Quoted 1 line
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
They come as tarballs, complete as source, in addition to some precompiled versions.
Andreas Steinmetz
D.O.M. Datenverarbeitung GmbH
Quoted 9 lines · Rasmus Bøg Hansen
Quoted 5 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about
modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all
intents and purposes)
Quoted 5 lines
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
Rasmus
Yes, but the modules are not binary-only.
The sourcecode is in the package, although it is not GPL.
Regards
Anders Fugman
Quoted 6 lines · --On Monday, September 24, 2001 19:08:27 +0200 Anders Peter Fugmann…
Quoted 4 lines
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
Rasmus
Yes, but the modules are not binary-only.
The sourcecode is in the package, although it is not GPL.
I believe they only provide source for an interface layer that can be compiled against a specific version of the kernel. I think the core drivers are binary only.
Dave McCracken
======================================================================
Dave McCracken IBM Linux Base Kernel Team 1-512-838-3059
[email protected] T/L 678-3059
Quoted 1 line
IIRC, vmware includes one or more kernel modules.
Their kernel modules are GPL, although they let other stuff do icky things
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Hardware drivers
----------------
AVM - CAPI drivers for their passive ISDN cards
(Fritz!Classic, Fritz!PCI, Fritz!PnP, Fritz!PCMCIA,
Fritz!USB)
For most of the hardware open source drivers exist as well, lacking some functionality, like e.g. softfax
--Kai
Quoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
Sigma designs - driver for soundcard
That's their NetStream 2000 DVD (mpeg/ac3) decoder. There are reverse engineered (GPL) drivers for the Hollywood Plus.
As a side note, there are currently 4 misc minor numbers allocated to the em8300 drivers (according to Documentation/devices.txt). That's fine for one card but the driver support up to 4 cards so we'd need 16 devices in that case. Currently we're using major number 121. Does anyone have suggestions for moving over to official device numbers?
Signature · 5 lines
Rick ([email protected]) http://dxr3.sourceforge.net I think the slogan of the fansubbers puts it best: "Cheaper than crack, and lots more fun."
Quoted 5 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Highlevel drivers
-----------------
Hewlet Packard - High level security modules (LSM)
SGI - High level security modules (LSM)
Wirex - High level security modules (LSM)
For those interested in the current LSM licensing issues, feel free to join the discussion on the linux-security-module-list:
http://mail.wirex.com/mailman/listinfo/linux-security-module
The thread can be read online starting at:
http://mail.wirex.com/pipermail/linux-security-module/2001-September/thread.html#2017
with the title:
GPL only usage of security.h
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 9 lines
Hi,
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
Quoted 6 lines
Greetings,
Arjan van de VenSGI - XFS cluster extensions
This is not something which is available yet.
and you can add:
Tricord - filesystem,
the only public info about this appears here:
they do not advertise the fact that their hardware runs Linux too much.
Steve
Re: Binary only module question
In reply to Arjan van de VenQuoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Will the list be available somewhere?
I'm working on a tool that (among other things) indicates what is "accepted practice" for loadable modules that are binary. I seem to recall Linus saying, some years ago, something about the the fact that the module must not be fundamental to basic kernel operation. I can't remember the exact details of the quote (if anyone has it, I'd appreciate a reference to it), but I thought the general spirit was that add-on's are OK, but basic functionality (like the scheduler, memory management, driver *systems* (not drivers themselves), etc.) were off limits for being binary modules.
I'm assuming that if a module is currently known, and there does not appear to be great backlash against it, that it is accepted practice. Also, I assume that modules that perform essentially the same functionality as these would also be acceptable (from a community standpoint - the legal standpoint is a different matter). Basically, I'm infering a kind of community precendence from existing known binary modules?
Am I way off?
(And yes, I know that given a choice, the community vastly prefers an open source module over a binary module)
____________________________________________________________
Tim Bird Lineo, Inc. Senior VP, Research 390 South 400 West [email protected] Lindon, UT 84042
Hello,
Quoted 4 lines · On 24-Sep-2001 Arjan van de Ven wrote:
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Hardware drivers
----------------
Samsung - wireless lan driver (prism2 chipset, binary core with source
for interface layer)
see www.magiclan.com
Signature · 4 lines
bye, Michael Leun
Quoted 5 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 1 line · Arjan van de Ven
Highlevel drivers
...
Quoted 1 line
SGI - High level security modules (LSM)
License terms and release scheme for this work
have not been finalized.
Signature · 3 lines
Casey Schaufler Manager, Trust Technology, SGI [email protected] voice: 650.933.1634 [email protected] Pager: 888.220.0607
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
SGI - High level security modules (LSM)
License terms and release scheme for this work
have not been finalized.
