Skip to contentSkip to conversation

codeBeamer MR - Easy ACL for Git

ANNOUNCE Intland Software 8 participants 17 messages Jun 15, 2016 1 message not in the archive

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

codeBeamer MR is a new tool for teams working with Git, and striving for fast repository management and easy access control management. Setting up and maintaining ACL on top of Git is not trivial. With this web based tool, you can *save a lot of boring and error-prone maintainenace work*, and spend your time rather with coding.

FEATURES
* Starts and close projects and repositories in just seconds
* Project-, group-, and role-based administration across multiple repositories
* ACL on directory level
* SSH authentication
* Lightweight wiki, issue tracking and project management facilities
* Web based
* Remote API

PRICE?
It is *free* (as in beer). No expiration.

LEARN MORE & DOWNLOAD
More details, screenshots and downloads:
http://www.intland.com/products/cb-mr/overview.html

#1 lore raw
Quoted 15 lines · Intland Software

codeBeamer MR is a new tool for teams working with Git, and striving for fast repository management and easy access control management. Setting up and maintaining ACL on top of Git is not trivial. With this web based tool, you can *save a lot of boring and error-prone maintainenace work*, and spend your time rather with coding.

FEATURES
* Starts and close projects and repositories in just seconds
* Project-, group-, and role-based administration across multiple repositories
* ACL on directory level
* SSH authentication
* Lightweight wiki, issue tracking and project management facilities
* Web based
* Remote API

Quoted 6 lines

PRICE?
It is *free* (as in beer). No expiration.

LEARN MORE & DOWNLOAD
More details, screenshots and downloads:
http://www.intland.com/products/cb-mr/overview.html

Interesting, thank you for the announcement; it would be good to note that it's not open-source.

I think a lot of people wonder now, how does this compare to existing solutions; from your announcement I thought it's something like Gitosis/Gitolite, but in fact it seems more similar to Gitorious or GitHub (if it was publicly available, of course); perhaps it would be good idea to present comparison to these on the project homepage.

Signature · 3 lines
				Petr "Pasky" Baudis
A lot of people have my books on their bookshelves.
That's the problem, they need to read them. -- Don Knuth
#2 lore raw

Thanks for your comments, Petr.

Quoted 6 lines · Petr Baudis
Quoted 3 lines

LEARN MORE & DOWNLOAD
More details, screenshots and downloads:
http://www.intland.com/products/cb-mr/overview.html

Interesting, thank you for the announcement; it would be good to note that it's not open-source.

That's right, codeBeamer MR is not open source.
More precisely: parts of the source code are actually open, including
the wiki plugins and the remote clients, for instance. The core source is closed, because the same core is also used in our commercial offerings, and our commercial license doesn't (currently) allow publishing the complete code. We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything ;)

We are currently in the midst of rethinking our licensing scheme
in general, to make things more liberal or to set up some kind of a dual license.

Quoted 5 lines

I think a lot of people wonder now, how does this compare to existing solutions; from your announcement I thought it's something like Gitosis/Gitolite, but in fact it seems more similar to Gitorious or GitHub (if it was publicly available, of course); perhaps it would be good idea to present comparison to these on the project homepage.

Good point. More on this later.
---
Intland

#3 lore raw

11/18/2009 04:19 PM, Intland Software::

Quoted 2 lines

We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything

I think they are just dumb.
But they pay you, so let's just say it's OK. :-)

Signature · 3 lines
      Architecte Informatique chez Blueline/Gulfsat:
   Administration Systeme, Recherche & Developpement
                                   +261 33 11 207 36
#4 lore raw
In reply to Intland Software
Quoted 6 lines · Intland Software

More precisely: parts of the source code are actually open, including the wiki plugins and the remote clients, for instance. The core source is closed, because the same core is also used in our commercial offerings, and our commercial license doesn't (currently) allow publishing the complete code. We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything ;)

are you sure? did you see the recent memo about OpenSource by the DOD?

David Lang

Quoted 17 lines

We are currently in the midst of rethinking our licensing scheme in general, to make things more liberal or to set up some kind of a dual license.

Quoted 5 lines

I think a lot of people wonder now, how does this compare to existing solutions; from your announcement I thought it's something like Gitosis/Gitolite, but in fact it seems more similar to Gitorious or GitHub (if it was publicly available, of course); perhaps it would be good idea to present comparison to these on the project homepage.

