DialUp and ADSL on same machine??
As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup
setup on the same machine.. It's either one or the other.. Not both.. This machine has a NIC and a hardware modem, with the modem running for years with little problems.. "Adding" PPPOE for ADSL completely upsets everything, necessitating an install of the ppp package and running pppsetup again from scratch, in order to have dial up again..
Am I wrong?? Any comments most welcome. TIA
Signature · 7 lines
Hal. GNU/Linux -- Slackware 10.1, kernel 2.4.29 . - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-newbie" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.linux-learn.org/faqs
Quoted 9 lines · Hal
As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup
setup on the same machine.. It's either one or the other.. Not both.. This machine has a NIC and a hardware modem, with the modem running for years with little problems.. "Adding" PPPOE for ADSL completely upsets everything, necessitating an install of the ppp package and running pppsetup again from scratch, in order to have dial up again..Am I wrong?? Any comments most welcome. TIA
I'm afraid, Hal, that I can respond in only the most general way. I don't know if this vague a response will help or not.
It should be possible to have on your system setups for both dial-up (ppp) and ADSL (pppoe). At least the underlying stuff (kernel modules, drivers, and userspace apps) should be able to handle it. But you'll probably need to do the setup by hand, because scripts like pppsetup tend to be written to handle only "vanilla" cases ... in this instance, a host with a single pppd interface requirement. For example, you'll probably want to make one of the interfaces ppp0, the other ppp1.
If you want both connections to run at the same time, there will be some added complications, mainly involving the host's routing table. But I'm guessing you want to maintain the dial-up as a backup arrangement, for when the DSL connection fails or, perhaps (if we're discussing a laptop, say) when you are away from the home connection. So you'll want a way to use apps like ifup and ifdown to switch interfaces.
Having said all that, I am, unfortunately, way too rusty on pppd to help with the details (I have the good fortune to have a static-address DSL line here, so I don't have to jump through any pppoe hoops, and I don't even own a modem). But if you provide the usual sorts of details, someone else here may be able to give you more exact advice.
Sorry I can't offer more help on this one.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-newbie" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.linux-learn.org/faqs
Quoted 9 lines · Hal
As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup
setup on the same machine.. It's either one or the other.. Not both.. This machine has a NIC and a hardware modem, with the modem running for years with little problems.. "Adding" PPPOE for ADSL completely upsets everything, necessitating an install of the ppp package and running pppsetup again from scratch, in order to have dial up again..Am I wrong?? Any comments most welcome. TIA
Hi, Hal:
You may be right or wrong, but I think you are ambiguous. :-|
I used 'pppsetup' for a few years, then RoaringPenguin (PPPOE) a few years when I upgraded to DSL, and now I have cable modem internet access.
Both 'pppsetup' and "PPPOE" are used to connect to an
Internet Service Provider (ISP). So...
"As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup setup on the same machine."
IMHO, is ambiguous and false. You can have both on the same machine. They may not run concurrently unless you edit some configurations. (iptables, 'route -n', /etc/resolv, ...) You could share (or not) your DSL connection by allowing users to dial into your telephone modem and establish a ppp connection through (or to) your host.
"completely upsets everything" IMHO, is ambiguous. Each may change (upset?) /etc/resolv, routing tables, DNS, IPTABLES, ... for the other program. ;-)
Both packages perform a similar function. Connect to an ISP.
'pppsetup':
"... PPPsetup is a bash shell script to help you in creating a chat script, for establising a PPP connection to a internet service provider. ..."
'rp-pppoe':
"... pppoe is a user-space redirector which permits the use of PPPoE (Point-to-Point Over Ethernet) with Linux. PPPoE is used by many DSL service providers. ..." i.e. connect to an internet service proveder.
Just for grins, when I had DSL service. I dialed my '56k' modem to an ISP just to see if the DSL telephone frequencies would interfere with the telephone modem frequencies. Whilst doing a download via DSL, I dialed
and got a 49.333 kbps connection over and over and over... Which was as
fast as I ever got before DSL. :-)
HTH, Chuck
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-newbie" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.linux-learn.org/faqs
Quoted 8 lines · Chuck Gelm
Quoted 7 lines · Hal
As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup
setup on the same machine.. It's either one or the other.. Not both.. This machine has a NIC and a hardware modem, with the modem running for years with little problems.. "Adding" PPPOE for ADSL completely upsets everything, necessitating an install of the ppp package and running pppsetup again from scratch, in order to have dial up again..