But from your comments on the LSM list we can guess
Quoted 7 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines
SGI - High level security modules (LSM)
License terms and release scheme for this work
have not been finalized.But from your comments on the LSM list we can guess
Sure you can guess. That's all you'll be doing though. As a representitive of a corporate entity it is important that I not make promises that I can't keep. I would like to provide all facilities under GPL or more liberal terms. We have to deal with potential legal encumberances, and that's a fact of corporate life. I can say that I want to use GPL, that I plan to use GPL (which is true) but I am required to provide notice that I may not be able for legal, copywrite, or corporate poliy reasons to commit to doing so. This is one of the disadvantages of being a wage slave.
Signature · 3 lines
Casey Schaufler Manager, Trust Technology, SGI [email protected] voice: 650.933.1634 [email protected] Pager: 888.220.0607
On Mon, 24 Sep 2001 12:40:44 -0400 Arjan van de Ven <[email protected]> wrote:
AvdV> Hi,
AvdV>
AvdV> I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, AvdV> and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, AvdV> so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I AvdV> left out, so that I can complete the list.
Win4Lin both patches kernel and uses binary modules (www.netraverse.com). Check Point FireWall-1 uses binary module (www.checkpoint.com).
Regards,
Nerijus
Quoted 7 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Hi,
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about
modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all
intents and purposes)
The Znyx driver appears to have a binary-only core (the file znb/rlk.O (note the capital letter 'O')).
Regards,
Brian Strand
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/
greg k-h
Quoted 6 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Hi,
Highlevel drivers
-----------------
You can probably add mvfs ClearCase file system but I don't remember the URL.
Cheers
Fabbione
Signature · 2 lines
Debian GNU/Linux Unstable Kernel 2.4.9 fabbione on irc.atdot.it #coredump #kchat | [email protected]
Quoted 8 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/
Umm, is it me or is that totally against the GPL? Have you bitched at them about this?
Signature · 8 lines
Mark Zealey [email protected] UL++++>$ G!>(GCM/GCS/GS/GM) dpu? s:-@ a16! C++++>$ P++++>+++++$ L+++>+++++$ !E---? W+++>$ N- !o? !w--- O? !M? !V? !PS !PE--@ PGP+? r++ !t---?@ !X---? !R- b+ !tv b+ DI+ D+? G+++ e>+++++ !h++* r!-- y-- (www.geekcode.com)
Quoted 6 lines · Mark Zealey
Quoted 4 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/Umm, is it me or is that totally against the GPL? Have you bitched at them about this?
IIRC, the GPL only talks about _modifications_of_ GPLed code, not _modifications_made_to_. Argus is treading a line, but it may not be doing anything illegal.
Signature · 1 line
Ignacio Vazquez-Abrams <[email protected]>
Quoted 6 lines · Mark Zealey
Quoted 4 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/Umm, is it me or is that totally against the GPL? Have you bitched at them about this?
I have only talked to one of their resellers, who could not find a link to the code anywhere. I have not asked them directly. I will go do that right now.
thanks,
greg k-h
Hi Greg,
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/Umm, is it me or is that totally against the GPL? Have you bitched at them about this?
I have only talked to one of their resellers, who could not find a link to the code anywhere. I have not asked them directly. I will go do that right now.
If you're dealing with argus, ask straight for developers or technical people not resellers. The second problem is that they ceased making their
Pitbull LX product available for download on the web for some reasons. Since I work with argus-system products sometime I got the chance of still
having a copy of this huge tarball and I made a diff or their actual changes
to the 2.2.19 kernel for you. Unfortunately I had to put it onto a non- argus related development site and I will leave it there for the next 12 hours. Grab it, analyse it and convince yourself that they actually go quite into the direction of the LSM framework approach. Actually I talked
to one of the argus technical guys about a possible port to the LSM frame-
work and he said that they are going to look into it. Of course the lkm with the real security functionality is binary only. Decide yourself ...
http://www.linuxvirtualserver.org/~ratz/argus.diff
Best regards,
Roberto Nibali, ratz
Quoted 3 lines · Roberto Nibali
If you're dealing with argus, ask straight for developers or technical people not resellers.
I did just directly email them. Thanks for letting me know.