Good point. More on this later.
---
Intland
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

#5 lore raw

Hey David,

Quoted 6 lines · [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 3 lines

our commercial license doesn't (currently) allow publishing the complete code. We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything ;)

are you sure? did you see the recent memo about OpenSource by the DOD? David Lang

Can you direct us to an URL please? Thanks.
---
Intland

#6 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Intland Software
Quoted 6 lines · [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 3 lines

our commercial license doesn't (currently) allow publishing the complete code. We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything ;)

are you sure? did you see the recent memo about OpenSource by the DOD?

Can you direct us to an URL please? Thanks.

Indirect links:
* "New DoD memo on Open Source Software" (David A. Wheeler)
http://www.dwheeler.com/blog/2009/10/27/#dod-oss-2009
* "Notes about the DoD and OSS memo" (David A. Wheeler)
http://www.dwheeler.com/blog/2009/10/28/#dod-oss-2009-notes

Signature · 3 lines
Jakub Narebski
Poland
ShadeHawk on #git
#7 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Jakub Narebski
Quoted 7 lines · Intland Software
Quoted 5 lines · [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 3 lines

our commercial license doesn't (currently) allow publishing the complete code. We have quite some large customers from the defense space that would not be happy if we opened everything ;)

are you sure? did you see the recent memo about OpenSource by the DOD?

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line

Can you direct us to an URL please? Thanks.

Indirect links:
* "New DoD memo on Open Source Software" (David A. Wheeler)
http://www.dwheeler.com/blog/2009/10/27/#dod-oss-2009
* "Notes about the DoD and OSS memo" (David A. Wheeler)
http://www.dwheeler.com/blog/2009/10/28/#dod-oss-2009-notes

Hmm, very interesting reading! Thanks a lot.
---
Intland

#8 lore raw
In reply to Petr Baudis
Quoted 4 lines · Petr Baudis

I think a lot of people wonder now, how does this compare to existing solutions; from your announcement I thought it's something like Gitosis/Gitolite, but in fact it seems more similar to Gitorious or GitHub (if it was publicly available, of course); perhaps it would be

All right, some quick comparisons with codeBeamer Managed Repository (MR).

* MR against Gitosis
In terms of access control, MR has the concept of "role", and it makes our security model more fine grained. Permissions can be set by role. One user account can have multiple roles. Roles are project-dependent. When you add a group to a project, you can assign multiple roles to the group (which is equivalent with assigning those roles to each group member one by one). On the other hand, MR has a much broader scope than Gitosis. MR helps you to manage your repos, to track your tasks/bugs/issues, to follow commit activities, to browse repos in the web, can be extended using its APIs, etc. (And you don't have to install and maintain Git extensions for this.)

* MR against Gitolite
Pretty much the same applies here as well.

* MR against GitHub & Gitorious
Probably the most significant difference is that MR is available as free download, and can run behind your firewall.
MR was derived from the source code of our commercial product codeBeamer. CodeBeamer is a full-blown enterprise collaboration solution, thus MR is likely to focus more on the enterprise needs, not on the "social" aspect.

A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]

#12 lore raw
In reply to Intland Software
Quoted 10 lines · Intland Software
Quoted 5 lines · Petr Baudis

I think a lot of people wonder now, how does this compare to existing solutions; from your announcement I thought it's something like Gitosis/Gitolite, but in fact it seems more similar to Gitorious or GitHub (if it was publicly available, of course); perhaps it would be

All right, some quick comparisons with codeBeamer Managed Repository (MR).

* MR against Gitosis

I think you meant "versus" :-)

Quoted 10 lines

In terms of access control, MR has the concept of "role", and it makes our security model more fine grained. Permissions can be set by role. One user account can have multiple roles. Roles are project-dependent. When you add a group to a project, you can assign multiple roles to the group (which is equivalent with assigning those roles to each group member one by one). On the other hand, MR has a much broader scope than Gitosis. MR helps you to manage your repos, to track your tasks/bugs/issues, to follow commit activities, to browse repos in the web, can be extended using its APIs, etc. (And you don't have to install and maintain Git extensions for this.)

Quoted 2 lines

* MR against Gitolite
Pretty much the same applies here as well.

Conceptually, gitolite can do the roles stuff you mentioned, if I understood it correctly. Of course, gitolite's access config is in plain text.

