HBA Adaptor Advice
Getting back on track of specific adaptor advice:
To recap: I am looking for ideas on what to buy to upgrade our small office servers (not really stretched, just adding more backup disks and similar). My main requirement is to be able to buy equipment in single lots (one server at a time) and so I require the ability to take an array from one machine and use it in another machine using a different adaptor - therefore the previous thread has dissuaded me from looking at adaptors with writeback cache (and also hardware raid controllers)
Therefore can I see a show of hands for "good value" HBA adaptors with 8, 12 and 24 ports? Ideally using fewer PCI slots is preferred and onboard expanders rather than separate expanders are preferred
Seems that previously we discovered that most LSI RAID cards were well supported and Marvel cards were frequently not. Does this generalisation persist with pure HBA cards also?
I can see the list of LSI HBA cards on their site, but any pointers for good value HBA adaptors appreciated? (Current chassis will be a tower chassic, but future upgrades are expected to be Supermicro/Norco 3/4U rack boxes)
(is there a page on the wiki already covering any of this that we could try and distil this wisdom to?)
Thanks
Ed W
Quoted 10 lines · Ed W
Getting back on track of specific adaptor advice:
To recap: I am looking for ideas on what to buy to upgrade our small office servers (not really stretched, just adding more backup disks and similar). My main requirement is to be able to buy equipment in single lots (one server at a time) and so I require the ability to take an array from one machine and use it in another machine using a different adaptor - therefore the previous thread has dissuaded me from looking at adaptors with writeback cache (and also hardware raid controllers)
Quoted 3 lines
Therefore can I see a show of hands for "good value" HBA adaptors with 8, 12 and 24 ports? Ideally using fewer PCI slots is preferred and onboard expanders rather than separate expanders are preferred
Be aware that this won't be cheap. Also be aware that many (most) expandor designs are performance limited due to their implementations. We see significant contention from bandwidth oversubscription in every day situations, regardless where the expandor is.
On the HBA side
On the hardware RAID side of this:
LSI controllers as HBAs are reasonably good. Make sure you update your drivers and firmware to late revisions.
Quoted 10 lines
Seems that previously we discovered that most LSI RAID cards were well supported and Marvel cards were frequently not. Does this generalisation persist with pure HBA cards also?
I can see the list of LSI HBA cards on their site, but any pointers for good value HBA adaptors appreciated? (Current chassis will be a tower chassic, but future upgrades are expected to be Supermicro/Norco 3/4U rack boxes)
(is there a page on the wiki already covering any of this that we could try and distil this wisdom to?)
Don't skimp on power supply, or power distribution. RAIDs hate that.
Don't skimp on cooling. Drives hate that.
Regards,
Joe
Signature · 9 lines
Joseph Landman, Ph.D Founder and CEO Scalable Informatics, Inc. email: [email protected] web : http://scalableinformatics.com http://scalableinformatics.com/sicluster phone: +1 734 786 8423 x121 fax : +1 866 888 3112 cell : +1 734 612 4615