When is the kernel moving to GPLv3?
/"Red Hat has slammed the door shut <http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2059675,00.asp> on any possibility of entering into a patent protection deal similar to the one Microsoft recently announced with Novell, eWeek is reporting. While Microsoft has repeatedly said it wants to work with Red Hat and would like to structure a relationship where its customers can be assured of the same thing as Novell's customers <http://linux.slashdot.org/linux/06/11/02/1957252.shtml?tid=109> now are, Mark Webbink, Red Hat's deputy general counsel, says 'we do not believe there is a need for or basis for the type of relationship defined in the Microsoft-Novell announcement.' Interestingly enough, Microsoft also says that it has not ruled out going it alone and providing some sort of indemnification for its customers who also use Red Hat Linux."/
"Meanwhile, Eben Moglen, the FSF general counsel, promises that GPLv3 will explicitly outlaw <http://money.cnn.com/blogs/legalpad/2006/11/is-microsoft-novell-deal-dead-on.html> deals like this. (Of course everyone's on v2, so calling the Novell deal "DOA" would be premature.)"
So when is the kernel moving to GPLv3? I have seen some discussions about moving off v2, is there concensus about moving to v3 to remove
threats of patent claims against v2 code by M$ and others who may use Linux in hardware based projects.
Jeff
Re: When is the kernel moving to GPLv3? (probably feeding a troll :)
Quoted 21 lines · Jeffrey V. Merkey
/"Red Hat has slammed the door shut
<http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2059675,00.asp> on any possibility of entering into a patent protection deal similar to the one Microsoft recently announced with Novell, eWeek is reporting. While Microsoft has repeatedly said it wants to work with Red Hat and would like to structure a relationship where its customers can be assured of the same thing as Novell's customers
<http://linux.slashdot.org/linux/06/11/02/1957252.shtml?tid=109> now are, Mark Webbink, Red Hat's deputy general counsel, says 'we do not believe there is a need for or basis for the type of relationship defined in the Microsoft-Novell announcement.' Interestingly enough, Microsoft also says that it has not ruled out going it alone and providing some sort of indemnification for its customers who also use Red Hat Linux."/"Meanwhile, Eben Moglen, the FSF general counsel, promises that GPLv3 will explicitly outlaw
<http://money.cnn.com/blogs/legalpad/2006/11/is-microsoft-novell-deal-dead-on.html>
deals like this. (Of course everyone's on v2, so calling the Novell deal "DOA" would be premature.)"
Quoted 4 lines
So when is the kernel moving to GPLv3? I have seen some discussions
about moving off v2, is there concensus about moving to v3 to remove threats of patent claims against v2 code by M$ and others who may use Linux in hardware based projects.
The "consensus" seems to be: The kernel is currently GPLv2 (and nothing else) and changing that is almost an imposible task, and the majority of the major active contributers also don't seem interested in considering the GPLv3 in its current form. It really seems to be that simple.
Some people claim Novell's "Deal" isn't even permitted under the GPLv2, or that the "Deal" has no meaning or purpose at all.
--
Len Sorensen
Re: When is the kernel moving to GPLv3? (probably feeding a troll :)
Quoted 10 lines · Lennart Sorensen
The "consensus" seems to be: The kernel is currently GPLv2 (and nothing else) and changing that is almost an imposible task, and the majority of the major active contributers also don't seem interested in considering the GPLv3 in its current form. It really seems to be that simple.
Some people claim Novell's "Deal" isn't even permitted under the GPLv2, or that the "Deal" has no meaning or purpose at all.
There exists sufficient precedence and case law to assert this position as accurate. It would take a patent infringement case where GPL code was being distributed to establish it as a matter of law. I can guarantee Novell and M$ will avoid any such suit for that very reason.
It may all be moot and not really matter, other than for FUD factor by Novell/M$.
Jeff
Quoted 5 lines
--
Len Sorensen
[ot] (was When is the kernel moving to GPLv3?)
In reply to Jeffrey V. MerkeyOn 2006-11-16, Jeffrey V. Merkey wrote:
[]
Quoted 4 lines
So when is the kernel moving to GPLv3? I have seen some discussions
about moving off v2, is there concensus about moving to v3 to remove threats of patent claims against v2 code by M$ and others who may use Linux in hardware based projects.
Archives, man, search archives, and get off OT, please.
<http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=linux-kernel&w=2&r=1&s=GPLv3&q=b>
I guess, you know who is the Author, thus select messages.
____