Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Sound issues with kernel 2.4.14 - 2.4.17

DISCUSSION Paul G. Allen 2 participants 3 messages Dec 27, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Sound worked fine through kernel 2.4.9. Since I upgraded to 2.4.14, and now to 2.4.17 (I skipped 2.4.10 - 2.4.13) I have several games that are FUBAR, all sound related: Quake III Arena and Quake II both core dump initializing sound; Soldier of Fortune, Railroad Tycoon II, Sid Myers Alpha Centaury all make strange noises with no intelligable game sound. Tribes 2, Unreal Tournament, and Descent 3 all work fine. GNOME and Enlightenment sound work fine as well, as does xmms.

I have a SB Live! OEM and have tried compiling with and without the MIDI module. The main thing is I am trying to do some game development and it's impossible when sound is FUBAR. Any ideas?

I hate to go back to an earlier kernel as IDE did not work (for me) in the previous kernels.

PGA

Signature · 4 lines
Paul G. Allen
Owner, Sr. Engineer, Security Specialist
Random Logic/Dream Park
www.randomlogic.com
#1 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Paul G. Allen

Sound worked fine through kernel 2.4.9. Since I upgraded to 2.4.14, and now to 2.4.17 (I skipped 2.4.10 - 2.4.13) I have several games that are FUBAR, all sound related: Quake III Arena and Quake II both core dump initializing sound; Soldier of Fortune, Railroad Tycoon II, Sid Myers Alpha Centaury all make strange noises with no intelligable game sound. Tribes 2, Unreal Tournament, and Descent 3 all work fine. GNOME and Enlightenment sound work fine as well, as does xmms.

Quoted 9 lines

I have a SB Live! OEM and have tried compiling with and without the MIDI module. The main thing is I am trying to do some game development and it's impossible when sound is FUBAR. Any ideas?

I hate to go back to an earlier kernel as IDE did not work (for me) in the previous kernels.

PGA

Hello!

I ran into a similar problem:
Upgraded from 2.4.5 to 2.4.14 and added some RAM (total 1GB now). When not using
HIHGMEM_4GB, ~180MB of the RAM was missing. With HIGHMEM_4GB enabled, sound
was totally trashed (I also had the segfaulting Quake3Arena).

The SBLive uses the "emu10k1"-driver - and the driver that came with 2.4.14 was broken if used with "HIGHMEM" enabled. W/o this, the sound had no problems. Rui Sousa made it working with HIGMEM enabled. (But sometimes, especially with very little free RAM left the sound is still broken )

Have you tried the latest snapshot from opensource.creative.com ?
I've taken a look into the kernel-patches (I'm still at 2.4.14 - will upgrade to 2.4.17 when SGI's XFS is ready for thet kernel), and there were no version-changes in the driver.

How to do it (very short):
Unzip and untar, cd into "emu10k1_<date>" and do "make && make install"
(maybe save the old from "/lib/modules/<kernel-version>/kernel/drivers/sound" and "sound/emu10k1" before...) Remove your loaded "emu10k1" and "ac97_codec" modules (don't forget this), load the new and test it.

There are some more nice features within Creatives "official" drivers (such as bass/treble control)...

ciao

Michael

#2 lore raw
In reply to Paul G. Allen
Quoted 28 lines · Michael Dunsky
Quoted 8 lines · Paul G. Allen

Sound worked fine through kernel 2.4.9. Since I upgraded to 2.4.14, and now to 2.4.17 (I skipped 2.4.10 - 2.4.13) I have several games that are FUBAR, all sound related: Quake III Arena and Quake II both core dump initializing sound; Soldier of Fortune, Railroad Tycoon II, Sid Myers Alpha Centaury all make strange noises with no intelligable game sound. Tribes 2, Unreal Tournament, and Descent 3 all work fine. GNOME and Enlightenment sound work fine as well, as does xmms.

Quoted 9 lines

I have a SB Live! OEM and have tried compiling with and without the MIDI module. The main thing is I am trying to do some game development and it's impossible when sound is FUBAR. Any ideas?

I hate to go back to an earlier kernel as IDE did not work (for me) in the previous kernels.

PGA

Hello!

I ran into a similar problem:
Upgraded from 2.4.5 to 2.4.14 and added some RAM (total 1GB now). When not using
HIHGMEM_4GB, ~180MB of the RAM was missing. With HIGHMEM_4GB enabled, sound
was totally trashed (I also had the segfaulting Quake3Arena).

Quoted 4 lines

The SBLive uses the "emu10k1"-driver - and the driver that came with 2.4.14 was broken if used with "HIGHMEM" enabled. W/o this, the sound had no problems. Rui Sousa made it working with HIGMEM enabled. (But sometimes, especially with very little free RAM left the sound is still broken )

That may be the problem, I have "HIGHMEM" enabled. I too have a MoBo that can handle lots of memory (up to 4GB) and I plan to use it.

Quoted 6 lines

Have you tried the latest snapshot from opensource.creative.com ? I've taken a look into the kernel-patches (I'm still at 2.4.14 - will upgrade to 2.4.17 when SGI's XFS is ready for thet kernel), and there were no version-changes in the driver.

Quoted 9 lines

How to do it (very short):
Unzip and untar, cd into "emu10k1_<date>" and do "make && make install" (maybe save the old from "/lib/modules/<kernel-version>/kernel/drivers/sound" and "sound/emu10k1" before...) Remove your loaded "emu10k1" and "ac97_codec" modules (don't forget this), load the new and test it.

There are some more nice features within Creatives "official" drivers (such as bass/treble control)...

I haven't tried the Creative stuff, but I did D/L OSS and it works fine. In fact, the sound in all my games is better than it was. Only one problem - if I continue to use the OS driver/module, I have to pay $35 for it (no big deal really, but it is money :)

Maybe I'll give the Creative stuff a try.

PGA

Signature · 4 lines
Paul G. Allen
Owner, Sr. Engineer, Security Specialist
Random Logic/Dream Park
www.randomlogic.com