Skip to contentSkip to conversation

RSE and incomplete register frame

DISCUSSION Christian Hildner 2 participants 3 messages Aug 2, 2006 – Aug 3, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi there,

for an IA64 related question I dropped a query to [email protected] . However there was not really any helpful response. So please let me make use of the bigger audience on this list. Your comments are all welcome. Thanks.

Here the original text:
Hi,

while developing an instruction set simulator I found the chapter about incomplete register frame (ASDM vol. 2) to be inaccurate. It says that the incomplete frame becomes complete when RSE.ndirty_words becomes non-negative by executing mandatory RSE loads. However, mandatory RSE loads are not touching BSPSTORE or the dirty partition. RSE loads are extending the clean partition. Furthermore if you consider RSE.BOF to end up inside the clean partition after a br.ret or rfi, then BSPSTORE is located above BSP. However, the new current frame should be considered complete since there are no mandatory RSE loads needed. Given this, BSPSTORE should be replaced by RSE.Bspload, which is the true criterion for an incomplete register frame.

The practice when dealing with br.ret or rfi seems to be that BSPSTORE is forced to BSP when RSE.BOF is updated into the clean partition. However, this behavior is lacking documentation in one of the ASDM.

Christian

____________
Virus checked by G DATA AntiVirusKit

#1 lore raw

Hi Christian,

It took me a while to get my head around this. I'm not convinced that the documentation is incorrect, although they are maybe looking at it from a slightly different perspective.

Keep in mind Figure 6-3... the current partition is above the dirty partition is above the clean partition. RSE operation should preserve this relationship (as I see it).

Also, note that the registers in the current partition, even though not technically part of the dirty partition, are necessarily dirty... they may be targeted at any time by writebacks.

Quoted 1 line

while developing an instruction set simulator

I'd be interested in learning more about this simulator :)

Quoted 4 lines

incomplete register frame (ASDM vol. 2) to be inaccurate. It says that the incomplete frame becomes complete when RSE.ndirty_words becomes non-negative by executing mandatory RSE loads. However, mandatory RSE loads are not touching BSPSTORE or the dirty partition.

Indirectly they are, because presumably the dirty partition (and BSPSTORE) must remain squeezed between the invalid partition and the current partition (albeit being zero-size, or negative-size depending on how you look at it - the invalid partition extends into the current partition!).

Quoted 1 line

RSE loads are extending the clean partition.

IMHO there is no clean partition. The RSE loads are targeting the current frame so they are immediately dirty+current.

Quoted 3 lines

Furthermore if you consider RSE.BOF to
end up inside the clean partition after a br.ret or rfi, then BSPSTORE is located above BSP.

RSE.BOF by definition ends up in the current partition (which is immediately dirty), which is above the other dirty registers (if any) in the dirty partition, which is above the clean partition. Hence in the normal case BSPSTORE is less than or equal to BSP.

Hope this helps, feel free to argue with me if you disagree.

Matt

#2 lore raw
In reply to Christian Hildner
Quoted 9 lines · Matthew Chapman

Hi Christian,

It took me a while to get my head around this.

Quoted 3 lines

while developing an instruction set simulator

I'd be interested in learning more about this simulator :)

It will become a functional IA64 simulator with some more features compared to HP Ski. And in opposite to HP Ski it also has the clean partition architected.

Quoted 22 lines
Quoted 6 lines

incomplete register frame (ASDM vol. 2) to be inaccurate. It says that the incomplete frame becomes complete when RSE.ndirty_words becomes non-negative by executing mandatory RSE loads. However, mandatory RSE loads are not touching BSPSTORE or the dirty partition.

Indirectly they are, because presumably the dirty partition (and BSPSTORE) must remain squeezed between the invalid partition and the current partition (albeit being zero-size, or negative-size depending on how you look at it - the invalid partition extends into the current partition!).

Quoted 3 lines

RSE loads are extending the clean partition.

IMHO there is no clean partition. The RSE loads are targeting the current frame so they are immediately dirty+current.

Quoted 5 lines

Furthermore if you consider RSE.BOF to
end up inside the clean partition after a br.ret or rfi, then BSPSTORE is located above BSP.

Quoted 5 lines

RSE.BOF by definition ends up in the current partition (which is immediately dirty), which is above the other dirty registers (if any) in the dirty partition, which is above the clean partition. Hence in the normal case BSPSTORE is less than or equal to BSP.

It looks to me like the clean partition only exists in the high level IA64 architecture design. The clean partition is probably lacking in the Intel reference models as well as in current hardware designs. So the documentation does not care a lot about the clean partition and leaves it up to the phantasy of the reader what happens to it in the case of a br.ret or rfi.

Quoted 2 lines

Hope this helps, feel free to argue with me if you disagree.

Your idea of treating all former clean regs as current dirty regs and so logically flushing the clean parition is exactly the way I solved the issue in our simulator.

Thanks

Christian

____________
Virus checked by G DATA AntiVirusKit