Skip to contentSkip to conversation

mlmmj bug with qmail+vpopmail

DISCUSSION Alexander Kardailsky 3 participants 5 messages Jul 21, 2007 – Jul 25, 2007

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Dear mlmmj,

Just installed the latest version of the mlmmj on freebsd 6.1 box and tried to work with it. I created test list sw-test and configured .qmail-sw-test and .qmail-sw-test-default files. Subscription was ok. However, when I tried to send email to the list I got the following error:
listcontrol.c:740: Unknown command "test". Ignoring mail: Unknown error: 0 Anyone else has such problem?

Signature · 2 lines
Best regards,
 Alexander                          
#1 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Alexander Kardailsky

Dear mlmmj,

Just installed the latest version of the mlmmj on freebsd 6.1 box and tried to work with it. I created test list sw-test and configured .qmail-sw-test and .qmail-sw-test-default files. Subscription was ok. However, when I tried to send email to the list I got the following error:
listcontrol.c:740: Unknown command "test". Ignoring mail: Unknown error: 0 Anyone else has such problem?

First of all, you shouldn't use vpopmail, it's simply useless (unless you like it's stupid multiple flat password file thing), a bare qmail has virtual users integrated.

Thomas

#2 lore raw
In reply to Alexander Kardailsky

Dear Alexander,

Quoted 9 lines · you

Dear mlmmj,

Just installed the latest version of the mlmmj on freebsd 6.1 box and tried to work with it. I created test list sw-test and configured .qmail-sw-test and .qmail-sw-test-default files. Subscription was ok. However, when I tried to send email to the list I got the following error:
listcontrol.c:740: Unknown command "test". Ignoring mail: Unknown error: 0 Anyone else has such problem?

I think I fixed that problem. I've added one more check in mlmmj-process.c :

- } else if(dtemails.emailcount >= 1) {

+  } else if(dtemails.emailcount >= 1 && strcmp(dtemails.emaillist[0], getlistaddr(listdir)) != 0) {
    /* parse the (first) Delivered-To: header */
    recipextra = recipient_extra(listdir, dtemails.emaillist[0]);
-  } else if(toemails.emailcount >= 1) {
+  } else if(toemails.emailcount >= 1 && strcmp(toemails.emaillist[0], getlistaddr(listdir)) != 0) {
    /* parse the (first) To: header */

I think there is no needed recipextra in case mailing list name and To: or Delivered-To: addresses are equals.

Signature · 2 lines
Best regards,
 Alexander
#3 lore raw
In reply to Alexander Kardailsky

Hi Alexander,

Quoted 1 line · Alexander Kardailsky
Quoted 1 line

configured .qmail-sw-test and .qmail-sw-test-default files.

[snip]

Quoted 6 lines

I think I fixed that problem. I've added one more check in mlmmj-process.c :

(quoted diff) +1 -1
-  } else if(dtemails.emailcount >= 1) {
+  } else if(dtemails.emailcount >= 1 && strcmp(dtemails.emaillist[0],

getlistaddr(listdir)) != 0) {

[snip]

Quoted 2 lines

I think there is no needed recipextra in case mailing list name and To: or Delivered-To: addresses are equals.

It is true that the parsing is not needed, but I can not see how your patch fixes anything.

Your delivery agent should set one of the DEFAULT, EXTENSION or LOCAL_PART_SUFFIX environment variables. If it does not, mlmmj parses the headers in an attempt to find the envelope to address anyway. This is a fall back. Don't rely on it. There is - as far as I can see - no way it can parse the address if the address itself contains the delimiter.

test-foo-bar <-- is it test-foo with extension bar or test with extension foo-bar? Only the mail server can tell.

Without your patch:
test -> test / NULL
test-foo -> test / foo
test-foo-bar -> test / foo-bar

With your patch:
test -> test / NULL
test-foo -> test-foo / NULL
test-foo-bar -> test / foo-bar

See the problem?

You have two options here:
- use a delivery agent which reveals the envelope information
- use an address without the delimiter embedded

Morten

Signature · 2 lines
Morten K. Poulsen <[email protected]>
http://www.afdelingp.dk/
#4 lore raw
In reply to Alexander Kardailsky

Hi Alexander,

Quoted 6 lines · Alexander Kardailsky
Quoted 1 line

See the problem?

Not sure.
test-foo ->> test-foo / NULL
This is only if your mailing list have this address test-foo@ If it has different one there would be test / foo

Yes. But all of this is only a problem if you are using the delimiter *in* the address. Your list is IIRC called test-sw and you are using a dash as delimiter.

With your patch [email protected] will not be parsed. However [email protected] will still be parsed. And it will be parsed into test / sw-faq. Mlmmj will then reject that mail, because there is no "sw-faq" command. If you were using + as delimiter it would not be a problem:
[email protected] is unambiguous.

Quoted 3 lines

It doesn't matter what you have test-'foo-bar' or test-foo-'bar' because there is comparison with mailing
list address.

The patch fixes the case where there is no extension. But as far as I can see it will fail with one. Maybe I am wrong, but please explain how your patch will make mlmmj parse [email protected] into test-sw / faq.

You could change recipient_extra() to look for the list's address in the beginning of the given address, but consider this case: A list has two names (yes, mlmmj supports this) [email protected] and [email protected]. How do you parse [email protected]?

Morten

Signature · 2 lines
Morten K. Poulsen <[email protected]>
http://www.afdelingp.dk/