[2.6.6] Synaptics driver is 'jumpy'
Quoted 3 lines
Hello List,
Since installing 2.6.6 on my trusty laptop, I can't use the built-in
synaptics
Quoted 4 lines
touchpad anymore. The tracking is totally broken:
When you touch-drag on the touchpad, the mouse cursor will jump to where you stopped your action approx. 1/1.5 seconds _after_ your move. This makes
using
Quoted 11 lines
the touchpad virtually impossible.
This problem is not present under 2.6.5, which I'm running right now. Same .config.
Nothing seems to show up in the logs that could reflect any problem.
Any pointers?
Jan
Under normal load this shouldn't happen. It could only have to do with interrupts from PS/2 port.
However, this shows the actual problem with using Synaptics' absolute mode. I vote against having this as the default setting.
In the absolute mode, the CPU must process the absolute movements of the finger in order to translate them to mouse movements. That means that, under some system load, the mouse will not respond smoothly any more. I wouldn't like to have increased priority or so just for the mouse.
In the relative mode, the touchpad processor calculates the movements and queues them as mouse events to the PS/2. This buffering provides smooth movement even under heavy CPU usage. The downside is that in relative mode, the touchpad has no adjustments (only default ones) and no extra features (Z-axis, scroll zones). It may even not have the middle button (which I'm missing most)
Perhaps we should ask Synaptics for a better relative mode. AFAIK the PIC processor inside the touchpad is not upgradeable, but future models could offer better code..
Try running the touchpad in relative mode, with 'options psmouse proto=exps' at /etc/modprobe.conf, which disables the Synaptics (i.e. absolute mode).
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Quoted 2 lines · P. Christeas
Under normal load this shouldn't happen. It could only have to do with interrupts from PS/2 port.
Unfortunately, it happens all the time, even if the CPU load == 0.00. I don't have any other PS/2 devices (since I don't have a PS/2 port ;p) but I do use a USB mouse - but this is totally unrelated to this problem.
Quoted 3 lines
Try running the touchpad in relative mode, with 'options psmouse proto=exps' at
/etc/modprobe.conf, which disables the Synaptics (i.e. absolute mode).
Well... This causes X to bomb out with not finding any Synaptics device - which If i understand the driver correctly is quite correct at this point.
The fact is, it worked _perfectly_ under 2.6.5 with the standard mode. No problems whatsoever. Something must have changed (but I'm too unfamiliar with kernel code) that causes some sort of a delay in the processing of the input queue of the touchpad.
I've upgraded the X driver, but that changes nothing.
Jan
- --
"For the man who has everything... Penicillin."
-- F. Borquin
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFAp2yJUQQOfidJUwQRAvhEAJ9AlsLKIyPb1lP+6lql6E8YhEieOgCcDSQZ giKmwZyuYUkkR3YiAfGfYso=
=CBBE
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Hello,
Quoted 1 line
The fact is, it worked _perfectly_ under 2.6.5 with the standard mode. No problems whatsoever. Something must have changed (but I'm too unfamiliar with kernel code) that causes some sort of a delay in the processing of the input queue of the touchpad.
same problem here with 2.6.6 (recent gentoo system). I am running 2.6.6-rc3 and 2.6.5 without the problems.
Alexander
Quoted 4 lines
I've upgraded the X driver, but that changes nothing.
Jan
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
I just wanted to add that I also have a synaptics mouse, running 2.6.6 and yesterday i was compiling 2 copies of xfree86, glibc and gcc at the same time getting loads into the 5.x range per uptime and havent experienced any problems; well other than my occasional problem of putting an extra finger on the mouse pad and then wondering whats wrong.
- --
It is only the great men who are truly obscene. If they had not dared to be obscene, they could never have dared to be great.
-- Havelock Ellis
Quoted 39 lines · P. Christeas
Quoted 3 lines
Hello List,
Since installing 2.6.6 on my trusty laptop, I can't use the built-in
synaptics
Quoted 4 lines
touchpad anymore. The tracking is totally broken:
When you touch-drag on the touchpad, the mouse cursor will jump to where you stopped your action approx. 1/1.5 seconds _after_ your move. This makes
using
Quoted 11 lines
the touchpad virtually impossible.
This problem is not present under 2.6.5, which I'm running right now. Same .config.
Nothing seems to show up in the logs that could reflect any problem.
Any pointers?
Jan
Under normal load this shouldn't happen. It could only have to do with interrupts from PS/2 port.
However, this shows the actual problem with using Synaptics' absolute mode. I vote against having this as the default setting.
In the absolute mode, the CPU must process the absolute movements of the finger in order to translate them to mouse movements. That means that, under some system load, the mouse will not respond smoothly any more. I wouldn't like to have increased priority or so just for the mouse.
In the relative mode, the touchpad processor calculates the movements and queues them as mouse events to the PS/2. This buffering provides smooth movement even under heavy CPU usage. The downside is that in relative mode, the touchpad has no adjustments (only default ones) and no extra features (Z-axis, scroll zones). It may even not have the middle button (which I'm missing most)
Perhaps we should ask Synaptics for a better relative mode. AFAIK the PIC processor inside the touchpad is not upgradeable, but future models could offer better code..
Quoted 9 lines
Try running the touchpad in relative mode, with 'options psmouse proto=exps' at
/etc/modprobe.conf, which disables the Synaptics (i.e. absolute mode).-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.2 (OpenBSD)
iD8DBQFAqBCnsKAeTAhLiCERAl8UAJ0d3cyQg+Qh16N2m2DyoYUcRzBVpACfc1hO DF/SQKwG/VySAactWl3akJA=
=V5Nx
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----