freebox possible GPL violation
Hi,
I will try to present the facts and free claims about the freebox that run Linux GPL source code.
Please note that I am not a Laywer.
Also due to the obscurity of the freebox, some informations could be out of date or incorrect.
Finaly as free is a french provider, most of the link are in french.
==FACT==
1) The freebox is an adsl gateway with VoIP, TV over ADSL and a optional wifi bridge. The box is built and lended by an ADSL provider 'free'[0].
2) The freebox runs Linux 2.4. You could find some BitKeeper logs on internet [1], [2]. You could also find some interesting (but sometimes suspicious) informations on [3]. For example you could see the files that are in the firmware (and find other GPL softwares).
3) The boot sequence is described on [4]. Note that in case of firmware upgrade, the box should first synchronize with the dslam and do dhcp requests, then download the new firmware and finaly reboot.
4) The optional wifi support is provided by a pcmcia card (prism2/3 for 802.11b, broadcom for 802.11g). You can buy it on 'free' portal or on your own [5]. Note that in both case the card is yours and it is not lended by 'free'.
==FREE and PRO-FREE CLAIMS (some claims could be find on [6])==
A) The freebox is only lended, so the user can't ask for GPL source code.
-> They forgot that for wifi feature, you have buy a pcmcia card and that is card works wifi Linux driver. So according to GPL you could ask for wifi driver source code and all the Linux source code ??? Also some people that don't return the freebox in time had to paid 400 Euros and they became the owner of the freebox. Free send to a client a letter [7] saying that if the user don't return the freebox, free could bill it and then it becomes propriety of the user :
'Nous vous rappelons que conformément aux Conditions Générales de Vente , en cas de non-restitution du modem, Free se réserve le droit de procéder à la facturation de l'équipement terminal, au prix mentionné dans les CGV, qui deviendra alors la *propriété* de l'Usager.'
B) The freebox don't keep the Linux kernel in memory, it is downloaded at each boot.
-> If you remember 3), you could find strange that the box need to reboot if a new firmware is available. Also the boot sequence is quite complex to be made by an external (non-GPL) firmware : it need to control the led display, need to control the ADSL chips in order to synchronize, need to manage PPP in case of 'no-degroupe' users and finaly donwload in memory the fimware. So we could assume that at least a mininal system (Linux kernel + some utils) is keep in rom).
C) 'Free' is a network operator and needs to keep secret some informations in order to preserve security on its networks.
-> Everybody know how security obscurity via is safe. Also I agree they don't want to give their script or their configuration, but I fail to see what could be a threat in the Linux kernel.
PS : sorry for my bad english.
[0] http://free.fr
[1] http://openlogging.org:8080/sakura.(none)/max-20040524220224-60268-baea416b9b2da5c2/src?nav=index.html
[2] http://openlogging.org:8080/chewbacca.proxad.net/rani-20040112173203-20972-c609c93690b2941a/src?nav=index.html
[3] http://www.f-b-x.net/
[4] http://forums.grenouille.com/index.php?showtopic=14659
[5] http://faq.free.fr/?q=797
[6] http://djeyl.net/free/nntp/index.php?group=all&author=Alexandre&headers=gpl
[7] http://linuxfr.org/comments/626391.html#626391
Quoted 5 lines · Pierre Michon
==FREE and PRO-FREE CLAIMS (some claims could be find on [6])==
A) The freebox is only lended, so the user can't ask for GPL source code.
If you lend someone linux, you're _distributing_ linux. The GPL is about _distribution_ I believe, it doesn't have to be a _sale_.
You can't _lend_ someone windows (as a way of doing business) without satisfying ms licencing terms either.
Quoted 4 lines
-> They forgot that for wifi feature, you have buy a pcmcia card and
that is card works wifi Linux driver. So according to GPL you could ask for wifi driver source code and all the Linux source code ???
Well, the wifi driver may or may not be under the GPL licence. Check that first. The linux kernel itself is GPL of course.
Quoted 6 lines
Also some people that don't return the freebox in time had to paid 400 Euros and they became the owner of the freebox. Free send to a client a letter [7] saying that if the user don't return the freebox, free could bill it and then it becomes propriety of the user : 'Nous vous rappelons que conformément aux Conditions Générales de Vente , en cas de non-restitution du modem, Free se réserve le droit de procéder à la facturation de l'équipement terminal, au prix mentionné dans les CGV, qui deviendra alors la *propriété* de l'Usager.'
B) The freebox don't keep the Linux kernel in memory, it is downloaded at each boot.
Check where it is downloaded from, that is where linux is being distributed from. Likely the same company though.
Quoted 3 lines
C) 'Free' is a network operator and needs to keep secret some informations in order to preserve security on its networks.
