Skip to contentSkip to conversation

HARDWARE: Open-Source-Friendly Graphics Cards -- Viable?

DISCUSSION Albert Cahalan 2 participants 2 messages Oct 21, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Timothy Miller

(2) How much would you be willing to pay for it?

(3) How do you feel about the choice of neglecting 3D performance as a priority? How important is 3D performance? In what cases is it not?

(4) How much extra would you be willing to pay for excellent 3D performance?

(5) What's most important to you, performance, price, or stability?

Stability with a kernel of my choice on possibly non-x86 hardware matters most. Digital DVI, fanless operation, and DVD scaling are next. After that, 3D.

I'm not so sure you have to give up 3D. You can put at least 4 AltiVec-capable "G4" CPUs on a PCI board without having horrible power and temperature issues. (Perhaps an AGP board can safely support even more.) Each will do 4 32-bit floating-point fused-multiply-add operations per cycle. That's got to be good for something. I think the latest chips have built-in memory interfaces. They have RapidIO interfaces. So you make your FPGA speak RapidIO protocol (easy) and have each CPU render every fourth frame.

One could even put the X server on the card.

Ultimately, this is a huge risk, with potentially great reward. One must take some risks to succeed, and this one is a whopper.

#1 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · Albert Cahalan
Quoted 9 lines · Timothy Miller

(2) How much would you be willing to pay for it?

(3) How do you feel about the choice of neglecting 3D performance as a priority? How important is 3D performance? In what cases is it not?

(4) How much extra would you be willing to pay for excellent 3D performance?

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

(5) What's most important to you, performance, price, or stability?

Stability with a kernel of my choice on possibly non-x86 hardware matters most. Digital DVI, fanless operation, and DVD scaling are next. After that, 3D.

My aside from the DVD bit, my original 2D concept would make all of that possible.

So, say you decide that you want to use this card for some obscure variant of BSD or an Amiga or something, and you're having some trouble with the porting of the available drivers, I'd be happy to assist in that process.

Quoted 11 lines

I'm not so sure you have to give up 3D. You can put at least 4 AltiVec-capable "G4" CPUs on a PCI board without having horrible power and temperature issues. (Perhaps an AGP board can safely support even more.) Each will do 4 32-bit floating-point fused-multiply-add operations per cycle. That's got to be good for something. I think the latest chips have built-in memory interfaces. They have RapidIO interfaces. So you make your FPGA speak RapidIO protocol (easy) and have each CPU render every fourth frame.

A CPU and a GPU don't do the same things. A GPU naturally parallelizes things, both in time (pipelining of rendering functions) and space (multiple pipelines). A CPU, even a superscalar one, does things in essentially a sequential fashion. Thus, a 200Mhz GPU will absolutely cream your 1Ghz G4 in graphics performance, even WITH clever AltiVec hacks. Dedicated hardware is ALWAYS going to be faster than doing it in
software.

That being said, I'm not rejecting your G4 idea out-right. While you can't expect stellar performance out of it, you CAN program it to do absolutely every kind of 3D rendering you want.

I'm going to propose this as a possible solution to the problem.

Quoted 1 line

One could even put the X server on the card.

'Tis true.

Quoted 8 lines

Ultimately, this is a huge risk, with potentially great reward. One must take some risks to succeed, and this one is a whopper.