Quoted 4 lines
The second problem is that they ceased making their
Pitbull LX product available for download on the web for some reasons. Since I work with argus-system products sometime I got the chance of still having a copy of this huge tarball and I made a diff or their
Quoted 8 lines
actual changes to the 2.2.19 kernel for you. Unfortunately I had to put it onto a non- argus related development site and I will leave it there for the next 12 hours. Grab it, analyse it and convince yourself that they actually go quite into the direction of the LSM framework approach. Actually I talked to one of the argus technical guys about a possible port to the LSM frame- work and he said that they are going to look into it. Of course the lkm with the real security functionality is binary only. Decide yourself ...
Thank you for putting this up. It looks like they are placing hooks all through the kernel, much like the LSM patch does.
And since they are patching the kernel to provide hooks for their security module, they should also release that security module source code to remain legal.
Thanks again.
greg k-h
Hi Greg,
Quoted 2 lines
Thank you for putting this up. It looks like they are placing hooks all through the kernel, much like the LSM patch does.
Yep, and I reckon that they could port their security module to the LSM one within one week. I mentioned it to Peter Loscocco at OLS 2001 at the LSM BOF.
Quoted 3 lines
And since they are patching the kernel to provide hooks for their security module, they should also release that security module source code to remain legal.
I don't know about GPL and kernel related rights but I can hardly imagine a company that has a B1 certified product not to care well about their other products to be on the right side of the law. I can talk to them on thursday about this at the comdex/orbit showcase. The outcome of your legality statement might be crucial for their future business.
BTW, I recall the HP Linux which IMO also violates the GPL then, doesn't it? http://www.hp.com/security/products/linux/opensource/
Or does this differ in them providing the source code even for the LKMs as opposite to argus which has binary only LKMs?
Quoted 1 line
Thanks again.
No problem, regards,
Roberto Nibali, ratz
Quoted 7 lines · Roberto Nibali
I don't know about GPL and kernel related rights but I can hardly imagine a company that has a B1 certified product not to care well about their other products to be on the right side of the law. I can talk to them on thursday about this at the comdex/orbit showcase. The outcome of your legality statement might be crucial for their future business.
Yes, the LSM licensing issue seems to be critical to a lot of people :) Presently I am waiting for a response from WireX as to what their stance is.
Quoted 4 lines
BTW, I recall the HP Linux which IMO also violates the GPL then, doesn't it? http://www.hp.com/security/products/linux/opensource/
Or does this differ in them providing the source code even for the LKMs as opposite to argus which has binary only LKMs?
Exactly. It looks like HP provides the source code for everything (someone tell me if I'm wrong here) while Argus looks like they only provide the kernel patches and a compiled loadable module binary, under a unknown license (at this time.)
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 1 line
Yes, the LSM licensing issue seems to be critical to a lot of people :)
I read the current evolvement of the LSM framework and its ongoing licensing discussions with great affection and joy :) This is what happens if too many third party vendors get interested in yet another possiblity of selling their product under Linux legally ...
Quoted 2 lines
Presently I am waiting for a response from WireX as to what their stance is.
Ok. I thought it had to be GPL anyway but then again I'm not too familiar with the whole LSM "patch" yet. It seems as if there are multiple licenses needed. [Well, that's what we have the MODULE_LICENSE for then.]
Quoted 4 lines
Exactly. It looks like HP provides the source code for everything (someone tell me if I'm wrong here) while Argus looks like they only provide the kernel patches and a compiled loadable module binary, under a unknown license (at this time.)
I put their license on the page too. Enjoy the binary software license:
http://www.linuxvirtualserver.org/~ratz/argus-license.txt
Cheers,
Roberto Nibali, ratz
Quoted 12 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 11 lines · Mark Zealey
Quoted 8 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 2 lines · Arjan van de Ven
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules,
Argus System's PitBull for Linux modifies the kernel. No source or patches for these modifications can be found on the web, so I'm guessing that it's closed source:
http://www.argus-systems.com/
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Umm, is it me or is that totally against the GPL? Have you bitched at them about this?
I have only talked to one of their resellers, who could not find a link to the code anywhere. I have not asked them directly. I will go do that right now.
Argus has responded to me that their kernel patch is released under the GPL (and will be placing it up on a sf.net site soon.) However their security kernel module that their patch uses is closed source. So add them to the closed source module list :)
As for the legality of modifying the kernel to provide hooks for your closed source driver, I'm not going to argue that one, but I thought it was forbidden.
thanks,
greg k-h
Quoted 3 lines
As for the legality of modifying the kernel to provide hooks for your closed source driver, I'm not going to argue that one, but I thought it was forbidden.
Indeed.