They don't need to keep the kernel secret for security. Of course they can still keep their scripts secret, their (non-GPL) userland utilities secret, their proprietary drivers secret and the hw specs secret. Good or bad, it is up to them. But it seems to me they have to offer the kernel source, at least.
Helge Hafting
Quoted 2 lines · Pierre Michon
1) The freebox is an adsl gateway with VoIP, TV over ADSL and a optional wifi bridge. The box is built and lended by an ADSL provider 'free'[0].
I suggest you say :
"The box is built by an ADSL provider 'free'[0]. The box is located at the user end of the ADSL line (i.e. in the appartement of an individual or in the offices of a company). "
Later on you could expand on how the box gets there, how
it is installed (lended or not) and the claim of Free that it is not lended in any ways.
Quoted 3 lines
==FREE and PRO-FREE CLAIMS (some claims could be find on [6])==
A) The freebox is only lended, so the user can't ask for GPL source code.
I insist that free does not even claim to lend the Freebox. They
claim that the freebox is a terminal equipement of their local network.
Quoted 11 lines
-> They forgot that for wifi feature, you have buy a pcmcia card and that is card works wifi Linux driver. So according to GPL you could ask for wifi driver source code and all the Linux source code ??? Also some people that don't return the freebox in time had to paid 400 Euros and they became the owner of the freebox. Free send to a client a letter [7] saying that if the user don't return the freebox, free could bill it and then it becomes propriety of the user :
'Nous vous rappelons que conformément aux Conditions Générales de Vente , en cas de non-restitution du modem, Free se réserve le droit de procéder à la facturation de l'équipement terminal, au prix mentionné dans les CGV, qui deviendra alors la *propriété* de l'Usager.'
I believe that a customer could ask for the corresponding sources
to Free if she/he got a copy of the binary out of the freebox. Does anyone have such a binary ?
Quoted 2 lines
the fimware. So we could assume that at least a mininal system (Linux kernel + some utils) is keep in rom).
Could someone provide a hard proof of this ?
Quoted 6 lines
C) 'Free' is a network operator and needs to keep secret some informations in order to preserve security on its networks.
-> Everybody know how security obscurity via is safe. Also I agree they don't want to give their script or their configuration, but I fail to see what could be a threat in the Linux kernel.
I'd say this is more a debatable justification than a claim.
Cheers,
Signature · 2 lines
Loic Dachary, 12 bd Magenta, 75010 Paris. Tel: 33 8 71 18 43 38 http://www.fsffrance.org/ http://www.dachary.org/loic/gpg.txt
Hi,
2005/10/15, Loic Dachary <[email protected]>:
Quoted 3 lines
I believe that a customer could ask for the corresponding sources
to Free if she/he got a copy of the binary out of the freebox. Does anyone have such a binary ?
But those ISP does everything in order the user couldn't touch the firmware because they are frightened that the user could modify it and does things that wasn't planed (record live tv stream for example).
For that they :
- disable all debug functions on customers boxes (serial port, jtag, ...).
- download the firmware via encrypted protocol (https, ...)
- check the integrity of the bootloader, firmware server, firmware.
- encrypted all rescue firmware that could be present on user computer.
So one way of recovering the firmware could be to unsold the flash chip and read it on another board.
An other way will be to try to renable debug functions by soldering component on the board.
But it will be very expensive and need special competences (and without the datasheet of the board could be very hard...).
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
the fimware. So we could assume that at least a mininal system (Linux kernel + some utils) is keep in rom).
Could someone provide a hard proof of this ?
No without reading the flash chip.
What I have seen for the boards like freebox in my company :
- the bootloader try to load the firmware in flash
- if it fails, it try to read a rescue firmware. That rescue firmware is minimal and will only allow to enable ADSL line and download a new firmware in the flash and reboot.
- if it fails, the bootloader will try to load a encrypted firmware from local Ethernet LAN (bootp, ...) and reboot.
But there no way to know what exactly does the freebox (may be try to find the flash chip and its size)...
Pierre
PS : Does we need the binary image in order to ask for the source code ? In this case, with Embedded devices that hide the firmware it will be very difficult to make GPL apply...
Quoted 3 lines · Pierre Michon
PS : Does we need the binary image in order to ask for the source code ? In this case, with Embedded devices that hide the firmware it will be very difficult to make GPL apply...
It is not mandatory, it's just easier in this specific case.
If we knew for sure what the firmware contains, the box would be enough. But if someone is able to figure out exactly what the firmware contains she/he will also be able to extract a tarball in which case the box itself becomes useless to ask for the corresponding sources ;-)
Cheers,
Signature · 2 lines
Loic Dachary, 12 bd Magenta, 75010 Paris. Tel: 33 8 71 18 43 38 http://www.fsffrance.org/ http://www.dachary.org/loic/gpg.txt