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Am I wrong?? Any comments most welcome. TIA
Hi, Hal:
You may be right or wrong, but I think you are ambiguous. :-|
More like duh!!
Quoted 9 lines
I used 'pppsetup' for a few years, then RoaringPenguin (PPPOE) a few years when I upgraded to DSL, and now I have cable modem internet access.
Both 'pppsetup' and "PPPOE" are used to connect to an
Internet Service Provider (ISP). So..."As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup setup on the same machine."
Quoted 7 lines
IMHO, is ambiguous and false. You can have both on the same machine. They may not
run concurrently unless you edit some configurations. (iptables, 'route -n',/etc/resolv, ...)
You could share (or not) your DSL connection by allowing users to dial into your
telephone modem and establish a ppp connection through (or to) your host.
I'm the only user so it should be simple, eh?? HI.. If they
both use PAP, we have a big problem with the way rp-pppoe and pppsetup works.. No work around that so far.. The automatic DNS entries overwrite and no amount futzing has fixed that so far.. If one ISP handled all it would be, maybe, easier but Verizon doesn't support POP3 and hands off all it's mail operation to either Yahoo or MSN.. I don't care to use either..
Quoted 2 lines
"completely upsets everything" IMHO, is ambiguous. Each may change (upset?)
Upset a stupid cutsie and, probably, poor metaphor.. It
doesn't work... <grin>
Quoted 3 lines
/etc/resolv, routing tables, DNS, IPTABLES, ... for the other program. ;-)Both packages perform a similar function. Connect to an ISP.
Yes but they both presume either alone and I cannot, so far,
seem to find anyway to circumvent that..
Quoted 10 lines
'pppsetup':
"... PPPsetup is a bash shell script to help you in creating a chat script, for
establising a PPP connection to a internet service provider. ..."'rp-pppoe':
"... pppoe is a user-space redirector which permits the use of PPPoE (Point-to-Point Over Ethernet) with Linux. PPPoE is used by many DSL service providers. ..." i.e. connect to an internet service proveder.
For the time being I'm going to presume I have to use pppoe
only and that works very well for Web access but sendmail and ftp are a problem.. My web site is at the same site as my mailboxes and I can web mail, no problem, but my eyes aren't that good.. I'd rather go the POP3 route that's OK with ADSL for receiving mail only using getmail.. I can sendmail to anyone on the same ISP, but nowhere else.. A DNS problem?? I guess so but no way to fix it yet.. To complicate matters my ISP insists on being a remote rather than letting me on the INet myself like I used to do.. The ADSL ISP will not talk to anyone about Linux as long as their MS stuff is working.. It's up to me to figure it out someway or another.. I may be able to do something with different partitions.. Any way it's gonna be a lot of leg work, methinks..
Quoted 5 lines
Just for grins, when I had DSL service. I dialed my '56k' modem to an ISP just to see if the DSL telephone frequencies would interfere with the telephone modem frequencies. Whilst doing a download via DSL, I dialed
and got a 49.333 kbps connection over and over and over... Which was as
fast as I ever got before DSL. :-)
Thats a good one.. Why do we like computers?? <grin> The
opposite has happened here at least for fetching mail but it could be a coincidence.. Another anomoly, here, is that my ADSL download speed hovers around 54kBps for several big file fetches, html, firefox.. I've fetched a few, same size files, via torrent and the reported download speed is 200-300kBps... Torrent should be slower than straight peer to peer I would think.. Oh well. Back to the drawing boards, eh? Thanks for your comments. It all helps.. At least, with torrent, I can keep my share over 1.0 instead of being a leech with dialup..
Signature · 7 lines
Hal. GNU/Linux -- Slackware 10.1, kernel 2.4.29 . - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-newbie" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.linux-learn.org/faqs
Topic:
As far as I can see I cannot have a pppoe setup and a dialup setup on the same machine.. It's either one or the other.. Not both.. This machine has a NIC and a hardware modem, with the modem running for years with little problems.. "Adding" PPPOE for ADSL completely upsets everything, necessitating an install of the ppp package and running pppsetup again from scratch, in order to have dial up again..
Am I wrong?? Any comments most welcome. TIA Hal. Discussion:
Sequentially or concurrently?