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Arjan" == Arjan van de Ven <[email protected]> writes:
Arjan> Hi, I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, Arjan> and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly Arjan> forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know Arjan> about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I Arjan> do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or Arjan> earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
Arjan> Greetings, Arjan van de Ven
Arjan> Hardware drivers ----------------
JNI - Fibre Channel cards: http://www.jni.com/Drivers/drivers2.cfm?OS=6
Can't seem to find any source there ;-(
Jes
Quoted 2 lines · Fabbione
You can probably add mvfs ClearCase file system but I don't remember the URL.
http://www.rational.com/ is the corporate website, and the particular product is at http://www.rational.com/products/clearcase/ .
The actual module is an implementation of the Rational (previously Atria) ClearCase mvfs filesystem for Linux; it is composed of a source-available translation layer, and a binary-only core.
One important note to mention: they only support Red Hat-supplied kernels; there is a high chance of failure using it with a stock kernel, due to changes in internal structures required by mvfs.
Signature · 3 lines
Edward S. Marshall <[email protected]> http://esm.logic.net/ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [ Felix qui potuit rerum cognoscere causas. ]
Hi,
Quoted 15 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Hi,
I'm composing a list of all existing binary only modules, and I got to a list of 26 different modules; I undoubtedly forgot a few, so I hereby request feedback from people who know about modules I left out, so that I can complete the list. (I do not really care about modules that once existed for 2.0 or earlier and no longer exist for all intents and purposes)
Greetings,
Arjan van de VenHardware drivers
----------------
[...]
Quoted 1 line
PCTel - winmodem driver
This one is not really 100% binary only, it use
an modified version of serial.c kernel driver. Of course it's freely available.
Cheers.
Signature · 4 lines
73's de Daniel, F1RMB.
-=- Daniel Caujolle-Bert -=- [email protected] -=-
-=- [email protected] (AMPR NET) -=-Quoted 8 lines · Daniel Caujolle-Bert
Quoted 2 lines
Hardware drivers
----------------[...]
Quoted 1 line
PCTel - winmodem driver
This one is not really 100% binary only, it use
an modified version ofserial.ckernel driver. Of course it's freely available.
That I would call an obvious GPL violation... no discussion about vague "interfaces", if you directly link serial.c (even modified) into a non-GPL .o file that's obvious....
Quoted 3 lines
That I would call an obvious GPL violation... no discussion about vague "interfaces", if you directly link
serial.c(even modified) into a non-GPL .o file that's obvious....
I raised this one with Ted T'so (who wrote the serial.c they use) a long time ago. Ted seemed happy for this to occur - and its kind of his code, his business.
Quoted 7 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 3 lines
That I would call an obvious GPL violation... no discussion about vague "interfaces", if you directly link
serial.c(even modified) into a non-GPL .o file that's obvious....I raised this one with Ted T'so (who wrote the
serial.cthey use) a long time ago. Ted seemed happy for this to occur - and its kind of his code, his business.
Prehaps it'd be a good idea to (unofficialy) ask authors of drivers in the kernel that are thought to be GPL'd and not known to be under other licenses (BSD etc.), to (when possible) let the public know that they've granted some sort of license to a company/person to use that code in a binary-only module, so that people don't start accusing people of blatant GPL violations if they happen to notice. serial.c would be a perfect example of something that could be construed as a blatant violation and people might start yelling at the company and others about it, and it might make the company less willing to support Linux *at all*.
I'd prefer that there was no such thing as a binary-only module, but IMO binary-only is better than no support whatsoever. And if people start yelling at companies for using something they may have a legitimate license for, those companies may wonder what the point is in supporting Linux at all.
(This isn't directed at Arjan van de Ven, he just stated obvious facts, he didn't go off half-cocked at anybody :)
Quoted 2 lines · Nicholas Knight
I'd prefer that there was no such thing as a binary-only module, but IMO binary-only is better than no support whatsoever.
If the module works in user-space Linux, problem solved.
Quoted 8 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 4 lines
That I would call an obvious GPL violation... no discussion about vague "interfaces", if you directly link
serial.c(even modified) into a non-GPL .o file that's obvious....I raised this one with Ted T'so (who wrote the
serial.cthey use) a long time ago. Ted seemed happy for this to occur - and its kind of his code, his business.
I don't understand you here, sorry, complicated sentence are
hard for me :<. Anyway, i am one of the one who hacked and old version of this driver for 2.4.7+, of course i can understand it's a GPL violation,
but like another guy wrote (sorry, i haven't his name liying around), binary only module is *almost* better than no support.
Cheers.
Signature · 4 lines
73's de Daniel, F1RMB.
-=- Daniel Caujolle-Bert -=- [email protected] -=-
-=- [email protected] (AMPR NET) -=-