how does grub exactly work?
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
Quoted 2 lines · Andreas Jellinghaus
Hi Edward,
Hello.
Quoted 13 lines
I saw your mail on btrfs ml with the grub patches and the notes how to deal with btrfs.
can you explain how grub and btrfs work exactly?
I read the grub manual at
http://www.gnu.org/software/grub/manual/html_node/Bootstrap-
tricks.html#Bootstrap-tricksso I wonder: does btrfs provide a "boot loader area" similar to ffs and reiserfs, where grub places the stage 1.5 code and stage 1 can read it?
Yes.
Quoted 5 lines
or does grub find out the sectors of the stage 1.5 file and put the list of those into the stage 1 file (first sector address of stage 1.5 file) and stage 1.5 first sector (list of all other sectors)?
Grub doesn't make the blocklist for stage1_5
Optionally grub makes the blocklist for stage2 (in particular when stage1.5 can not be embedded for some reasons).
Note, that it is important to embed and use btrfs_stage1_5. First, because btrfs has defragmentator, which can make the blocklist out of date (so that you'll need to reinstall grub). Second, I am not sure, if the blocklist will be composed correctly in the case when stage2 locates in btrfs volume (I didn't look at the blocklist specification: it can happen that grub installer makes an assumption that all sectors of stage2 locate on the same device).
Quoted 9 lines
and what would be the proper way to make boot from a raid1 device? so that if one disk fails the other can boot?
device (hd0)/dev/sda
root (hd0,X) setup (hd0)device (hd0)
/dev/sdb
root (hd0,X)
setup (hd0)
Perhaps, it will work. But officially grub doesn't understand software raid, and I am not familiar with raid1 specifications, so... ;)
Quoted 16 lines
if data is written to mbr only and the sectors between mbr and the first partition, this could work. but if data is written to mbr and to btrfs (either a "boot loader area" or changes to the stage 1.5 file), then that data can only contain the valid block lists for one of the two hard disks - which shouldn't be a problem if drives are the same and have 100% the same geometry and partitioning.
so I wonder, and it would be great if thise fine details would be documented for btrfs somewhere, as there is very little information about them (the situation isn't better with other filesystems either).
thanks for your help!
Regards, Andreas