Bad disks or bug ?
Hello,
i have a little doubt on the following....
/> Sep 10 12:50:30 abivrs0 kernel: hdb: dma_intr: status=0x51 { DriveReady / /> SeekComplete Error } /
/> Sep 10 12:50:30 abivrs0 kernel: hdb: dma_intr: error=0x40 / ////
...Of course the explanation of such an error is that drive has bad sectors and i'd better change it BUT:
I have many production servers running 2.4.27, everything seems OK while they're new.
After about an year of production many of them (5 of them at present) begin to show the problem BUT:
1) All of them show the problem on hdb (ALL OF THEM)
2) Never had problems on hda on ANY server, disks are the same, same size, same partitioning
3) Typically hdb is used as a disk mirror
4) Many times a mkfs.ext3 -c -c solves the problem bringing bad sectors to a new life !
How do you explain that ? Overload on hdb due to mirroring and surface degradation ?
OR a kind of vodoo on my hdbs ?
NOTE: Over the internet, when i searched for such errors on disks (not ramdisks or loop devs) i ALWAYS found problems on hdb !!!
Could it be depending on master-slave configuration ? Kernel bug ? Other ?
What do you say ?
thanks for your time,
Gianluca Alberici
Quoted 3 lines · Ing. Gianluca Alberici
How do you explain that ? Overload on hdb due to mirroring and surface degradation ?
OR a kind of vodoo on my hdbs ?
Is it possible that hdb is closer to a high heat source
or is not being cooled as hda if all these machines are the same case design?
Signature · 19 lines
Mark Nipper e-contacts: 4475 Carter Creek Parkway [email protected] Apartment 724 http://nipsy.bitgnome.net/ Bryan, Texas, 77802-4481 AIM/Yahoo: texasnipsy ICQ: 66971617 (979)575-3193 MSN: [email protected] -----BEGIN GEEK CODE BLOCK----- Version: 3.1 GG/IT d- s++:+ a- C++$ UBL++++$ P--->+++ L+++$ !E--- W++(--) N+ o K++ w(---) O++ M V(--) PS+++(+) PE(--) Y+ PGP t+ 5 X R tv b+++@ DI+(++) D+ G e h r++ y+(**) ------END GEEK CODE BLOCK------ ---begin random quote of the moment--- "That we are not much sicker and much madder than we are is due exclusively to that most blessed and blessing of all natural graces, sleep." -- Aldous Huxley ----end random quote of the moment----
Hello,
Very Interesting news from Massimo...
About the heat source, Mark, i thought about that, too, and hdb is always the bottom (CS Enabled) device of rackmounts (so the colder one) , in front of the usual ball bearing fans !!!!
I am beginning to believe all this deserves a more deep investigation...
Waiting for comments,
Gianluca
Quoted 15 lines · Mark Nipper
Quoted 5 lines · Ing. Gianluca Alberici
How do you explain that ? Overload on hdb due to mirroring and surface degradation ?
OR a kind of vodoo on my hdbs ?Is it possible that hdb is closer to a high heat source
or is not being cooled as hda if all these machines are the same case design?
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Prarit,
I run 2.4.27 on all my machines.
Never had problems but this (if we want to say its not a disk problem)
I have seen on mailing lists many people having this very problem, always on hdb, with a lot of different kernel and machines.
I have basically two kind of cabinets:
- The 'Antec style' tower
- Racmount cases
Everything well cooled...i am sure bout that.
Always ASUS A7V, Athlon XP 2xxx+, NEVER OVERCLOCKED, of course...
Disks are mainly Maxtor, or IBM
Basically i was wondering whether to swap disks on a server just to try....
....These are the things that rave me mad !
Quoted 45 lines · Prarit Bhargava
Hi Gianluca,
How old is your kernel?
P.Quoted 38 lines · Ing. Gianluca Alberici
Hello,
Very Interesting news from Massimo...
About the heat source, Mark, i thought about that, too, and hdb is always the bottom (CS Enabled) device of rackmounts (so the colder one) , in front of the usual ball bearing fans !!!!
I am beginning to believe all this deserves a more deep investigation...
Waiting for comments,
Gianluca
Quoted 10 lines · Mark Nipper
Quoted 4 lines · Ing. Gianluca Alberici
How do you explain that ? Overload on hdb due to mirroring and surface degradation ?
OR a kind of vodoo on my hdbs ?Quoted 6 lines
Is it possible that hdb is closer to a high heat source
or is not being cooled as hda if all these machines are the same case design?-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
Quoted 15 lines · Ing. Gianluca Alberici
Prarit,
I run 2.4.27 on all my machines.
Never had problems but this (if we want to say its not a disk problem)
I have seen on mailing lists many people having this very problem, always on hdb, with a lot of different kernel and machines.
I have basically two kind of cabinets:
- The 'Antec style' tower
- Racmount casesEverything well cooled...i am sure bout that.
Quoted 7 lines
Always ASUS A7V, Athlon XP 2xxx+, NEVER OVERCLOCKED, of course...
Disks are mainly Maxtor, or IBM
Basically i was wondering whether to swap disks on a server just to try....
....These are the things that rave me mad !
You might see if you can swap positions in the case first, then I guess you would have nothing to try but actually flipping master with slave (and contents as well, good fun).
Just wondering, where is your swap? Your Journal? Do you have a small fast drive you could use for swap and external journal? I checked all the machines which have a similar configuration, and I don't see any pattern, although all the machines with really high i/o load are using SCSI.
Signature · 3 lines
-bill davidsen ([email protected]) "The secret to procrastination is to put things off until the last possible moment - but no longer" -me