Skip to contentSkip to conversation

busybox & update-alternatives

DISCUSSION Gary Thomas 5 participants 10 messages Feb 11, 2011 – Feb 12, 2011

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

A build for my platform with today's master
49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Thanks

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Signature · 2 lines
Tom Rini
Mentor Graphics Corporation
#2 lore raw
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r <root>] <basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by
commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
Author: Mark Hatle <[email protected]>
Date: Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
#3 lore raw
Quoted 32 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r <root>] <basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Quoted 8 lines

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by
commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
Author: Mark Hatle <[email protected]>
Date: Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

--Mark

#4 lore raw
Quoted 39 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 38 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r <root>] <basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by
commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
Author: Mark Hatle <[email protected]>
Date: Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Mark, any comments?

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

I asked and it appears there is a limitation of one initscript per split package. So as a workaround, I suggest removing the busybox-udhcpc from the INITSCRIPTS_NAME_${PN} line..

--Mark

Quoted 8 lines

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

--Mark
_______________________________________________
poky mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.yoctoproject.org/listinfo/poky

#5 lore raw

Op 11 feb 2011, om 19:37 heeft Mark Hatle het volgende geschreven:

Quoted 43 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 42 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 40 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 14 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 5 lines

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r <root>] <basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by
commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
Author: Mark Hatle <[email protected]>
Date: Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

I asked and it appears there is a limitation of one initscript per split package. So as a workaround, I suggest removing the busybox-udhcpc from the INITSCRIPTS_NAME_${PN} line..

If you use update-rc.bbclass, yes. But that class is only a few lines, easy enough to copy it into the recipe and do multiple initscripts. There are a number of recipes in OE doing that.

regards,

Koen

#6 lore raw
In reply to Mark Hatle
Quoted 43 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 42 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 40 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r<root>]<basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by

    commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
    Author: Mark Hatle<[email protected]>
    Date:   Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

I asked and it appears there is a limitation of one initscript per split package. So as a workaround, I suggest removing the busybox-udhcpc from the INITSCRIPTS_NAME_${PN} line..

The attached patch looks like it does the right thing. Any reason it's not the way to fix this?

Quoted 5 lines

--Mark

Quoted 2 lines

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
meta/classes/update-rc.d.bbclass +9 -3
index 7e4dda7..3647cb4 100644
@@ -15,17 +15,23 @@ if test "x$D" != "x"; then
 else
 	OPT="-s"
 fi
-update-rc.d $OPT ${INITSCRIPT_NAME} ${INITSCRIPT_PARAMS}
+for i in ${INITSCRIPT_NAME}; do
+  update-rc.d $OPT $i ${INITSCRIPT_PARAMS}
+done
 }
 
 updatercd_prerm() {
 if test "x$D" = "x"; then
-	${INIT_D_DIR}/${INITSCRIPT_NAME} stop
+  for i in ${INITSCRIPT_NAME}; do
+	${INIT_D_DIR}/$i stop
+  done
 fi
 }
 
 updatercd_postrm() {
-update-rc.d $D ${INITSCRIPT_NAME} remove
+for i in ${INITSCRIPT_NAME}; do
+  update-rc.d $D $i remove
+done
 }
 
 
#7 lore raw
Quoted 49 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 48 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 46 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 32 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r<root>]<basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Quoted 8 lines

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by

    commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
    Author: Mark Hatle<[email protected]>
    Date:   Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I asked and it appears there is a limitation of one initscript per split package. So as a workaround, I suggest removing the busybox-udhcpc from the INITSCRIPTS_NAME_${PN} line..

The attached patch looks like it does the right thing. Any reason it's not the way to fix this?

That patch should work fine. Only concern is if you have multiple initscripts with different params.. how do you reconcile that. (Simplest answer for me would be ${INITSCRIPT_PARAMS_name} --- but I'm guessing that might clash with the package names and cause other problems.

