Losing one of various PVs in VG
Hi all,
I am planning our new storage system.
I would like the ability to migrate LVs between the various RAID arrays we have. This would require we have a PV per array and all PVs under the same VG.
Now I'm wondering what happens if we lose an array: all data on all arrays will be lost because the VG is lost?
I did spot one way to prevent this:
I could create one VG per PV, then just before the migration I would do vgmerge between the two VGs source and destination, then perform migration of the LV with pvmove, then wait for it to complete (by not sending it to background probably), then do vgsplit to return to initial condition.
It's quite complex and unconvenient though. Also if I forget to wait completion for pvmove and/or I forget to do vgsplit, and then one of the two array fails, I would probably lose data from both.
What do you suggest?
Thanks for your help
Quoted 2 lines · Spelic
Now I'm wondering what happens if we lose an array: all data on all arrays will be lost because the VG is lost?
No.
If you use LVM level raid0 (striping) on a particular LV, then losing any component of the stripe will lose the LV (but not the VG).
If you use LVM level raid1 (mirroring) on a particular LV, then losing any component of the mirror does not lose the LV (or the VG).
For linear LVs (extents on minimum number of PVs), losing a PV used by the LV will lose the LV, but not the VG.
You do not gain anything by assigning a separate VG to each array - unless you want to be able to easily remove the array.
Signature · 4 lines
Stuart D. Gathman <[email protected]> Business Management Systems Inc. Phone: 703 591-0911 Fax: 703 591-6154 "Confutatis maledictis, flammis acribus addictis" - background song for a Microsoft sponsored "Where do you want to go from here?" commercial.