2.4: high system load with SG_IO on IDE-SCSI: PIO?
Quoted 9 lines · Matthias Andree
I have seen readcd ("sg driver 3.2.0") use 96% system time for a readcd -c2scan on IDE-SCSI (ATAPI CD-ROM, Plextor PX-4824TA 1.04, UDMA/33), Linux 2.4.19+SuSE patches (k_athlon-2.4.19-167).
...
ioctl(3, 0x2285, 0xbfffec20)= 0
...
Quoted 8 lines
The same application on a real SCSI-device with SCSI host adaptor (aic7xxx FWIW) is way below 5% system CPU time.
Might
SG_IOuse PIO on ATAPI CD-ROMs? If so, are there patches to enable DMA? Is this at all possible withSG_IO?I find 96% system load is way too high for modern hardware. (Duron/700 that is, VIA 82C686a).
SG_IO is an ioctl in the sg driver that issues scsi commands and waits for a response. The route from sg is through the scsi mid level and via ide-scsi to the ide subsystem. Nothing in the SG_IO ioctl interface addresses ATA DMA and PIO settings. They can be changed via the hdparm ** command.
The experience from the early 2.4 series was that the ide subsystem was too aggressive in its DMA settings for CD/DVD burners. [My experience with scsi devices is that disks have much better target implementations (i.e. more robust) than CD/DVD devices and scanners.] Later versions of the 2.4 series are a lot more conservative in their speed treatment of ATAPI devices. The robustness comes at the expense of system load.
** Even though a CD writer appears as /dev/scd0 with ide-scsi appropriately configured, the hdparm command can still be used on /dev/hdd (for example, if the writer is the slave on the second IDE bus).
Doug Gilbert
Quoted 5 lines · Douglas Gilbert
The experience from the early 2.4 series was that the ide subsystem was too aggressive in its DMA settings for CD/DVD burners. [My experience with scsi devices is that disks have much better target implementations (i.e. more robust) than CD/DVD devices and scanners.] Later versions of the 2.4 series
ATAPI scanners? Cool stuff. Seriously, there is cheap ATAPI junk and there is serious stuff.
Quoted 2 lines
are a lot more conservative in their speed treatment of ATAPI devices. The robustness comes at the expense of system load.
Well, some amount of configurability would be nice for the ones of us who have working ATAPI hardware. Even if it's a boot-time parameter like "hdc=atapidma" or something (that's what FreeBSD does, with the boot-time variable hw.ata.atapi_dma, it defaults to 0 but drop hw.ata.atapi_dma="1" into /boot/loader.conf.local and have the machine talk DMA to ATAPI stuff). Am I missing such an option?
I am currently facing the choice "switch to some other OS that talks DMA to my CD-writer" or "buy an ATAPI-SCSI-converter" (which is above 100 EUR). I'd like to have a third option to choose, tell the kernel "forget your sorrows and talk DMA." -- it could use a (user-space) whitelist,
say "Plextor CD-R 4824TA 1.04 is fine".
Quoted 4 lines
** Even though a CD writer appears as
/dev/scd0with ide-scsi appropriately configured, the hdparm command can still be used on/dev/hdd(for example, if the writer is the slave on the second IDE bus).
/sbin/hdparm -X66 -d1 -u1 happens at boot time (for hdc) -- still I'm facing unreasonably high system load when writing a CD.
Signature · 1 line
Matthias Andree