Skip to contentSkip to conversation

flash file system for production use

DISCUSSION Michael Palme 3 participants 5 messages Aug 27, 2002 Memory technology devices (MTD)

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

hello...

i've got a strongarm system with 32mb intel strata flash. i need a mechanism for storing configuration files etc in the flashes. for this purpose 20mb of the flashes are free. the performance/ stability thing is very important for me. i cant wait 10 secs fot mounting/ checking etc. i' ve tried jffs2 from CVS and it seems to be "fast" on a nearly empty flash partition, but i have no suggestion about what happens in hard production use, when the flash will be written over and over again and the wear leveling takes place. the device is never shutdown'ed in a clean way -- always hard power off...

because i have 20megs free and only small information to store i think there is no need for a complex wear leveling mechanism but im not an expert.

what the best solution fot my problems???

please give some hints....

thanks in advance ... Michael Palme

Signature · 11 lines
-------------------------------
Dipl.-Ing. (FH)
Michael Palme
software engineer
Goepel electronic GmbH

mailto: [email protected]
phone:  +493641689682
fax:    +493641689644
inet:   http://www.goepel.com
-------------------------------
#1 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · [email protected] said:

i need a mechanism for storing configuration files etc in the
flashes. for this purpose 20mb of the flashes are free. the performance/ stability thing is very important for me. i cant wait 10 secs fot mounting/ checking etc. i' ve tried jffs2 from CVS and it seems to be "fast" on a nearly empty flash partition, but i have no suggestion about what happens in hard production use, when the flash will be written over and over again and the wear leveling takes place. the device is never shutdown'ed in a clean way -- always hard power off...

JFFS2 from CVS should be fine. It hasn't had as much hard testing as the stable branch, but I have no particular reason to expect it to be broken on NOR flash. I wouldn't ship it to a customer before doing some serious retesting, but you can do that yourself and report anything you find -- I don't expect anything to break.

There are other things we can do to improve performance and mount time even more than we've already done in CVS. They're listed in the TODO file, and if you're likely to actually implement them I'm happy to give more explicit pointers -- or I can set our salesdroids on you if that would be useful :)

--
dwmw2

#2 lore raw

okay... thanks for the answer.
i will do some serious testing myself. what would be a real life scenario ??? is a random loop with creating, writing and deleting files mixed with mounting and unmounting and some random powerfaults???

i think the salesdroids- thing will not work: they only thing they want is to get a product to the market as fast as they can...

Quoted 31 lines · David Woodhouse
Quoted 11 lines · [email protected] said:

i need a mechanism for storing configuration files etc in the flashes. for this purpose 20mb of the flashes are free. the performance/ stability thing is very important for me. i cant wait 10 secs fot mounting/ checking etc. i' ve tried jffs2 from CVS and it seems to be "fast" on a nearly empty flash partition, but i have no suggestion about what happens in hard production use, when the flash will be written over and over again and the wear leveling takes place. the device is never shutdown'ed in a clean way -- always hard power off...

JFFS2 from CVS should be fine. It hasn't had as much hard testing as the stable branch, but I have no particular reason to expect it to be broken on NOR flash. I wouldn't ship it to a customer before doing some serious retesting, but you can do that yourself and report anything you find -- I don't expect anything to break.

There are other things we can do to improve performance and mount time even more than we've already done in CVS. They're listed in the TODO file, and if you're likely to actually implement them I'm happy to give more explicit pointers -- or I can set our salesdroids on you if that would be useful :)

--
dwmw2

#3 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] said:

okay... thanks for the answer. i will do some serious testing myself. what would be a real life scenario ??? is a random loop with creating, writing and deleting files mixed with mounting and unmounting and some random powerfaults???

Yeah -- coupled with sanity checking every existing file on the file system at every remount, etc. And make them _real_ powerfaults, with an X10 controller or something. You get really weird behaviour out of flash chips that way -- which we should deal with just fine.

If you're going to report any faults, it's best to do the testing with CONFIG_JFFS2_FS_DEBUG=1 and _logging_ the kernel messages over a serial port. But that of course slows down the test run. YMMV. A 230400 baud serial console helps :)

--
dwmw2

#4 lore raw
In reply to Michael Palme
Quoted 12 lines · Michael Palme

hello...

i've got a strongarm system with 32mb intel strata flash. i need a mechanism for storing configuration files etc in the flashes. for this purpose 20mb of the flashes are free. the performance/ stability thing is very important for me. i cant wait 10 secs fot mounting/ checking etc. i' ve tried jffs2 from CVS and it seems to be "fast" on a nearly empty flash partition, but i have no suggestion about what happens in hard production use, when the flash will be written over and over again and the wear leveling takes place. the device is never shutdown'ed in a clean way -- always hard power off...

Quoted 5 lines

because i have 20megs free and only small information to store i think there is no need for a complex wear leveling mechanism but im not an expert.

what the best solution fot my problems???

You have to decide, whats more important stability or preformance. If you write small but important information and your system has the possibility of power loss, then you have to use a stable, journalling flash file system like JFFS2 and accept some performance penalty. The actual JFFS2 code in CVS is faster than the stable branch. It needs some serious testing. And there is place for further improvents. You're heartly intvited to join us and implement some of the things, which are listed in the TODO file.

Signature · 5 lines
Thomas 
____________________________________________________
linutronix - competence in embedded & realtime linux
http://www.linutronix.de
mail: [email protected]