BIOS implementors disabling the LAPIC
I have several systems here where Linux tells me:
Local APIC disabled by BIOS -- you can enable it with "lapic"
As far as I understand, the Local APIC was integrated directly to the CPU 12-15 years ago. Why would a BIOS implementor choose to disable it?
(And what does it mean to "disable" the LAPIC?)
Note: the motherboard does not provide an IO-APIC.
I've ask the kernel to re-enable the LAPIC, and was able to use OProfile in hardware counter mode, i.e. it seems to work fine.
Regards.
Quoted 2 lines · John Sigler
As far as I understand, the Local APIC was integrated directly to the CPU 12-15 years ago. Why would a BIOS implementor choose to disable it?
Because they are lazy/incapable/out-of-time/select-your-favourite-excuse.
For the chip to work you have to provide some minimal support in the firmware, in particular for the trickier paths of execution in the system management mode. The system still works with the Local APIC disabled, so why bother?
Quoted 1 line
(And what does it mean to "disable" the LAPIC?)
The LINT0 and LINT1 inputs of the APIC are routed straight to the INT and
NMI inputs of the CPU respectively and the rest of the APIC logic becomes inactive (tri-stated, etc.).
Maciej
Quoted 10 lines · Maciej W. Rozycki
Quoted 2 lines · John Sigler
As far as I understand, the Local APIC was integrated directly to the CPU 12-15 years ago. Why would a BIOS implementor choose to disable it?
Because they are lazy/incapable/out-of-time/select-your-favourite-excuse. For the chip to work you have to provide some minimal support in the firmware, in particular for the trickier paths of execution in the system management mode. The system still works with the Local APIC disabled, so why bother?
The motherboard manufacturer (well, their level 1 support, anyway) told me I could "safely enable the LAPIC". If it is safe to enable the LAPIC, then why are they disabling it in the BIOS? (They weren't able to tell me whether their BIOS triggers SMIs or not...)
Is this a "either works or doesn't" situation where hell should break loose if I try to enable the LAPIC and it's not supported by the motherboard, or is this a "you will silently lose data at the worst possible time" situation?
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line
(And what does it mean to "disable" the LAPIC?)
The LINT0 and LINT1 inputs of the APIC are routed straight to the INT and NMI inputs of the CPU respectively and the rest of the APIC logic becomes inactive (tri-stated, etc.).
If that were the case, then I could not enable the LAPIC and have NMIs work, right?
Regards.
Quoted 4 lines · John Sigler
The motherboard manufacturer (well, their level 1 support, anyway) told me I could "safely enable the LAPIC". If it is safe to enable the LAPIC, then why are they disabling it in the BIOS? (They weren't able to tell me whether their BIOS triggers SMIs or not...)
Ask them.
Quoted 3 lines
Is this a "either works or doesn't" situation where hell should break loose if I try to enable the LAPIC and it's not supported by the motherboard, or is this a "you will silently lose data at the worst possible time" situation?
It could be either. For example some IBM hardware used to be known to
have problems, like the 8254 timer freezing occasionally, when the APIC was used and the NMI watchdog enabled. On some laptops you would get an instant hard lockup if you enabled the APIC and used one of the special key combinations (whether on purpose or by chance) used to adjust display brightness, etc..
Quoted 2 lines
If that were the case, then I could not enable the LAPIC and have NMIs work, right?
It depends on what you want to use NMIs for. For their PC/AT compatible
purpose, that is reporting of memory parity/ECC and bus errors, it works in either mode. For any other purpose you need an APIC.
Maciej