The web-based control, issue tracking, etc., are all on a different plane from what gitosis/gitolite aim to be. So much so that I might even disagree with Pasky on the need to mention these two products in your website. Here's one perspective (in round figures):

gitolite:   1600 lines of shell+perl, 1600 lines of doc
gitosis:    3300 lines of python
MR:         150 MB binary download

I don't honestly see any way to even *begin* to compare :-)

You should stick to gitorious, github, and -- here's a new one for you -- indefero.

Signature · 1 line
Sitaram
#13 lore raw

Hi!

Quoted 4 lines · Sitaram Chamarty
Quoted 2 lines · Intland Software

* MR against Gitolite
Pretty much the same applies here as well.

Quoted 8 lines

Conceptually, gitolite can do the roles stuff you mentioned, if I understood it correctly. Of course, gitolite's access config is in plain text.

The web-based control, issue tracking, etc., are all on a different plane from what gitosis/gitolite aim to be. So much so that I might even disagree with Pasky on the need to mention these two products in your website.

I brought Gitosis/Gitolite up because I got the impression that MR was marketed primarily as a Git ACL tool, the other things being sort of mirror; maybe my impession was wrong, but I still think the comparison in ACL capabilities is useful.

Quoted 2 lines

You should stick to gitorious, github, and -- here's a new one for you -- indefero.

Hmm, I didn't even know about this one, thanks for the pointer. Looks like this suddenly is a very popular area. High competition is good!

(BTW, if you don't care about wikis and issue tracking, but you do care about simplicity and light-weightness, you should best stick to Girocco! ;-)

Signature · 3 lines
				Petr "Pasky" Baudis
A lot of people have my books on their bookshelves.
That's the problem, they need to read them. -- Don Knuth
#14 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Petr Baudis

Looks like this suddenly is a very popular area. High competition is good!

Absolutely agreed!
---
Intland

#15 lore raw
In reply to Petr Baudis
Quoted 4 lines · Petr Baudis

I brought Gitosis/Gitolite up because I got the impression that MR was marketed primarily as a Git ACL tool, the other things being sort of mirror; maybe my impession was wrong, but I still think the comparison in ACL capabilities is useful.

Sorry; didn't mean to imply you were wrong about that...

But the bulk of MR is probably the web based stuff, wiki, issues etc., which means gitolite is way on the other side of the spectrum, so it felt like any comparision is moot, and used the code/binary sizes to highlight that.

But you said just the ACL capabilities... set me thinking...

Intland: do you have a page that describes your role based ACL stuff a little more? I have a feeling that, modulo it all being in one text file, gitolite can probably come close :-)

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

You should stick to gitorious, github, and -- here's a new one for you -- indefero.

Hmm, I didn't even know about this one, thanks for the pointer. Looks like this suddenly is a very popular area. High competition is good!

Oh yeah, and indefero is actually looking pretty good -- I know some guys at $DAYJOB looking at it very seriously.

Quoted 3 lines

(BTW, if you don't care about wikis and issue tracking, but you do care about simplicity and light-weightness, you should best stick to Girocco! ;-)

:-) yes it is nice, but again, at $DAYJOB access control (even to view projects) is a big deal. A very big deal, actually...!

#16 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines · Sitaram Chamarty

Intland: do you have a page that describes your role based ACL stuff a little more?

This is a good starting point in our Knowledge Base, to read more about
the permission model used in MR:

https://codebeamer.com/cb/wiki/11121

Signature · 3 lines
 Intland Team
 Follow @intland on Twitter: http://twitter.com/intland
 Find codeBeamer on Facebook: http://bit.ly/rcTuX
#17 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Intland Software
Quoted 3 lines · Sitaram Chamarty

Intland: do you have a page that describes your role based ACL stuff a little more?

This is a good starting point in our Knowledge Base, to read more about
the permission model used in MR:

https://codebeamer.com/cb/wiki/11121

Thanks; I've read through that and the link to "Working Sets".

Modulo a bunch of *big* differences [*] in scale and scope between gitolite and MR, I'm fairly certain that working sets (groups of projects), user roles, user groups, etc., can all be done using gitolite's group mechanism and its delegation feature.

It won't be as refined and nuanced as in MR, but in the main, maintainable access control, which is the main point of all those features, can be done.

Signature · 12 lines
Sitaram


[*] these big differences are:

  - gitolite config is all in one text file versus whatever MR uses
    internally
  - gitolite only deals with the git repo for each project; MR does with
    all sorts of stuff outside the actual code repo
  - gitolite has no UI for the end user, MR clearly does, and the user
    can do a lot of stuff by themselves (like create new projects)
  - possibly many more I missed