I'm exploring adding a -sysroot as well as -udhcpc split package. But so far I'm not having much success getting the semantics right....

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines

--Mark

Quoted 2 lines

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

#8 lore raw
Quoted 57 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 49 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 48 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 46 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 32 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r<root>]<basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN]
update-rc.d [-n] [-r<root>] [-s]<basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Quoted 8 lines

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by

     commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
     Author: Mark Hatle<[email protected]>
     Date:   Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Mark, any comments?

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I asked and it appears there is a limitation of one initscript per split package. So as a workaround, I suggest removing the busybox-udhcpc from the INITSCRIPTS_NAME_${PN} line..

The attached patch looks like it does the right thing. Any reason it's not the way to fix this?

Quoted 7 lines

That patch should work fine. Only concern is if you have multiple initscripts with different params.. how do you reconcile that. (Simplest answer for me would be ${INITSCRIPT_PARAMS_name} --- but I'm guessing that might clash with the package names and cause other problems.

I'm exploring adding a -sysroot as well as -udhcpc split package. But so far I'm not having much success getting the semantics right....

Since you're working on this, I'll leave the final solution to you :-)

I have a [temporary] solution for now.

Thanks

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines

--Mark

Quoted 2 lines

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

Signature · 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------
Gary Thomas                 |  Consulting for the
MLB Associates              |    Embedded world
------------------------------------------------------------
#9 lore raw
In reply to Mark Hatle
Quoted 39 lines · Mark Hatle
Quoted 38 lines · Gary Thomas
Quoted 14 lines · Tom Rini
Quoted 5 lines · Gary Thomas

A build for my platform with today's master 49a18f1748d2417958b8e19cdd58c0c79f4fc728
shows a new behaviour - many messages like this:
update-alternatives: Linking //usr/bin/wc to ../../bin/busybox

Quoted 7 lines

Questions:
* Is this truly new or was it just quiet before?
* Can't this be done at image build time? On my little embedded OMAP-L138, it takes nearly 2 minutes to run through this. My root is a ramdisk, so this is a cost I see on _every_ boot.
* If it can't be done at build time, can I disable it?

Quoted 4 lines

It can be done at build time _except_ for when there's a conflict. I suspect what's going on is that a recent change has introduced a conflict (which is to say, busybox provides foo as an alternative and something else also provides it, but isn't registering it as an alternative). If you check the whole boot log (or log.do_rootfs) you can find where the conflict is and then do something like http://cgit.openembedded.org/cgit.cgi/openembedded/commit/?id=902b98f32ffd35661e43382f47226f65528ff1b1 (it's a little more complicated if the recipe also does BBCLASSEXTEND, since you don't want to do the move for virtclass-foo).

Running the postinst script manually, I get this error:

+ update-rc.d -s syslog busybox-udhcpc defaults
usage: update-rc.d [-n] [-f] [-r <root>] <basename> remove
update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> defaults [NN | sNN kNN] update-rc.d [-n] [-r <root>] [-s] <basename> start|stop NN runlvl [runlvl] [...] .
-n: not really
-f: force
-v: verbose
-r: alternate root path (default is /)
-s: invoke start methods if appropriate to current runlevel

Looks like update-rc.d is not being called properly. This was introduced by
commit 427472e980cd6254a5e4ef37209b327e15af259b
Author: Mark Hatle <[email protected]>
Date: Thu Feb 3 19:29:50 2011 -0600

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Mark, any comments?

The error is coming from the INITSCRIPT_NAME_${PN} change. However, I don't know how to resolve it. Where there was previously only one init script, there are now two. So how do we inform bitbake that there are two initscripts to be processed?

customize update-rc.d class functionality in recipe

Quoted 9 lines

(If specifying more then one initscript is correct in the recipe, then the bug is in a class wherever update-rc.d is called.)

--Mark
_______________________________________________
poky mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.yoctoproject.org/listinfo/poky