Hal, I do not understand why you would want two IP/ISP connections of such a huge speed difference. :-| DSL is usually about 25 times faster than dial-up. Running both would give you, perhaps, a 4% gain. Now, you would not only need a custom routing table, but you would need to configure some way to share the data transfer. I know that IP sharing exists, but not how to configure it. :-|
If I was to switch between DSL and dialup on the same host, I'd run ppp-setup,
save the ppp-go/ppp-down scripts and the current rc.local; Then
setup PPPOE and save whatever script is created. Then, create two scripts, ALA... #/usr/local/bin/makeDSL.sh
cp /etc/rc.d/rc.local.DSL /etc/rc.d/rc.local /etc/rc.d/rc.local
&
#/usr/local/bin/makeDIALUP..sh
cp /etc/rc.d/rc.local.dialup /etc/rc.d/rc.local/etc/rc.d/rc.local
HTH. <more>
Quoted 11 lines · Hal
Quoted 2 lines · Chuck Gelm
Quoted 1 line · Hal
<snip>I'm the only user so it should be simple, eh?? HI.. If they
both use PAP, we have a big problem with the way rp-pppoe and pppsetup works.. No work around that so far.. The automatic DNS entries overwrite and no amount futzing has fixed that so far.. If one ISP handled all it would be, maybe, easier but Verizon doesn't support POP3 and hands off all it's mail operation to either Yahoo or MSN.. I don't care to use either..
Hal, I'm getting lost among the pronouns. I cannot tell who is doing what, with which, nor to whom.
This may or may not be simple. I need more information to tell whether I may have the capacity to assist.
I do not know what PAP is.
If rp-pppoe (RoaringPenguin) works, we do not have a problem.
If pppsetup works, we do not have a problem.
The need or benefit of running both DSL and dialup has not been demonstrated.
I have run one ISP connection and used another's DNS. I do not see that overwriting DNS entries is a fatal problem.
"Verizon doesn't support POP3"
Uh, I do not see why you put DSL/dialup and POP in the same sentence.
I have used POP with dialup, DSL, & cable modem.
What is the core issue here? Verizon-dialup?; Verizon DSL? Your Verizon-DSL account does not offer POP?
Who is your DSL ISP provider?
Who is your dialup ISP provider?
<snip>
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Both packages perform a similar function. Connect to an ISP.
Yes but they both presume either alone and I cannot, so far,
seem to find anyway to circumvent that..
It is illogical, to me, to use both DSL and dialup. Why do you wish both? What benefit?
<snip>
Quoted 5 lines
For the time being I'm going to presume I have to use pppoe
only and that works very well for Web access but sendmail and ftp are a problem. My web site is at the same site as my mailboxes and I can web mail, no problem, but my eyes aren't that good.. I'd rather go the POP3 route that's OK with ADSL for receiving mail only using
Quoted 8 lines
getmail.. I can sendmail to anyone on the same ISP, but nowhere else.. A DNS problem?? I guess so but no way to fix it yet.. To complicate matters my ISP insists on being a remote rather than letting me on the INet myself like I used to do.. The ADSL ISP will not talk to anyone about Linux as long as their MS stuff is working.. It's up to me to figure it out someway or another.. I may be able to do something with different partitions.. Any way it's gonna be a lot of leg work, methinks..
"but sendmail and ftp are a problem"
Would you be more specific? Exact error message?
My website is the same as my mailboxes and I can POP and SMTP and web mail, no problem. I''ve never had a problem with this nomatter whether I was using dialup, DSL, or cable modem. :-|
" I can sendmail to anyone on the same ISP, but nowhere
Quoted 1 line
else.. A DNS problem?? "
Exact error message?
"The ADSL ISP will not talk to anyone about Linux as long as their MS stuff is working.."
Uh huh. Neither will mine. I did not use any Micro$oft stuff when I had dialup nor DSL ISP (and not now with my cable modem). ?
"It's up to me to figure it out someway or another."
I disagree. You have [email protected] to assist.
You only need to share more information that will help us assist you. ;-)
So, you are actually having problems sending email
and you are assuming that using dialup and DSL concurrently
is a solution. :-| Perhaps not. Perhaps one does not get down from an elephant(*). ;-)
Perhaps a new topic should be started, ala;
"Does Verizon-DSL support POP3?"
Regards, Chuck
(*) Sorry, this may not translate internationally.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-newbie" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.linux-learn.org/faqs