Skip to contentSkip to conversation

IDE DVD reading & error handling

DISCUSSION Mathias Kretschmer 2 participants 3 messages Mar 4, 2003

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello,

Is there a way to optimize the IDE layer to handle DVD read errors more gracefully ?

Most used DVDs (borrowed from a local library, etc.) seem to have some defects. Those cause the IDE layer to get stuck for quite a while, interrupting the movie playback. It might be better to just return an error for that sector and let the player software continue.

I wonder if it would be possible to tune the IDE layer by i.e. reducing the number of retries and disabling the controller reset, etc.

I haven't fiddle with the below numbers, yet. Just wondering if that
could improve the situation, or if there are any other tricks that one could play here ?

/*
* Probably not wise to fiddle with these
*/

#define ERROR_MAX       8       /* Max read/write errors per sector */
#define ERROR_RESET     3       /* Reset controller every 4th retry */
#define ERROR_RECAL     1       /* Recalibrate every 2nd retry */

Cheers,

Mathias

PS: Also which DVD ROM do people recommended in general ?
Which one seems to have a decent error correction scheme not just a high read speed?

#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Mathias Kretschmer

Is there a way to optimize the IDE layer to handle DVD read errors more gracefully ?

I think its perfectly doable to set the maximum retries per device. Have a look at the current ide_error() and the error: handler in the relevant ide drivers (notably ide-cd).

Quoted 2 lines

I wonder if it would be possible to tune the IDE layer by i.e. reducing the number of retries and disabling the controller reset, etc.

A lot of the time you have to go through the controller reset. However cutting the retries down and having good readahead management on the I/O thread ought to still cope with that.

As to drives I'm using a mix of drives. Old 1x and 2x speed DVD drives are very cheap so its a good way to get multiple regions cheaply, and saves breaking the DMCA in the US 8)

#2 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines

I think its perfectly doable to set the maximum retries per device. Have a look at the current ide_error() and the error: handler in the relevant ide drivers (notably ide-cd).

Quoted 2 lines

I wonder if it would be possible to tune the IDE layer by i.e. reducing the number of retries and disabling the controller reset, etc.

A lot of the time you have to go through the controller reset. However cutting the retries down and having good readahead management on the I/O thread ought to still cope with that.

that's what I'm hoping for :)

Would it also be possible/make sense to never switch from DMA to PIO mode since those DVD read errors are most likely not a DMA problem ?